Faith & Evidence / Crucifixion and resurrection
Do disagreements among resurrection accounts undermine the central claim?
The answer
The four Gospels tell the resurrection each in its own way. They differ in details: which women went to the tomb, how many angels they saw, and where the risen Lord met the disciples. But they agree completely on what matters: Jesus died and was buried, women found the tomb empty on the first day of the week, and He appeared alive to His disciples. Differences of detail are exactly what we expect from honest witnesses telling the same event independently; a story agreed in advance would read the same in every telling. The differences show that the accounts were not smoothed into one, and so they strengthen the witness of the core. Christ is risen, and all four Gospels say so.
- Agreed by all four: Jesus was buried; women went to the tomb on the first day of the week; it was found empty; He was seen alive by His followers.
- Different: the names and number of the women, one or two angels, whether the stone was already moved, and who entered the tomb.
- Different: Galilee in Mark and Matthew, Jerusalem in Luke, and both in John, which shows that the Lord appeared in both places.
- St Paul’s list adds appearances the Gospels do not narrate, such as to James and to more than five hundred, and meets St Luke on the appearance to Simon Peter.
- Honest witnesses differ in details and agree on the core; that is the pattern of the resurrection accounts.
Why this question matters
Differences among the accounts are one of the commonest objections to the resurrection, and they can trouble believers who notice them for the first time. They deserve a plain answer.
The answer also teaches a sound way of reading: how witnesses to one event normally differ, the difference between a detail and the core, and why the Church has always kept four Gospels side by side rather than one blended story.
Four narratives of the empty tomb and appearances are in the Gospels, and a fifth, shorter and earlier, is in St Paul. Mark is dated around AD 70, Matthew and Luke somewhat later, and John later still. Matthew and Luke share much of Mark’s material, and John tells the story independently.
The ending of Mark is textually uncertain. The earliest manuscripts end at 16:8 with the women afraid, and a longer ending in 16:9–20 appears in later manuscripts. The longer ending is a separate question and is not used here.
The ancient world had a different standard for accounts of events from the one a modern court uses. A writer was expected to be faithful to the main course of events, and free in the choice, order and wording of details. Differences between Greek and Roman historians on a single event, such as speeches or the order of episodes, are common, and so the existence of differences does not by itself lead a historian to doubt that an event took place.
Terms used
- Primary source: A text or object from the period being studied, such as an ancient letter, a manuscript or an inscription.
- Independent attestation: Two sources report the same thing without one copying the other. Two copies of one source are one witness, not two.
- Textual variant: A place where surviving manuscripts differ in wording. Most variants are spelling or word-order differences.
- Gospel: An early Christian account of the life, death and resurrection of Jesus. “Gospel” also means the good news they proclaim.
- Synoptic Gospels: Matthew, Mark and Luke, which share much material and are read side by side.
- Resurrection: In Christian teaching, Jesus’ bodily rising from the dead to a transformed life. It is a different claim from the claim that his followers came to believe it.
The evidence
The Gospel accounts of the empty tomb and the appearances differ in details of persons, number, place and sequence.
Reading the passages side by side shows it. St Mark names three women, St Matthew two, St Luke three and others with them, and St John one. The messengers are a young man, an angel, two men, and two angels. The visit is at dawn, at sunrise, or while it was still dark. Each evangelist tells the event in his own words and from his own sources. [1] [2] [3]
All four Gospels agree on the burial, the women at the tomb on the first day of the week, the empty tomb, and the appearances of the risen Jesus.
The agreement is on the whole shape of the event. St John’s account, which differs most in detail and does not depend on the others in the same way, keeps exactly the same outline. Where the witnesses differ most in wording, they agree on the facts. [1] [2] [3] [4]
The appearances took place both in Jerusalem and in Galilee; St Luke tells of those in Jerusalem, St Matthew of the one in Galilee, and St John of both.
In St Mark and St Matthew the disciples are told to go to Galilee, and St Matthew has them meet the Lord there. In St Luke the appearances are in and around Jerusalem. St John records appearances in Jerusalem and then by the Sea of Tiberias in Galilee. Each evangelist chose what served his account, and together they show the Lord appearing in both places. [2] [5]
St Paul’s list and the Gospel accounts meet on Cephas and the Twelve, and each adds appearances the other does not narrate.
St Paul names appearances to James, to more than five hundred at once and to all the apostles. The Gospels tell of appearances to the women, to the two on the road to Emmaus, and to Thomas. St Luke 24:34 refers to the appearance to Simon, in agreement with St Paul. St Paul gives a short summary and the Gospels are selective, so together they give a fuller picture of many witnesses. [6] [2]
Read as ancient documents, the accounts agree on everything that matters to the claim and differ just where independent witnesses would be expected to differ. This is the pattern of genuine testimony, not of a legend made uniform.
