Faith & Evidence / Crucifixion and resurrection
How should vision, grief, legend, deception and other hypotheses be evaluated?
The answer
Every explanation must account for the same early facts: the apostles proclaimed that Jesus was raised; He appeared to individuals and to groups; His tomb was found empty; and the Church grew rapidly in the very city where He died. Each natural alternative fails at some point. Conspiracy cannot explain men who suffered for what they preached. Apparent death does not fit Roman execution. A wrong tomb does not explain the appearances. Visions cannot account for groups, for a former persecutor like St Paul, or for the claim of a bodily raising. Legend cannot grow in the few years between the cross and the creed St Paul received. Only the resurrection explains all the facts together. Its one "cost" is that it needs an act of God, and for anyone open to God that is no cost at all: Christ is risen.
- Conspiracy and theft: the oldest alternative on record (Matthew 28:11–15). It cannot explain the sincerity of men who suffered for their message, nor the appearances.
- Apparent death: it needs a chain of unlikely assumptions, and a half-dead man could never have been proclaimed the glorified Lord.
- Wrong tomb: at best it explains an empty tomb, not the appearances, and the tomb was known in the city.
- Visions and grief: they may touch one mourner, but not groups, not a persecutor like St Paul, and not the word "raised", which meant a body.
- Legend: the core of the faith is in the creed St Paul received within a few years of the cross. Weighed by scope, power and plausibility, the resurrection alone explains everything.
Why this question matters
A believer will meet these alternatives, in books, in class or online. Seeing each one in its best form, and seeing where it fails, lets a Christian answer with confidence and gentleness.
This is what the Fathers did. They stated each objection fairly and answered it, and the answers showed again that the apostles told the truth.
The "facts" that an explanation must account for are not all equally secure. The following are the most widely accepted: Jesus was crucified under Pilate; some of his followers came to believe he had been raised and proclaimed this; St Paul, once an opponent, came to the same belief; the movement grew in Jerusalem and beyond within a generation. More debated are the burial in a tomb, the discovery of the empty tomb and the nature of the appearances.
A method for comparing explanations has been proposed by philosophers of history such as C. B. McCullagh and applied to the resurrection by the historian Michael Licona. It asks of each hypothesis how much it explains (scope), how well (power), how plausible it is given what we know, how many extra assumptions it needs (ad hoc), and whether it conflicts with beliefs we hold with more confidence. Critics say that these criteria are applied to the resurrection with unequal care, and that each depends on prior judgments about what is plausible.
Explanations are of two kinds. Some say nothing happened to Jesus beyond death, and that the claims arose from the followers. Others say something happened, but a natural something. The Christian claim is that something happened that only God could do. Each family of explanation faces the same early evidence.
Terms used
- Primary source: A text or object from the period being studied, such as an ancient letter, a manuscript or an inscription.
- Independent attestation: Two sources report the same thing without one copying the other. Two copies of one source are one witness, not two.
- Eyewitness: A person who saw an event first-hand. A writer who reports what others said is not an eyewitness.
- Resurrection: In Christian teaching, Jesus’ bodily rising from the dead to a transformed life. It is a different claim from the claim that his followers came to believe it.
- Miracle: An event believed to result from God acting beyond the ordinary course of nature.
- Theism: The view that there is one personal God who made and sustains the world.
The evidence
Every major alternative has been proposed seriously, and each one breaks down against the evidence.
Conspiracy was argued in the eighteenth century by H. S. Reimarus, apparent death by rationalist writers of the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, wrong tomb by Kirsopp Lake in the early twentieth, subjective visions by D. F. Strauss, and visionary experiences of grief and guilt by Gerd Lüdemann. Each was answered in its own time, and none explains the whole of the early witness. [1] [4] [7]
Deliberate deception by the disciples, the oldest alternative on record, is also the weakest.
It cannot explain St Paul, who set out to destroy the Church, nor men who suffered for a message they would have known to be false. Even many historians who do not believe in the resurrection grant that the first believers sincerely saw something. [1] [2] [3]
Visions or hallucinations, the most discussed natural explanation, cannot account for the appearances as they are reported.
Grief experiences happen to individuals, one at a time. The risen Lord appeared to groups, to the Twelve and to more than five hundred at once, and to St Paul, an enemy who was not grieving at all. Visions of the dead were never called resurrection; the disciples chose that word because they met Him in the body, touched Him and ate with Him. [1] [5] [6]
The legend explanation fails because the core of the proclamation is early.
The heart of the Gospel, that Christ died, was buried, was raised and appeared, is not a late addition. St Paul the Apostle says he received it, and he met Peter and James in Jerusalem within a few years of the cross. The eyewitnesses were alive and leading the Church; there was no time and no room for a legend to replace what they had seen. [1] [2] [8]
Those who reject the resurrection usually do so because of a prior view that God does not act, not because of the historical evidence.
If one decides in advance that God does not exist or cannot act, no evidence for the resurrection could ever be enough. But that decision is a philosophical starting point, not a finding of history. Once we allow that the living God exists and loves His creation, raising His Son is exactly what we would expect, and the evidence points straight to it. [9] [4]
Each natural explanation leaves something important unexplained. The resurrection explains the whole: the empty tomb, the appearances to individuals and to groups, the change in St Paul and James, and the shape of the earliest proclamation. Careful historians such as N. T. Wright and Michael Licona have tested the alternatives one by one and concluded that the resurrection is the best explanation of the evidence.
The points that matter are clear. The core tradition is early, within the lifetime of the eyewitnesses. The experiences were shared, bodily and life-changing. And the only thing that stands against the resurrection is the assumption that God cannot act.
