Orthodoxia

Faith & Evidence / Crucifixion and resurrection

What is the difference between early resurrection belief and evidence for resurrection?

IntermediateHistoricalAnswer available

Revision 1, updated

The answer

Early belief is real evidence, and it points to the resurrection. In 1 Corinthians, written in the mid-50s, St Paul the Apostle hands on a message he had himself received: Jesus died, was buried, was raised on the third day and appeared to named people, many of them still alive. Such a belief, held so early, so firmly and at such cost, needs a cause. Grief, legend and fraud do not explain it; the risen Lord does. The Coptic Orthodox Church confesses the resurrection on the testimony of the apostles, and the historical evidence stands with that testimony.

  • St Paul's first letter to the Corinthians, from the mid-50s AD, hands on a message about Jesus' death, burial, resurrection and appearances that St Paul says he received.
  • The core of that message goes back to the first years after the crucifixion; St Paul met St Peter and James in Jerusalem within a few years of his conversion.
  • The apostles did not only believe early; they named witnesses who could be questioned, and they proclaimed the message in the city where it could be tested.
  • St Paul hands on that Jesus was buried, and the Gospels tell of the tomb found empty by women; even the opponents' story of a stolen body admits the empty tomb.
  • Grief visions, legend, deception and a mistaken tomb have each been proposed, and none of them accounts for all the evidence together.
  • The resurrection explains the early belief, the empty tomb and the appearances together. The Church confesses it on the witness of the apostles.

Why this question matters

Believers and sceptics sometimes talk past each other here. A believer may say, “The disciples were willing to suffer for this, so it must be true”; a sceptic may reply, “People believe all kinds of things sincerely.” The way forward is to look at what the earliest texts actually show and at what best explains it.

The answer matters for faith as well as for argument. When we see clearly what the evidence shows, we see that the Christian faith rests on testimony that is early, specific and strong, and that faith and reason point the same way.

It also matters because the resurrection is the centre of the Christian message. St Paul the Apostle himself says that, if Christ has not been raised, the preaching is empty (1 Corinthians 15:14). A claim this central deserves to be examined carefully, and it stands up to examination.

Jesus was crucified in Judea around AD 30 or 33. Our earliest surviving Christian writings are the letters of St Paul, from the AD 50s. The Gospels follow in the decades after, and their order and dates are discussed in other articles on this site.

Most of St Paul’s letters were occasional: written to particular communities about particular problems. In 1 Corinthians 15 he reminds the Corinthians of the message he first preached to them, and then argues against some in the community who said there is no resurrection of the dead. So the passage is not a neutral report but an argument, and it should be read that way.

The question of “early belief versus evidence” is a question about method. A historian asks what a text says, when and by whom it was written, what it draws on, and what explanation best accounts for it. The last step means weighing explanations that include or exclude the activity of God.

The word “resurrection” also needs care. In Christian teaching it means that Jesus rose bodily to a transformed life, which is more than the survival of his spirit or the continuing influence of his teaching. The first claim is about an event; the second is about what followers came to believe. This article keeps them apart.

Terms used

  • Primary source: A text or object from the period being studied, such as an ancient letter, a manuscript or an inscription.
  • Independent attestation: Two sources report the same thing without one copying the other. Two copies of one source are one witness, not two.
  • Eyewitness: A person who saw an event first-hand. A writer who reports what others said is not an eyewitness.
  • Gospel: An early Christian account of the life, death and resurrection of Jesus. “Gospel” also means the good news they proclaim.
  • Resurrection: In Christian teaching, Jesus’ bodily rising from the dead to a transformed life. It is a different claim from the claim that his followers came to believe it.
  • Crucifixion: A Roman method of execution by fixing a person to a cross or stake.
  • Miracle: An event believed to result from God acting beyond the ordinary course of nature.
  • Theism: The view that there is one personal God who made and sustains the world.

The evidence

By the mid-first century at the latest, Christians were proclaiming that Jesus had been raised from the dead and had appeared to named people.

St Paul's own letter, firmly dated and of known authorship, states the message and treats it as common ground with the Corinthians. It shows what the Church was proclaiming within about twenty years of the cross. [1] [4]

The message in 1 Corinthians 15:3–8 is older than St Paul's letter and goes back to the first years of the Jerusalem community.

St Paul uses the language of receiving and handing on, and the passage is compact and list-like: a formulated tradition older than the letter. In Galatians he tells of his visit to Jerusalem, where he stayed with St Peter and met James. [1] [2]

Jesus was buried in a tomb and that tomb was found empty.

