Verses 1–3
1 "Lo, mine eye hath seen all this, mine ear hath heard and understood it. 2 What ye know, the same do I know also: I am not inferior unto you. 3 Surely I would speak to the Almighty, and I desire to reason with God."
Lo, mine eye hath seen all this,
mine ear hath heard and understood it [1].
* See how, even in his humility, what he proclaimed was symbolic, led by the prophetic Spirit, who reveals to him what is higher. For he says, "Mine eye hath seen all this"; it is clear that he speaks a prophetic vision. "Mine ear hath heard it": the one whom God finds holy He chooses to hear His mysteries.
Fr. Hesychius of Jerusalem * "And understood it"... When something is seen or heard about without understanding being granted to the man, it is no longer a prophetic vision. Pharaoh saw in a dream things that were to happen to Egypt, but he could not understand what he saw, and he was not a prophet. King Belshazzar saw the fingers of a hand writing on the wall, yet he was not a prophet, because he did not obtain the understanding of what he saw.
Pope Gregory (the Great)
What ye know, the same do I know also:
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
I am not inferior unto you [2].
The humble Job was obliged to defend himself and to praise himself, as the Apostle Paul did later, when some groups in Corinth made the accusation that he was not an apostle.
Here Job affirms that he is not inferior to them, and that what they know he knew also; in these circumstances he does not need sermons and discussions, but love, care and prayers to support him.
* May we not be strenuous in debate and slothful in our prayers (for them). Let us pray, dear beloved, let us pray that God may give us grace, even for our enemies, and especially for our brethren and loved ones.
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
St. Augustine Surely I would speak to the Almighty, and I desire to reason with God [3].
He turned away from his friends and turned toward God, for he found no rest in speaking with them; therefore he wanted to speak with the Almighty, for to be judged before God is better than to fall into the hand of a man. To enter into dialogue with God is easier than dialogue with friends. As David said to Gad the prophet: "I am in a great strait: let us fall now into the hand of the LORD; for his mercies are great: and let me not fall into the hand of man" (2 Sam 24:14; 1 Chr 21:13).
* I also know the infinite greatness of God, the unlimited wisdom of the Creator, and His amazing power; but with this knowledge [I desire to speak to the Lord], for I know His righteousness. Since He is righteous, He bears with those who speak with Him without being accused. For if He does not wish this, I will be silent, since I know what I am bound to as one who receives the honor of being His servant. By His command "I speak," and I dare to the point of accusing God.
Fr. Hesychius of Jerusalem * I will not cease speaking with God, for am I speaking with a man? I speak with God, who knows the secrets of my thoughts.
He says that it is a matter of great value to be judged before God rather than to be judged before them.
St. John Chrysostom * We speak to the Almighty when we ask for His tenderness, and we argue with Him (are judged before God) when we unite with Him in His righteousness and examine our works with careful inquiry. Perhaps by arguing with God he means that whoever obeyed God's commandments here will come with Him as a judge when He judges the people (Mt 19:28)... Therefore the Lord also says through Isaiah: "Relieve the oppressed, judge the fatherless, plead for the widow. Come now, and let us reason together" (Isa 1:17-18).
For it is right that they should plead with God concerning the charges in the judgment, those who at (hearing) the words of God utterly renounce the present world. Thus speaking with Him is fulfilled by prayer, and pleading with Him by judgment.
Therefore the saint speaks here with the Almighty, so that he may afterward plead with Him (at the time of the general judgment), when he comes afterward with God as a judge, he who clings to the Almighty here by prayer.
As for the holy Church, to which we said before that Job bears a likeness that is to come, she not only judges the wicked when the time of the final judgment arrives, but even now does not cease to judge all, whether those who walk in evil or those who think foolishly.
Pope Gregory (the Great)
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
Verses 4–8
4 "But ye are forgers of lies, ye are all physicians of no value. 5 O that ye would altogether hold your peace! and it should be your wisdom. 6 Hear now my reasoning, and hearken to the pleadings of my lips. 7 Will ye speak wickedly for God? and talk deceitfully for him? 8 Will ye accept his person? will ye contend for God?"
But ye are forgers of lies,
ye are all physicians of no value [4].
Job complains of his friends, because they judged him and condemned him according to their false notions and their lack of understanding of God's providence and care and His plan for mankind. Therefore they became forgers of lies. They uttered falsehood and fabricated false accusations against him.
