Orthodoxia

Methodology

This section is written from a Coptic Orthodox Christian perspective. It tries to describe objections in terms their holders would recognise, and it says plainly when a claim rests on history, on philosophy, or on faith.

Five different kinds of claim

A source reports an event. The event probably happened. Early Christians believed it. A philosophical argument supports a conclusion. The Church affirms a doctrine. These are five different claims and each needs its own kind of support. A report is not yet a fact, a belief is not yet proof, and a doctrine is not a historical finding.

Each article keeps them apart: what a source states is shown separately from what we infer from it, and historical inference is shown separately from theological explanation.

Scripture as an ancient document

An argument meant to establish Christianity’s historical credibility must not require the reader to accept biblical inspiration first. When the Bible is used historically, it is read as a collection of ancient documents, with the usual questions about date, authorship, genre and sources. Belief in inspiration is a separate, theological question, and the articles label it so.

Assessment labels

Each claim carries a label and a written reason for it. The labels are definitions, not percentages. We never state a statistical probability and we never claim that every scholar agrees. Two of the labels, philosophical argument and theological interpretation, name a kind of reasoning; they are not lower grades of confidence.

A label is never a verdict to take on trust: the reasons stand beside it so that you can weigh the argument for yourself.

Strong historical support
Several independent lines of evidence point the same way and serious alternatives have been examined. Some details may still be uncertain.
Supported, with disputed details
The central claim is supported by good evidence, while some of its details are debated among historians.
Actively debated
Informed specialists disagree, and the evidence can reasonably be read more than one way.
Limited evidence
Little or no independent evidence is available, so the claim rests mainly on one kind of source.
Philosophical argument
A claim assessed by reasoning from premises, not by historical documents. This is a kind of argument, not a low confidence score.
Theological interpretation
A claim about what the faith teaches or how a text is read within the Church. This is a kind of claim, not a low confidence score.
Assessment
No reviewer has assessed this yet.

How sources are treated

A source is recorded with what it is (a text, an edition of a text, a book, a museum record, a storefront), whose voice it is when that can be documented, how it was dated, and how much of it the site may show. A modern author’s religion does not decide the value of an argument; it is recorded only when documented, and otherwise marked “not established”.

Two websites hosting the same ancient text are one witness, not two. A publisher page is a pointer to a book, not the book. A source is marked reviewed only when someone has read it, never because its title or synopsis was read. A book we have only by metadata is cited only as a whole work, for the thesis its author states, and never with a chapter, page or quotation we have not seen.

Non-Christian does not mean independent, unbiased, contemporary or reliable, and Christian does not mean the opposite. Each source is weighed on what it can show.

Access: Full text available online · Excerpts or images only · Abstract only · Metadata only · Paywalled · Awaiting an authorised copy · Unavailable.

Dates

The date a text was composed, the date of the manuscript that survives, and the date an object was found are three different dates, and the timeline keeps them apart. We give ranges with the basis for them, and we do not invent exact years.

Review and corrections

Questions are answered in the order they are written up, and each answer keeps its revision number. When a source or a claim changes, the articles that depend on it are revised rather than silently changed, and every correction is kept in the article’s history. A named reviewer’s name and the review date appear on an article once one has signed it off.

What this section does not do

It does not promise that every doctrine has conclusive proof outside the faith. It does not score readers, label their beliefs or pressure anyone. It does not claim to answer every doubt: the backlog lists questions that still have no answer, and says so.

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close