The women named at the cross, at the burial and at the tomb tie the discovery to the events before it. St Paul’s early list, St Luke’s note of the appearance to Simon, and St John’s independent telling all point to the same Easter morning. The differences of detail confirm that these are several witnesses, and their agreement points to the risen Christ.
In Scripture
Mark 16:1–8
King James Version
1 And when the sabbath was past, Mary Magdalene, and Mary the mother of James, and Salome, had bought sweet spices, that they might come and anoint him.
2 And very early in the morning the first day of the week, they came unto the sepulchre at the rising of the sun.
3 And they said among themselves, Who shall roll us away the stone from the door of the sepulchre?
4 And when they looked, they saw that the stone was rolled away: for it was very great.
5 And entering into the sepulchre, they saw a young man sitting on the right side, clothed in a long white garment; and they were affrighted.
6 And he saith unto them, Be not affrighted: Ye seek Jesus of Nazareth, which was crucified: he is risen; he is not here: behold the place where they laid him.
7 But go your way, tell his disciples and Peter that he goeth before you into Galilee: there shall ye see him, as he said unto you.
8 And they went out quickly, and fled from the sepulchre; for they trembled and were amazed: neither said they any thing to any man; for they were afraid.
Luke 24:1–12
King James Version
1 Now upon the first day of the week, very early in the morning, they came unto the sepulchre, bringing the spices which they had prepared, and certain others with them.
2 And they found the stone rolled away from the sepulchre.
3 And they entered in, and found not the body of the Lord Jesus.
4 And it came to pass, as they were much perplexed thereabout, behold, two men stood by them in shining garments:
5 And as they were afraid, and bowed down their faces to the earth, they said unto them, Why seek ye the living among the dead?
6 He is not here, but is risen: remember how he spake unto you when he was yet in Galilee,
7 Saying, The Son of man must be delivered into the hands of sinful men, and be crucified, and the third day rise again.
8 And they remembered his words,
9 And returned from the sepulchre, and told all these things unto the eleven, and to all the rest.
10 It was Mary Magdalene, and Joanna, and Mary the mother of James, and other women that were with them, which told these things unto the apostles.
11 And their words seemed to them as idle tales, and they believed them not.
12 Then arose Peter, and ran unto the sepulchre; and stooping down, he beheld the linen clothes laid by themselves, and departed, wondering in himself at that which was come to pass.
John 20:1–18
King James Version
1 The first day of the week cometh Mary Magdalene early, when it was yet dark, unto the sepulchre, and seeth the stone taken away from the sepulchre.
2 Then she runneth, and cometh to Simon Peter, and to the other disciple, whom Jesus loved, and saith unto them, They have taken away the Lord out of the sepulchre, and we know not where they have laid him.
3 Peter therefore went forth, and that other disciple, and came to the sepulchre.
4 So they ran both together: and the other disciple did outrun Peter, and came first to the sepulchre.
5 And he stooping down, and looking in, saw the linen clothes lying; yet went he not in.
6 Then cometh Simon Peter following him, and went into the sepulchre, and seeth the linen clothes lie,
7 And the napkin, that was about his head, not lying with the linen clothes, but wrapped together in a place by itself.
8 Then went in also that other disciple, which came first to the sepulchre, and he saw, and believed.
9 For as yet they knew not the scripture, that he must rise again from the dead.
10 Then the disciples went away again unto their own home.
11 ¶ But Mary stood without at the sepulchre weeping: and as she wept, she stooped down, and looked into the sepulchre,
12 And seeth two angels in white sitting, the one at the head, and the other at the feet, where the body of Jesus had lain.
13 And they say unto her, Woman, why weepest thou? She saith unto them, Because they have taken away my Lord, and I know not where they have laid him.
14 And when she had thus said, she turned herself back, and saw Jesus standing, and knew not that it was Jesus.
15 Jesus saith unto her, Woman, why weepest thou? whom seekest thou? She, supposing him to be the gardener, saith unto him, Sir, if thou have borne him hence, tell me where thou hast laid him, and I will take him away.
16 Jesus saith unto her, Mary. She turned herself, and saith unto him, Rabboni; which is to say, Master.
17 Jesus saith unto her, Touch me not; for I am not yet ascended to my Father: but go to my brethren, and say unto them, I ascend unto my Father, and your Father; and to my God, and your God.
18 Mary Magdalene came and told the disciples that she had seen the Lord, and that he had spoken these things unto her.
Mark 15:40–47
King James Version
40 There were also women looking on afar off: among whom was Mary Magdalene, and Mary the mother of James the less and of Joses, and Salome;
41 (Who also, when he was in Galilee, followed him, and ministered unto him;) and many other women which came up with him unto Jerusalem.