They came to him as physicians to attend to his wounds, but in truth they were physicians of no value; they did not know the disease, so the treatment turned out deadly. They changed from wise physicians into charlatan quacks. They claimed science and knowledge, while in complete ignorance of the divine truth, because they had lost love.
Job did not accept his brothers as physicians offering him the cure, looking instead to the coming Messiah, as the heavenly Physician of souls and bodies, who heals the eyes of our souls so that they enjoy the vision of divine things.
Wonderful is our heavenly Physician, for when He declared Himself a physician He was eating in the house of a tax collector, with many tax collectors and sinners gathered around Him. He did not preach to them nor rebuke them for their sins, but He ate with them (Lk 5:27-32). I do not think I would find a doctor who enters a hospital and invites all the patients to eat with him, then leaves them and goes out of the hospital without giving them medicines specific to their diseases to heal them.
The Lord gave the medicine when He ate with them, for He gave them practical love; He ate with those whom society loathed and did not even want to deal with, lest it be defiled. The Holy One stretches out His hand and eats with them, so that they may realize that their Savior is not far from them, nor aloof from them. This is the heavenly medicine that the heavenly Physician offered. He is a unique Physician and His medicine is unique!
And the wonder is that He declared His person thus as a physician at the very moments when He declared that His disciples are the children of the bridechamber, or friends of the Bridegroom. As though those who work with Him have as their work to receive the mysteries of the Bridegroom, so as to proclaim His person, His characteristics and His abilities to the bride: the humanity that accepts faith in Him. As though those who work with the Physician have no work except preparing for the joyful heavenly wedding.
The work of the servant of the Lord Christ, and of all leaders, indeed of every Christian, is to contribute to the preparation for this wedding, not by rebuke, reproof and condemnation, but by revealing the love of the Bridegroom and His coming down to His bride, and opening the doors of heaven, her bridal chamber, to her. For the bride is prepared for her Bridegroom by discovering her Bridegroom's love for her and His longing for her.
* You are harmful physicians who renew the diseases, [you renew evil], you who do not bring healing from the wounds by using very fitting remedies. So you think that you are defending God, and that your mouth utters pleasing words; yet you see evils in the one placed on trial, and you come to help the enemy by stirring up feelings of pain in the wounded.
Fr. Hesychius of Jerusalem * The heavenly Guide, the Logos, is called the Leader when He calls mankind to salvation... But when He works as a physician or trainer, His name becomes "the Instructor"... For the sick soul needs an instructor who heals its passions. Then it needs the Teacher who gives it understanding... "the revelation of the Logos." Thus, since the Logos wishes our salvation step by step, He uses an excellent method: at first He leads, then He corrects, and finally He teaches.
* Who is He? Learn briefly that He is the Word of truth, the Word of incorruption, who renews man by restoring him to the truth. He is the goad that urges to salvation. He is the destroyer of perdition and the driver away of death. He builds the temple of God in men, taking them for God as a dwelling.
The sick need a savior, the lost need a guide, the blind need one who leads them to the light, the thirsty need the living fountain from which whoever drinks will never thirst, the dead need life, the sheep need a shepherd, and children need a teacher; all mankind needs Jesus!
St. Clement of Alexandria * Blessed indeed are those who in their need of the Son of God have gone beyond the need of Him as a physician to heal their diseases, or as a shepherd, or as a redeemer, and whose need of Him has become need of Him as Wisdom and as Logos, or as one of the other titles He offers to those who have the spiritual Pascha that prepares them for the highest graces.
* Within the divinity of the Word there is power, not only to help and heal those who are sick..., but to reveal mysteries to those who are pure in body and mind.
The Word was sent as a physician to sinners, and also as a teacher to those who are already pure and without sin.
* By the light of the Word the darkness of heretical teachings is dispelled. For the Word opens the eyes of our souls, so that we can distinguish between light and darkness, and in every case choose to remain in the light.
* He who seeks healing has no course but to follow Jesus.
* Come now to Jesus, the heavenly Physician.
Enter this clinic, which is His Church.
Look. There lie great numbers of the weak. You find a woman seeking cleansing (Mk 5:25; Lev 12). You also find a leper isolated "without the camp" because of the defilement of his leprosy (Mk 1:40; Lev 13:46).
