Orthodoxia

Faith & Evidence / Crucifixion and resurrection

Can historical reasoning support a miracle claim?

AdvancedHistoricalPhilosophicalAnswer available

Revision 1, updated

The answer

Yes. History weighs testimony and asks which explanation best accounts for the evidence, and nothing in that method rules out an act of God unless one decides in advance that God cannot act. For the resurrection, history can show what the apostles proclaimed and how early, that the tomb was found empty, that the Lord appeared to individuals and groups, and that every natural explanation breaks down. The objection that a historian must always prefer a natural cause, however strained, is not a finding of history; it is a philosophy brought to it. Once God is not excluded, the evidence points clearly to the truth the Church proclaims: God raised Jesus from the dead.

  • Hume argued that uniform experience will always outweigh testimony to a miracle; but if experience is counted as uniform only by excluding the miracle, the argument assumes what it sets out to prove.
  • Ernst Troeltsch’s principles of criticism, analogy and correlation are useful working rules for historians, not a proof that God never acts.
  • History can and should ask which hypothesis best explains the evidence, and that includes the hypothesis that God acted.
  • Those who reject the resurrection usually do so because of a prior view that God does not act, not because of the evidence.
  • Christian faith rests on the apostolic witness and the Holy Spirit; honest study of the evidence confirms that this faith is well founded.

Why this question matters

Almost every discussion of the resurrection reaches this question sooner or later. Many people have been told that "history cannot show a miracle" as if it were a settled rule. It is not, and a believer should know why.

The Church has always answered the philosophy of its time. St Athanasius answered objections to the incarnation and the resurrection from reason. The same task now is to show clearly that the historical evidence for the resurrection deserves to be heard on its merits.

By "miracle" this article means an event ascribed to God's special action that goes beyond the ordinary course of nature, which the Church understands as a sign. It does not mean any unusual event. The question is whether evidence of the kind a historian uses could make it reasonable to believe that such an event occurred.

David Hume's essay on miracles (1748) argues that a wise person proportions belief to evidence, that experience of the laws of nature is as full as experience can be, and that testimony to a violation of those laws will therefore seldom or never outweigh it. Critics, including philosophers writing in the last decades, reply that Hume's argument begs the question against miracle if it counts uniform experience as already excluding the exception, and that on a proper account of probability, strong testimony can outweigh low prior probability. John Earman and others have argued this on Bayesian grounds, and Hume's defenders have replied.

Ernst Troeltsch (1898) proposed that historical method rests on three principles: that all historical judgments are open to revision (criticism), that the past is like the present (analogy), and that events are connected by cause and effect (correlation). Some take these principles as excluding a miracle. But they are working rules of the historian, not a philosophy that decides what the world is like, and a historian who uses them for research is not thereby committed to denying that God acts.

Terms used

  • Apologetics: The reasoned defence and explanation of a belief. It offers arguments and evidence for examination; it does not replace faith or guarantee agreement.
  • Primary source: A text or object from the period being studied, such as an ancient letter, a manuscript or an inscription.
  • Independent attestation: Two sources report the same thing without one copying the other. Two copies of one source are one witness, not two.
  • Resurrection: In Christian teaching, Jesus’ bodily rising from the dead to a transformed life. It is a different claim from the claim that his followers came to believe it.
  • Miracle: An event believed to result from God acting beyond the ordinary course of nature.
  • Theism: The view that there is one personal God who made and sustains the world.

The evidence

Historical method can establish what the sources claim and can compare natural explanations for those claims.

This is ordinary historical work, done by believers and sceptics alike. It is already a great deal: it shows that the apostles proclaimed the resurrection within a few years of the cross, that the proclamation began in Jerusalem, and that the natural explanations offered for it each fail at important points. [2] [4]

Hume's argument against miracles does not close the question.

If "uniform experience" means that no one has ever witnessed a miracle, that is exactly what is in question, so the argument assumes its conclusion. And on a sound account of probability, strong and independent testimony can outweigh a low prior probability; philosophers such as John Earman have argued this carefully against Hume. [1]

Once the existence of God is not ruled out, the resurrection is not improbable at all, and the evidence can be weighed fairly.