St Paul hands on that Jesus was buried, and Mark and the other Gospels tell of a named burial and of the tomb found empty by women. Matthew also reports the opponents' answer, that the disciples stole the body, which admits that the tomb was empty. [1] [3] [5]

Early, firm and costly belief needs a cause, and its cause is the event the apostles proclaimed.

Sincere belief alone does not make a claim true. But the apostles did not only hold an idea; they reported what they had seen, they named witnesses, and they would not deny it under threat. The best account of what prompted their belief is the event itself. [6] [7]

The main alternative explanations (grief visions, legendary development, deception, a mistaken tomb) each fail to account for the evidence as a whole.

Book-length studies by scholars such as Wright, Licona, Allison and Levering weigh these explanations in detail. Wright, for example, argues that the early Christian belief in a bodily resurrection is best explained by the resurrection having happened. Much of the difference between scholars lies in prior views about what is possible. [6] [7] [8] [9]

Christ rose bodily from the dead on the third day.

This is the faith of the Church, received from the apostles and confessed in the Creed. It rests on the apostolic witness and the life of the Church, and the historical evidence above stands in harmony with it. [1] [3]

The proclamation of the resurrection is early, it is found in a letter by an author who had once opposed the movement, and it is joined to a list of people who could be questioned. These are real strengths of the testimony, and they make the claim one that demands an explanation.

The alternative explanations do not account for all the evidence together: the burial, the empty tomb, the shared language of resurrection, and the appearances to individuals and groups. The resurrection accounts for all of it.

History leads the honest inquirer to the empty tomb and to the witnesses. There it meets the claim of the apostles, and the invitation to trust the risen Lord.

In Scripture

1 Corinthians 15:3–8

King James Version

3 For I delivered unto you first of all that which I also received, how that Christ died for our sins according to the scriptures;

4 And that he was buried, and that he rose again the third day according to the scriptures:

5 And that he was seen of Cephas, then of the twelve:

6 After that, he was seen of above five hundred brethren at once; of whom the greater part remain unto this present, but some are fallen asleep.

7 After that, he was seen of James; then of all the apostles.

8 And last of all he was seen of me also, as of one born out of due time.

Galatians 1:18–19

King James Version

18 Then after three years I went up to Jerusalem to see Peter, and abode with him fifteen days.

19 But other of the apostles saw I none, save James the Lord’s brother.

Mark 16:1–8

King James Version

1 And when the sabbath was past, Mary Magdalene, and Mary the mother of James, and Salome, had bought sweet spices, that they might come and anoint him.

2 And very early in the morning the first day of the week, they came unto the sepulchre at the rising of the sun.

3 And they said among themselves, Who shall roll us away the stone from the door of the sepulchre?

4 And when they looked, they saw that the stone was rolled away: for it was very great.

5 And entering into the sepulchre, they saw a young man sitting on the right side, clothed in a long white garment; and they were affrighted.

6 And he saith unto them, Be not affrighted: Ye seek Jesus of Nazareth, which was crucified: he is risen; he is not here: behold the place where they laid him.

7 But go your way, tell his disciples and Peter that he goeth before you into Galilee: there shall ye see him, as he said unto you.

8 And they went out quickly, and fled from the sepulchre; for they trembled and were amazed: neither said they any thing to any man; for they were afraid.

1 Corinthians 15:12–19

King James Version

12 Now if Christ be preached that he rose from the dead, how say some among you that there is no resurrection of the dead?

13 But if there be no resurrection of the dead, then is Christ not risen:

14 And if Christ be not risen, then is our preaching vain, and your faith is also vain.

15 Yea, and we are found false witnesses of God; because we have testified of God that he raised up Christ: whom he raised not up, if so be that the dead rise not.

16 For if the dead rise not, then is not Christ raised:

17 And if Christ be not raised, your faith is vain; ye are yet in your sins.

18 Then they also which are fallen asleep in Christ are perished.

19 If in this life only we have hope in Christ, we are of all men most miserable.

Matthew 28:11–15

King James Version

11 ¶ Now when they were going, behold, some of the watch came into the city, and shewed unto the chief priests all the things that were done.

12 And when they were assembled with the elders, and had taken counsel, they gave large money unto the soldiers,

13 Saying, Say ye, His disciples came by night, and stole him away while we slept.

14 And if this come to the governor’s ears, we will persuade him, and secure you.

15 So they took the money, and did as they were taught: and this saying is commonly reported among the Jews until this day.

What the Church teaches

The Church does not hold the resurrection as the conclusion of a historian’s argument. It confesses that Christ rose from the dead on the third day, as the Creed says, because the apostles bore witness to it and because the Church has lived in the power of that event since the beginning.