They seek healing from the Physician, asking how they may become healthy and how they may be cleansed.
Jesus the Physician is Himself the Word of God. He prepares medicines for His patients, not from preparations of herbs, but from the holy things of words.
If someone looks at those medicines of words scattered without order in the folds of the books, and does not know the power of the individual words, he may perhaps turn from them as cheap things lacking eloquence. But he who knows that the medicine of souls is in Christ will certainly understand from these books that are read in the Church how every person must gather useful herbs from the fields and mountains, I mean the power of the words, so that he who is troubled in soul may obtain healing, not by the power of the outer branches (of medicinal plants) and the surface bark, so much as by the effectiveness of the inner sap.
* There are also many other things hidden from us, known only to Him who is the Physician of our souls. For as regards our bodily health, we find it sometimes necessary to take disagreeable and bitter medicines as a cure for diseases we have brought upon ourselves through food and drink. So it happens if the nature of the disease requires harsh treatment with the surgeon's knife in a painful operation. Yes, and if the disease happens to extend beyond the effect of these remedies, recourse is had in the end to where the disease must be cauterized with fire. How can we realize that God, our Physician, desires to wash away the diseases of our souls that many sins and crimes have brought upon us, and uses a corrective treatment of similar kinds that may extend to the point of imposing the punishment of fire on those who have lost the health of their souls.
Origen * First, that you may realize God's condescension. Condescend and be humble for your own sakes, looking to God who condescended in humility also for your sake and not for His own...
Confess your weakness; and lie before the Physician in patience.
When you realize His condescension you are lifted up with Him, not by His raising Himself as the Word, but rather by being understood by you more and more...
He does not increase, but you are the ones who advance, so that He is as one who has risen with you...
Look at the tree: it first sends its roots down so that it may grow upward. It fixes its lower root in the earth so that its top may extend to heaven. Does it make any effort to grow except through humility? Then "that Christ may dwell in your hearts by faith; that ye, being rooted and grounded in love... might be filled with all the fulness of God" (Eph 3:17-19).
St. Augustine * We see that the Holy Scripture does not present the Lord to us under one name, nor only under the names assigned to His divinity or indicating His greatness; sometimes it uses the distinctions of nature (His hypostatic properties), and knows to say: [the name which is above every name] (Phil 2:9), the name of the Son, and the true Son, and the only-begotten God the Son, and the power of God and His wisdom and His Word. And sometimes, considering the multitude of ways by which grace comes to us, which in His goodness He grants to those who seek it according to His wisdom of many aspects, Scripture calls Him by many other titles. It calls Him at one time the Shepherd, at another the King, then the Physician, the Bridegroom, the Way, the Door, the Fountain, the Bread, the Axe and the Rock. These names do not indicate the nature, as I said, but the multiplicity of the activity that He exerts, out of mercy to each one of His creatures, and in answer to the need of everyone who asks Him.
St. Basil the Great * There is one Physician, who is at the same time flesh and spirit (man and God), begotten γεννητός: gennetos, and unbegotten, God become man. True life in death (in a mortal body), He was mortal (in the flesh) and is now immortal (by His resurrection), of Mary and of God, He is Jesus Christ our Lord.
St. Ignatius Theophorus * Let us then worship Him as God, believing in His becoming man, for what profit is there in saying of Him that He is a man and not God, or what salvation is there for us if we refuse to confess His humanity along with His divinity? Let us confess His presence, for He is King and Physician. For Jesus the King, having become a Physician, girded Himself with the linen of our humanity, and healed what was sick. The perfect Teacher of babes became a babe among them (Rom 2:20), that He might give wisdom to the foolish. The Bread of heaven came down to earth to feed the hungry!
* "Jesus" means "Savior," but in Greek it means "the Healer," for He is the Physician of souls and bodies, the Healer of spirits; He opened the eyes of the man born blind, and led minds to the light. He heals the visibly lame, and leads sinners in the way of repentance. He says to the paralytic: "Sin no more," and also: "Take up thy bed, and walk," because the body was paralyzed because of the sin of the soul. He served the soul first so that He might extend healing to the body.
Therefore if any of you is suffering in soul because of his sins, you will find Him a physician for you. And if any of you is of little faith, let him say to Him: "Help thou mine unbelief" (Mk 9:24).
And if any of you is afflicted with bodily pains, let him not be unbelieving, but draw near, for Jesus heals such diseases, and let him know that Jesus is the Christ.