In Scripture
1 Corinthians 15:3–11
King James Version
3 For I delivered unto you first of all that which I also received, how that Christ died for our sins according to the scriptures;
4 And that he was buried, and that he rose again the third day according to the scriptures:
5 And that he was seen of Cephas, then of the twelve:
6 After that, he was seen of above five hundred brethren at once; of whom the greater part remain unto this present, but some are fallen asleep.
7 After that, he was seen of James; then of all the apostles.
8 And last of all he was seen of me also, as of one born out of due time.
9 For I am the least of the apostles, that am not meet to be called an apostle, because I persecuted the church of God.
10 But by the grace of God I am what I am: and his grace which was bestowed upon me was not in vain; but I laboured more abundantly than they all: yet not I, but the grace of God which was with me.
11 Therefore whether it were I or they, so we preach, and so ye believed.
Matthew 28:11–15
King James Version
11 ¶ Now when they were going, behold, some of the watch came into the city, and shewed unto the chief priests all the things that were done.
12 And when they were assembled with the elders, and had taken counsel, they gave large money unto the soldiers,
13 Saying, Say ye, His disciples came by night, and stole him away while we slept.
14 And if this come to the governor’s ears, we will persuade him, and secure you.
15 So they took the money, and did as they were taught: and this saying is commonly reported among the Jews until this day.
Galatians 1:13–16
King James Version
13 For ye have heard of my conversation in time past in the Jews’ religion, how that beyond measure I persecuted the church of God, and wasted it:
14 And profited in the Jews’ religion above many my equals in mine own nation, being more exceedingly zealous of the traditions of my fathers.
15 But when it pleased God, who separated me from my mother’s womb, and called me by his grace,
16 To reveal his Son in me, that I might preach him among the heathen; immediately I conferred not with flesh and blood:
Luke 24:36–43
King James Version
36 ¶ And as they thus spake, Jesus himself stood in the midst of them, and saith unto them, Peace be unto you.
37 But they were terrified and affrighted, and supposed that they had seen a spirit.
38 And he said unto them, Why are ye troubled? and why do thoughts arise in your hearts?
39 Behold my hands and my feet, that it is I myself: handle me, and see; for a spirit hath not flesh and bones, as ye see me have.
40 And when he had thus spoken, he shewed them his hands and his feet.
41 And while they yet believed not for joy, and wondered, he said unto them, Have ye here any meat?
42 And they gave him a piece of a broiled fish, and of an honeycomb.
43 And he took it, and did eat before them.
What the Church teaches
The Church confesses that Christ rose, as the apostles saw and proclaimed. Her faith does not rest on having defeated every alternative, but on the witness handed down and on the Spirit who confirms it in the believer. The Church can therefore listen to alternatives without fear, and she distinguishes between the intellectual work of weighing evidence, which she encourages, and the act of faith in the living Lord, which that work serves but does not replace.
The Alexandrian tradition has always answered objections to the resurrection with reasoning. St Athanasius, in On the Incarnation, argues that the change in the lives of believers and their disregard of death show the power of the risen Christ. The Coptic Church holds this reasoning alongside the liturgical experience of the Pascha, in which the Church lives the resurrection as present and does not only prove it as past.
Objections answered
It is always more probable that people are mistaken, deceived or lying than that a dead man returned to life. Any natural explanation, however strained, is better than a miracle.
This is Hume’s argument. It is true that the dead do not rise in ordinary experience; the apostles knew that too, which is why the resurrection astonished them. But the argument decides the answer before looking: if no evidence could ever count, the question has not been examined at all.
The Church does not say that Jesus rose by natural causes. She proclaims that God raised Him. Once God is not ruled out in advance, a strained natural theory is no longer "better" than the explanation that fits every fact. The real question is about God, and the living God raised His Son.
Groups of people do sometimes share visions, and religious movements have often grown from visionary experiences after a leader's death. The resurrection claims are one more example.
Shared visions are reported in other movements, usually among devout groups who were already expecting them. The disciples were not. They had no expectation of a Messiah who would die and be raised in the middle of history; they were hiding in fear and grief.
Their claim was not a vision but a raised body and an empty tomb. And the Lord appeared also to James, who had not believed in Him, and to St Paul, who was persecuting His Church. No visionary movement explains these. The appearances were real meetings with the risen Christ.
Christians claim that all natural explanations fail, but a combination of factors (grief experiences, a mistaken tomb, a growing legend) can do the work together.
Combining weak explanations does not make a strong one. Each added factor is one more assumption, so the whole becomes less likely than any part: grief visions that happened to groups, and a wrong tomb that no one corrected, and a legend that grew while the eyewitnesses were still alive.
The resurrection needs no chain of coincidences. It needs one thing: that God acted. It explains the empty tomb, the appearances, the change in James and St Paul, and the apostles’ fearless preaching, all at once. That is why the Church proclaims it with confidence.
Conclusion
No natural explanation accounts for the early evidence without piling up assumptions. The resurrection accounts for all of it. Ask of each theory what it explains and what it assumes, and the answer becomes clear: the apostles told the truth. Christ is risen, as they saw and proclaimed, and the Church lives by that faith.
Sources
- 1 Corinthians 15:3–11
- Matthew 28:11–15
- Galatians 1:13–16
- The Resurrection of Jesus: Apologetics, Polemics, History · Dale C. Allison Jr.
- Luke 24:36–43
- The Resurrection of the Son of God · N. T. Wright
- The Resurrection of Jesus: A New Historiographical Approach · Michael R. Licona
- Jesus Before the Gospels · Bart D. Ehrman
- Miracles · Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy · entry "Miracles" (testimony, probability and Hume's argument)
No inbox has been set up yet, so nothing is sent. This copies a short report with the page address and revision for you to pass on.