In this confession, the resurrection is not only an event in the past but the victory over death and the beginning of a new creation, in which believers share by baptism and by the Eucharist. Faith in this sense is trust in a living Lord, and it is more than agreement that a fact took place.

This is why the historical evidence and the confession should not be confused. The evidence can help a person take the claim seriously; the confession is a response to the risen Lord that includes the mind, but is more than the mind.

The Coptic Orthodox Church keeps the resurrection at the centre of its year and its week. The Feast of the Resurrection is the greatest feast, Holy Week and the Paschal services lead up to it, and every Sunday is kept as a weekly remembrance of the Lord’s rising.

In the Church’s teaching the risen body of Christ is real and is the same Lord who was crucified, and the Church prays in the hope of the general resurrection. This is received from the apostles and handed on within the life of the Church, as part of the faith that is confessed in the Creed.

The Church therefore welcomes honest historical study but does not make its faith depend on the outcome of any particular scholarly debate. The articles on this site are offered so that a person can see the evidence and the questions plainly; they are not a substitute for the Church’s own teaching.

Objections answered

The first appearances were grief visions or hallucinations. Bereaved people sometimes see or sense the dead, and a group that had lost its leader, and was expecting vindication, could have had experiences that they then described as seeing him alive.

Grief can bring private experiences, but it does not explain what the sources report: appearances to groups, to people who did not expect a risen Messiah, and to a former opponent, St Paul. Nor does it explain why the disciples proclaimed that He was “raised”, and not simply that He was with God.

Visions do not empty tombs. A vision of a departed leader would have left his body in its grave, and the preaching in Jerusalem could have been ended at once. The appearances and the empty tomb belong together, and only the resurrection explains both.

[1] [8]

The resurrection story is a legend that grew. The earliest sources are brief; the Gospel accounts are later and more elaborate; and stories about revered figures commonly grow, so what we have may be the end of a long process rather than the report of an event.

Details are added between St Paul, Mark and the later Gospels, as each evangelist tells the story for his readers. But the central witness, death, burial, resurrection and appearances, is already in St Paul within about twenty years, and it was proclaimed while eyewitnesses and critics were alive.

Legends need generations, and distance from the facts. Here the core is fixed from the start, St Paul invites his readers to ask the witnesses, and the details that differ never touch the heart of the message.

[1] [3]

The disciples deceived others: they took the body and claimed Jesus had risen.

This is the oldest alternative on record, since Matthew already answers it. It requires that the leaders of a movement spent their lives, and in several traditions their deaths, on something they knew to be false. People may die for a mistake; they do not suffer for what they know is a lie.

The apostles' preaching, their hardship and their steadfast witness all show sincere conviction. Fraud does not fit the early texts, and it does not explain the conversion of St Paul or of James.

[5]

There was no honourable burial and no identifiable tomb. Crucified criminals were often left unburied or put in a common grave, so the empty-tomb story may have no historical basis, and the women may even have gone to the wrong tomb.

Roman practice toward executed criminals was often harsh. But Jewish law and custom pressed for burial before nightfall, the Gospels name a particular man, Joseph of Arimathea, who arranged it, and St Paul hands on that Jesus “was buried”. The witness to a burial in a known tomb is clear.

The wrong-tomb idea does not fit a story in which the tomb was known to Joseph and to the women, and in which opponents could have checked the claim and produced the body. They never did.

[1] [3] [5]

Historians cannot say that a miracle happened. History works by analogy with ordinary experience, so any natural explanation, however improbable, is to be preferred to a supernatural one; therefore the resurrection cannot be established as history.

This view goes back to Hume. Its weakness is that it excludes the possibility in advance, so that the conclusion follows from the assumption and not from the evidence. If God exists and acts, a miracle is not impossible, and the question becomes one of evidence.

History can establish what the sources say and test the natural explanations. When those explanations fail and the evidence points to an act of God, an open mind should follow where it leads.

From the other direction: “Belief this early, this widespread and this costly can only be explained by the resurrection, so the early belief is itself the proof.”

This is a serious argument and the heart of several scholarly cases. It is an argument to the best explanation: among the available explanations, the resurrection accounts for the evidence best.

The early belief does not stand alone. It comes with the burial, the empty tomb, the appearances to individuals and groups, and the transformation of the apostles. Taken together, these point clearly to the risen Lord.

[1] [6] [7]

Conclusion

Early belief is strong historical evidence, and it points beyond itself. The first Christians proclaimed within a few years that Jesus died, was buried, rose and appeared to many, and no rival explanation accounts for that witness. The Church confesses with the apostles that Christ is risen, and the evidence of history stands with her confession.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close