St. Cyril of Jerusalem * By the Physician's many medicines He grants healing... He binds up the wounds with firm commandments, and sends forth warmth when He forgives sins. He pricks the heart as wine does, when He announces His judgment. And he set him on his own beast (Lk 10:34); consider how He lifts you up (in Himself), since He bore our sins and suffered for us (Isa 53:4). The Shepherd also carried the lost sheep on His shoulders (Lk 15:5).
St. Ambrose O that ye would altogether hold your peace!
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
and it should be your wisdom [5].
They came to offer wise counsels, yet it appeared that they themselves rather needed someone to guide them and bring them into wisdom. The wisdom they lacked was that they should altogether hold their peace; their silence is more beneficial than vain, wounding speech. As the wise man says: "Even a fool, when he holdeth his peace, is counted wise: and he that shutteth his lips is esteemed a man of understanding" (Prov 17:28).
* [It would have been better, for God's sake, for you to keep silence, and it would be your wisdom] [5]... The wise man is not only one who speaks well, offering useful counsels and declaring what is beneficial and dignified for all, but also one who bridles himself (Jas 3:2)... He observes what David sang in the Psalms: [Set a watch, O LORD, before my mouth; keep the door of my lips. Incline not my heart to any evil thing, to practise wicked works with men that work iniquity] (Ps 141:3-4).
Let us withdraw completely from them, even if they sometimes think they are defending God, not with the intention of glorifying God, but to slander the one who dedicates himself to righteousness and to betray the soldier of goodness... For a man needs to flee from deceivers and their friendship, and turn his face away from their flattery. But men of goodness accept the rebuke that comes from them, and remember with dignity their malicious talk against them, for all things turn to their good and work for good (Rom 8:28), and soon they receive the praise of God the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit...
Job spoke, after losing all his wealth, as though he were in abundance.
Fr. Hesychius of Jerusalem * As in a house, when the door is shut, it is not known which members are hidden in it, so in general, if the fool keeps his peace (his silence), he hides whether he is wise or foolish. So it is when no work comes into the light, the mind speaks even if the man is silent. Therefore the saint, seeing his companions appear as what they are not, commands them to keep their peace (their silence), so that they may not be exposed for what they are. Thus it was said of Solomon: "Even a fool, when he holdeth his peace, is counted wise" (Prov 17:28).
Pope Gregory (the Great)
* [Set a guard, O Lord, before my mouth; keep the door of my lips] (Ps 141:3). He did not say "a fortified barrier," but [a fortified door]. A door is opened as well as shut. If this is a door, let it open and shut. It opens for the confession of sin, and shuts for the forgiveness of sin. For it is a door for protection, not for destruction.
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
St. Augustine Hear now my reasoning, and hearken to the pleadings of my lips [6].
He calls them to listen to him instead of vain talk. Although they did not interrupt him, they paid no attention to his words, nor did they give heed to the cries of his bitter soul. They thought they had defended God and spoken the truth, but without practical love they do not know God, nor do they perceive the truth.
* [Hear now my rebukes, and give ear to the judgment of my lips] [6]. Well does he begin first by offering rebuke and afterward "judgment." For unless the fool's pride is quenched, he cannot at all understand the judgment of the righteous.
Pope Gregory (the Great)
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
Will ye speak wickedly for God? and talk deceitfully for him? [7]
Job mocks them because they thought that God needed them to defend Him and to reveal His justice. As though he says to them: Who are you, weak ones without love, that you should defend the divine truth, which is inseparable from love?
Under the pretext of defending divine justice they spoke deceit, and made false accusations against Job, and counted him wicked, and so fell into lying, cruelty, injustice and wronging their brother. And they justify all this by saying that it is "for God." They did not realize that "the wrath of man worketh not the righteousness of God" (Jas 1:20).
They justified their evil conduct toward Job as being to achieve a lofty aim, namely the defense of God. Does a good end justify an evil means? As though they were saying: "Let us do evil, that good may come" (Rom 3:8). God rebuked those who hate their brethren while they praise God: "Your brethren that hated you, that cast you out for my name's sake, said, Let the LORD be glorified: but he shall appear to your joy, and they shall be ashamed" (Isa 66:5).