Only if there is no God is a resurrection nearly impossible. If God exists and loves the world He made, raising His Son to defeat death is exactly the kind of act we might expect. The question of God therefore comes first, and there are strong reasons to believe in Him; with that question answered, the early evidence speaks clearly. [1]

Careful historical study has concluded that the resurrection is the best explanation of the evidence.

Michael Licona, applying the stated methods of historians step by step, argues that the resurrection of Jesus is the best explanation of the data he examines. Matthew Levering joins that historical reasoning to theological reflection. Dale Allison’s careful comparison of apologetic and sceptical arguments shows how seriously the historical case must be taken. [2] [3] [4]

History does real work on the resurrection. It shows what the apostles proclaimed and how early; it shows that the proclamation began in Jerusalem, where the tomb was known; and it tests the natural explanations and finds each of them wanting.

The final step, from "no natural explanation works" to "God raised Jesus", rests on whether God can act. The Church answers that He can and did. Reason shows that God exists and that the evidence for the resurrection is strong; faith receives the risen Lord Himself.

What the Church teaches

The Church believes in a God who made the world and acts in it, so that a miracle is not a breach of order by an outsider but an act of the Creator, who is Lord of the order he made. The resurrection of Christ is the central act, the beginning of the new creation. Such belief is held in faith, through the apostolic witness and the life of the Church, and the Church is glad to have the support of reason without making reason the judge of the Lord.

The Coptic Church has a strong tradition of reasoned defence of the faith, from the school of Alexandria and from St Athanasius, and also a living tradition of miracles ascribed to the intercession of the saints and martyrs. The Church treats such reports with discernment, and does not make them the basis of faith. The resurrection is celebrated as the basis of all, and every Sunday is kept in its memory.

Objections answered

The historian can never conclude that a miracle occurred, since the historical method works by what is probable, and a miracle is by definition the least probable of events.

It is true that unusual claims need strong support, and that history contains many false reports of marvels. The Church agrees, and examines miracle reports with discernment.

But "least probable" depends on what one already believes. If God exists and acts, a resurrection is not the least probable of events; it is the act of the Lord of life. A method that could never conclude a miracle whatever the evidence is not a neutral test; it has decided the answer in advance. The evidence for the resurrection is early, multiple and strong, and it deserves to be weighed, not dismissed by definition.

[1]

If historical arguments can support a Christian miracle, they can equally support miracles in other religions, and the result is a contradiction.

A fair method treats every claim alike, and that is exactly why it does not confirm them all. Each claim is weighed on its own evidence: how early the report is, how close to the event, how many independent lines support it, and what alternatives there are. The resurrection of Jesus stands out on every one of these tests: a public event, proclaimed within a few years in the city where it happened, by many witnesses who suffered for it.

Many miracle reports do not even contradict each other; a healing in another tradition does not deny that Christ rose. Where claims do exclude each other, the evidence decides between them, as the article on comparing religious claims shows.

[1] [3]

Faith should not depend on historical argument at all. If the resurrection needs a historian to confirm it, it is not faith.

Faith does not wait on a historian. It is trust in a living Lord, received in the Church from the apostles, and it is more than assent to a conclusion. Many believers have a strong faith without having studied the historical evidence, and the Church does not require that they do.

But the Gospel is also the news that something really happened, and St Paul the Apostle himself appeals to witnesses, most of whom were still alive. Examining the evidence is therefore not alien to faith. It shows that faith stands on solid ground, and it helps us answer everyone who asks a reason for the hope that is in us.

Conclusion

History can support a miracle. It weighs the evidence and compares explanations, and nothing in honest historical method forbids the conclusion that God acted. The rule that a natural cause must always win is a philosophy, not a finding. Weighed fairly, the evidence for the resurrection of Christ is strong, and it leads to the confession of the Church: Christ is risen from the dead.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close