42 ¶ And now when the even was come, because it was the preparation, that is, the day before the sabbath,
43 Joseph of Arimathaea, an honourable counsellor, which also waited for the kingdom of God, came, and went in boldly unto Pilate, and craved the body of Jesus.
44 And Pilate marvelled if he were already dead: and calling unto him the centurion, he asked him whether he had been any while dead.
45 And when he knew it of the centurion, he gave the body to Joseph.
46 And he bought fine linen, and took him down, and wrapped him in the linen, and laid him in a sepulchre which was hewn out of a rock, and rolled a stone unto the door of the sepulchre.
47 And Mary Magdalene and Mary the mother of Joses beheld where he was laid.
Matthew 28:16–20
King James Version
16 ¶ Then the eleven disciples went away into Galilee, into a mountain where Jesus had appointed them.
17 And when they saw him, they worshipped him: but some doubted.
18 And Jesus came and spake unto them, saying, All power is given unto me in heaven and in earth.
19 ¶ Go ye therefore, and teach all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost:
20 Teaching them to observe all things whatsoever I have commanded you: and, lo, I am with you alway, even unto the end of the world. Amen.
1 Corinthians 15:5–8
King James Version
5 And that he was seen of Cephas, then of the twelve:
6 After that, he was seen of above five hundred brethren at once; of whom the greater part remain unto this present, but some are fallen asleep.
7 After that, he was seen of James; then of all the apostles.
8 And last of all he was seen of me also, as of one born out of due time.
What the Church teaches
The Church receives the four Gospels as the witness of the Holy Spirit through four evangelists, each with his own emphasis. St Irenaeus argued that there are four Gospels as there are four regions of the world, and the Church has not asked that they be merged. The multiplicity is a richness in the Church's eyes, and the unity is in the person of the risen Lord, to whom all four bear witness.
In the Paschal services the Coptic Church reads the resurrection Gospels in their turn, from Matthew, Mark, Luke and John, at the different hours and on the following Sundays, and does not read them as one blended story. The differences are part of what is heard. The Church has also kept the memory of the women as the first to be sent, and honours Mary Magdalene in its teaching as the first to announce the risen Lord.
Objections answered
Witnesses who cannot agree on how many women, how many angels or where the disciples met Jesus cannot be trusted on whether he rose at all.
Differences in secondary details are normal when several witnesses report one event, and they do not lead us to deny the event. Ancient historians who reported the same battle or death differed in just this way, and so do honest witnesses in court today.
What matters is the core, and on the core all four agree: the burial, the women, the empty tomb, and the appearances of the risen Lord. The differences actually tell against invention: writers who had agreed on a story would not have left such obvious variations. The witnesses are independent, and they agree on the resurrection.
The differences are not minor. Galilee and Jerusalem are incompatible, and one day and forty days cannot both be right. The evangelists were rewriting the story for their own purposes.
Each evangelist did write with a purpose, and arranged his material to serve it. St Luke, for example, centres his account on Jerusalem, where the Church was to begin. Choosing and arranging is not inventing.
Jerusalem and Galilee are not incompatible: the disciples saw the Lord in Jerusalem and then in Galilee, and St John records both. St Luke himself, the author of both the Gospel and Acts, tells us in Acts that the Lord appeared over forty days. The same writer would not contradict himself; in his Gospel he tells the events briefly, and in Acts he gives the length of time.
If the Bible is the word of God, it should have no discrepancies. The existence of differences shows that it is not inspired.
The objection assumes that inspiration means four identical accounts. The Coptic Orthodox Church does not hold that view. She receives four Gospels, not one merged text, and the Fathers noticed the differences and explained them without ever doubting inspiration.
The Holy Spirit spoke through four evangelists, each with his own memory, sources and emphasis. Their differences of detail are the mark of real human witness, and their agreement on the risen Lord is the witness of the Spirit.
Conclusion
The resurrection accounts differ in details and agree on the core. That is the mark of honest, independent witnesses, not of a story invented and agreed. All four Gospels, with St Paul, bear witness that the tomb was empty and that the Lord appeared alive to His disciples. The Church receives the four voices as the one witness of the Holy Spirit: Christ is risen.
Sources
- Mark 16:1–8
- Luke 24:1–12
- John 20:1–18
- Mark 15:40–47
- Matthew 28:16–20
- 1 Corinthians 15:5–8
- The Resurrection of Jesus: Apologetics, Polemics, History · Dale C. Allison Jr.
- The Resurrection of the Son of God · N. T. Wright
No inbox has been set up yet, so nothing is sent. This copies a short report with the page address and revision for you to pass on.