He who has fellowship with God, the Truth, cannot practice deceit and lying, unless a man has turned aside from God, who cannot endure deceit. The Psalmist often puts deceit on the same level as the shedding of blood, because its aim is the destruction of the souls of others and their possessions or honor; and the deceiver destroys himself, and deprives himself of glory and eternal blessedness.
"Thou shalt destroy them that speak leasing: the LORD will abhor the bloody and deceitful man" (Ps 5:6).
"Blessed is the man unto whom the LORD imputeth not iniquity, and in whose spirit there is no guile" (Ps 32:2).
"Keep thy tongue from evil, and thy lips from speaking guile" (Ps 34:13).
"But thou, O God, shalt bring them down into the pit of destruction: bloody and deceitful men shall not live out half their days; but I will trust in thee" (Ps 55:23).
"He that worketh deceit shall not dwell within my house: he that telleth lies shall not tarry in my sight" (Ps 101:7).
"What doth he give thee? or what doth he add unto thee, thou deceitful tongue?" (Ps 120:3).
"A false balance is abomination to the LORD: but a just weight is his delight" (Prov 11:1).
"The wicked worketh a deceitful work: but to him that soweth righteousness shall be a sure reward" (Prov 11:18).
"He that speaketh truth sheweth forth righteousness: but a false witness deceit" (Prov 12:17).
"Deceit is in the heart of them that imagine evil: but to the counsellors of peace is joy" (Prov 12:20).
"The wisdom of the prudent is to understand his way: but the folly of fools is deceit" (Prov 14:8).
"A true witness delivereth souls: but he that speaketh lies is deceit" (Prov 14:25).
"Weight and weight is an abomination to the LORD, and deceitful balances are not good" (Prov 20:23).
"The sacrifice of the wicked is abomination: how much more, when he bringeth it with a wicked mind" (Prov 21:27).
"He that hateth dissembleth with his lips, and layeth up deceit within him" (Prov 26:24).
"For the holy spirit of discipline will flee deceit, and remove from thoughts that are without understanding, and will not abide when unrighteousness cometh in" (Wis 1:5).
"Yea, speedily was he taken away, lest that wickedness should alter his understanding, or deceit beguile his soul" (Wis 4:11).
"Bring not every man into thine house: for the deceitful man hath many trains" (Sir 11:31).
*Do you not speak before the Lord, and utter deceit before Him, despite your splendid words? This is what he wishes to say: you do not believe that God listens to what you say, because deceit dictates your dialogue. No good motive moves you, but the desire to harm my reputation and to make wounding comments. For even if your words are proper, you do not express a good intention by them; they do not seek correction, reform and progress, but seek destruction, for you are not teaching a man who is wholly ignorant.
St. John Chrysostom * [Hath God need of your lie, that ye speak deceitfully for him?] God has no need of a lie, for the truth does not accept being accomplished with the help of falsehood... The heretics speak deceit for Him, deceiving those of weak minds, misleading their concepts of God in a foolish manner.
Pope Gregory (the Great)
In St. Augustine's commentary on (Ps 55:23), he compares the shedders of blood with the deceiving heretics and those who speak deceit, and says that the shedders of blood are manifest murderers who shed the blood of bodies and do not kill souls, whereas the heretics destroy souls and shed their invisible blood. They are bloody and deceitful men!
In his commentary on the Psalmist's question and answer: [What doth he give thee, and what is set before thee against the deceitful tongue? Sharpened arrows of the mighty, with coals of desolation] (Ps 120:3-4), he sees that the opposition to those with deceitful tongues is not by mere words, but requires the word of God, the sharpened arrows of the mighty one, together with living examples of righteous persons who were like a lifeless, desolate desert and became burning like coals. He says: [It is not enough to answer them with words, but we also defend with examples... The word "coals" is used to express examples of many sinners who returned to the Lord. You hear people marveling and saying: "I know a man how addicted to drink he was, how base in his love of theaters and the circus and his love of deceit; now behold, he serves God, how innocent he has become!" Do not marvel, for he has become a living coal. Rejoice that he is alive, he for whom you grieved because he was dead.]
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
Will ye accept his person? will ye contend for God? [8]
God does not need defenders; in their defense they hate their brothers. "Will ye accept his person? will ye contend for God?" How do they serve God by hatred and loathing of their brothers? In their zeal for God, they insult God and rob Him of the seat of His judgment as the Judge of mankind. For He alone knows every soul and its strength and inclinations, and man's gifts, his biological makeup, his energies and the circumstances surrounding him. On the basis of all this He is the One who condemns or justifies. Truly we may know a man who committed a certain sin, perhaps obvious, needing no investigation; but can we judge the man as a whole because of a sin or sins he committed at one time, when we do not know his depths or his circumstances?!
* [Will ye accept his person? will ye contend for God?] [8] For when fools see the deeds of the wise, they all appear to them to be worthy of blame. They forget their own emptiness and shortcomings, and judge the conduct of others with greater zeal... On the other hand, when the righteous rebuke the conduct of the wicked, they always acknowledge their own weaknesses and that they themselves deserve blame. For even if they rebuke and rush strongly to resist the evils of others from outside, yet they sympathize with them inwardly, realizing that the examination of men's sins belongs to God... Therefore the friends of blessed Job rebuked his deeds as though they themselves had done nothing blameworthy.
Well was it said here: [Will ye accept his person? will ye contend for God?] For a person to put on the face of God means that he claims for himself His authority to condemn; and a person contends for God when he rebukes the weak points in others and does not feel his own inward weakness.
Pope Gregory (the Great)
* An elder said: "If no one knows what is in a man save his spirit, as the Apostle says, and if we know that many have repented and we did not know of their repentance, then a man may repent at the end of his life, and be accepted like the repentance of the thief; so you must not judge anyone. For the Judge is God alone, so how can anyone dare to intervene in what belongs to God?!"
The Garden of the Monks * Do not be a judge of your brother, that you may be made worthy of forgiveness. Perhaps you always see him as wrong, but you do not know with what ending he departs the world. The thief crucified with Jesus was a murderer and a shedder of blood, and Judas was a disciple of Christ and among the intimates, since the purse was with him; yet in a short time they changed, so the thief entered Paradise, and the disciple deserved the gallows and perished.
St. Anastasius * Look, my brothers: the work of the servants at the wedding of the king's son (Mt 22) was nothing but drawing the good and the wicked to the feast. The Lord did not say of them that they judged those invited and distinguished between the good and the wicked, nor did He say of them that they found one who did not have a wedding garment; rather the king himself was the one who saw him, the master of the house alone discovered him and cast him out.
St. Augustine * If you see a man who has sinned and you see him on the morrow, do not look at him as a sinner, for you do not know whether in the period of your absence from him he has done something good after the fall; rather, plead with the Lord with sighs and bitter tears, entreating Him!
St. Ephraim the Syrian
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
Verses 9–12
9 "Is it good that he should search you out? or as one man is deceived, do ye deceive him? 10 He will surely reprove you, if ye do secretly accept persons. 11 Shall not his excellency make you afraid? and his dread fall upon you? 12 Your speeches are like ashes, and your strongholds are strongholds of clay."
Is it good that he should search you out? or as one man is deceived, do ye deceive him? [9]
It is for their good, and better for them, that God should search their hearts and reveal to them their hatred of their brothers and their loathing of the truth, than that they should cloak themselves with an outward defense of God, and so deceive Him (beguile Him unawares) as a man is deceived.
* Every innovator is, in relation to God, "an enemy and a defender," for in his struggle and in the way of his defense of God he resists the truth. But nothing can escape the sight of God, for He judges according to the thoughts of the heart rather than the outward appearance in which he seems to be one who serves God.
Pope Gregory (the Great)
* How do they resist the truth except by the vanity of their pride, exalted in vain? While they set themselves up on high as great and righteous men, they pass away like empty air.
St. Augustine * If anyone objects to the existence of heretics now, let him remember that it has been so from the beginning, since Satan was always setting up error over against the truth. In the beginning God promised good things, and Satan too made his promise. God established Paradise, and Satan deceived man by saying: [Ye shall be as gods] (Gen 3:5); for if he was unable to provide a work, he offered promises which are rather words, and this is the nature of deceivers.
After this came Cain, and with him Abel; the sons of Seth, and with them the daughters of men; Ham, and with him Japheth; Abraham (and in his days) there was Pharaoh; Jacob, and with him Esau.
And so came Moses (and Aaron), and the two magicians arose.
The prophets, and with them the false prophets.
The apostles and the false apostles; Christ, and the Antichrist will come.
This is what was before, and what has happened up to that day... In brief, there was never a time when falsehood did not exist to stand against the truth. So do not be troubled.
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
St. John Chrysostom He will surely reprove you, if ye do secretly accept persons [10].
In rebuking Job in this spirit filled with hatred, they became respecters of persons, even if secretly; therefore they are not counted in the eyes of God worthy of praise, but of severe reproof. God abhors the hatred concealed under the defense of God and of His glory and Kingdom. Perhaps by respect of persons he meant that they used to honor him, perhaps with exaggeration, for his wealth, and for no reason their conduct completely changed when he became poor and lost his social position and his authority as a king or leader, and also all his money. Scripture has warned us against partiality.
"Wherefore now let the fear of the LORD be upon you; take heed and do it: for there is no iniquity with the LORD our God, nor respect of persons, nor taking of gifts" (2 Chr 19:7).
"These things also belong to the wise. It is not good to have respect of persons in judgment" (Prov 24:23).
"To have respect of persons is not good: for for a piece of bread that man will transgress" (Prov 28:21).
"For there is no respect of persons with God" (Rom 2:11).
"And, ye masters, do the same things unto them, forbearing threatening: knowing that your Master also is in heaven; neither is there respect of persons with him" (Eph 6:9).
"But he that doeth wrong shall receive for the wrong which he hath done: and there is no respect of persons" (Col 3:25).
"I charge thee before God, and the Lord Jesus Christ, and the elect angels, that thou observe these things without preferring one before another, doing nothing by partiality" (1 Tim 5:21).
"My brethren, have not the faith of our Lord Jesus Christ, the Lord of glory, with respect of persons" (Jas 2:1).
"And if ye call on the Father, who without respect of persons judgeth according to every man's work, pass the time of your sojourning here in fear" (1 Pet 1:17).
Pope Gregory (the Great) says that God is the searcher of the secrets of hearts and nothing is hidden from Him (1 Cor 4:5); for it may happen that under the cover of defending the truth, some blame the righteous man, and show partiality to those who stand against the righteous, while they stand on the side of those who blaspheme God. These claim that they glorify God, while they bear no sincerity in their conduct. They are like the demons who said to the Lord Christ: [Thou art the Son of God] (Mk 3:11); in this they do not seek His glory, but are terrified of what will come upon them.
* What benefit comes to you from honoring (showing partiality to) the rich man? Is it because he is better prepared to keep the love of others for him? So we do kindness to those from whom we expect that they will repay us for it. We must think rather of the weak and needy, because for the sake of these we hope for recompense from the Lord Jesus, who in the example of the wedding feast (Lk 14:12-13) gave us a general picture of virtue. For He asked us to give our works rather to those who are not able to repay us.
* If the Kingdom of God is for the poor, who is richer than they?
St. Ambrose * All are equal before God; only the rank of each is raised according to his faith, and not according to his money.
St. Augustine * Many rebuke me, saying: You are always pressing hard on the rich, and they in turn press hard on the poor.
Well, I do press hard on the rich, or rather not on the rich, but on those who misuse money. I do not attack their persons but their greed. Wealth is one thing, and greed is another; having a surplus is one thing, and covetousness is another.
Are you rich? I do not forbid you this. Be rich. Are you greedy? I warn you... I will not be silent.
Do you attack me because of this? I am ready for my blood to be shed, but I want to keep you from sinning. I bear you no hatred, nor do I wage war on you, but I want one thing only, the benefit of those who listen to me.
The rich are my children, and the poor are also my children. One womb (Baptism) brought them forth in great travail. All are the offspring of her who travailed with them. So if you heap insults on the poor man, I warn you, because the poor man in this case suffers no loss like yours. For he does not fall into error; the loss that befalls him is merely the loss of money, whereas you, as a rich man, suffer loss in your spirit.
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
St. John Chrysostom Shall not his excellency make you afraid? and his dread fall upon you? [11]
Job warns them about their improper conduct, for while they think they are defending God, they fall under His wrath, because they walk in evil, and the awe of His majesty and His dread fall upon them.
* Now the righteous perceive the awe of God before His wrath is stirred up against them. They fear Him while He is calm (toward them), lest they be compelled to feel Him when He moves in anger. On the other hand, the wicked are terrified of Him for the first time when they are struck with the rod, and terror raises them from the sleep of their torpor, as vengeance disturbs them. So it was said by the prophet: [Vexation alone will be the support for understanding what they hear] (cf. Isa 28:19). For when they begin to fall under the blows of vengeance because of their contempt for God's commandments and their neglect of them, they understand what they hear. The Psalmist says: "When he slew them, then they sought him" (Ps 78:34)...
Pope Gregory (the Great)
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
Your speeches are like ashes, and your strongholds are strongholds of clay! [12]
Job's friends boasted that they were defenders of God and His justice and His judgments, and behold all their talk is like ashes, trifling and worthless; the wind blows and the ashes vanish. Their thoughts fly away from their earthy bodies; they pass away, and their human wisdom passes with them. They do not heap up wisdom for time, but heaps of clay, from which the children of God want deliverance.
He likens their talk to dust, because it rests on earthly, transient thoughts, and does not depend on heavenly, eternal wisdom. They fortify themselves with human logic, which cannot protect them except for moments.
* [Their remembrance is like ashes] [12]. All who are shaped by the present condition have earthly thoughts, for in all they do they leave a temporary memorial of themselves in the world. Some strive in war, others by erecting towering buildings, and some by recording books that bear the experiences of this world. They toil and struggle and build in order to set up a memorial to their names. But since life runs swiftly toward its end, what can endure in it, when nature itself is swiftly falling away?
A breath of wind scatters the ashes, as it is written: "The ungodly are not so: but are like the chaff which the wind driveth away" (Ps 1:4). Rightly the remembrance of the foolish is compared to ashes, since its place is to be scattered by a breath of wind. The more a man toils to gain glory for his name, the more he places his remembrance, which is like ashes, in the gusts of the winds of mortality that hasten to a moment. In contrast to this it is written of the righteous: "The righteous shall be in everlasting remembrance" (Ps 112:6). For by the very circumstances in which he impresses his works on the eyes of God alone, his name remains fixed for his remembrance in the eternal world.
* [And your bodies to bodies of clay] [12]... Thus the neck is brought down to clay, when every proud man goes down to death, and the body that was lifted up in corruption is dissolved. Let us consider the corpses of the rich lying in their graves, what kind of death has come upon the lifeless body, what is the stench of its corruption!
Pope Gregory (the Great)
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
Hold your peace from me, that I may speak, and let come on me what may [13].
If Job was struck with trials of this magnitude, they are lighter than what befell him from the words of his friends. His trials will not condemn him but vindicate him, whereas their wicked words, their lying and their hatred are greater misfortunes than any disaster or calamity!
It is fitting for them to be silent, for they are lovers of profitless dispute. Let Job speak, and reveal to them what they are, even if he speaks while sitting on the dunghill, wearing a garment of the worms around him.
Job does not care what befalls him: "and let come on me what may," and however they interpret these calamities, and think the worst of him, all this will not stop the testimony of his conscience, which he gives with all uprightness and integrity.
* [Hold your peace from me a little, that I may speak what my mind dictates to me] [13]. It appears that they spoke with a fleshly understanding, those whom he requires to be silent, so that he may speak as his mind dictates to him. As though he says in plain words: I do not speak in a fleshly manner but spiritually, for I hear with spiritual understanding the things that I present through the service of the flesh.
Pope Gregory (the Great)
* When you meet a man who loves disputes and begins to argue with you about what is self-evident and true, cut off the conversation and withdraw quickly, for his mind has turned to stone.
For as water spoils the finest wines, so foolish discussions spoil those who are virtuous in their conduct and in their characters.
St. Anthony the Great
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
Verses 14–19
14 "Wherefore do I take my flesh in my teeth, and put my life in mine hand? 15 Behold, he slayeth me; I have no hope: only I will justify my way before him. 16 This also shall be my salvation, that the ungodly shall not come before him. 17 Hear diligently my words, and my declaration in your ears. 18 Behold now, I have ordered my cause; I know that I shall be justified. 19 Who is he that will contend with me, that now I should hold my peace and give up the ghost?"
Wherefore do I take my flesh in my teeth, and put my life in mine hand? [14]
Perhaps Job wishes to bring out his desire to bear witness to the truth under all circumstances, not only when he was torn by his calamities, but even if he tore his body with his teeth, and put his life on his palm to hand it over to death; all this will not make him silent about revealing his innocence in the Lord, and about his friends' wrong interpretation of the events.
* It means: why should I condemn myself severely before men, or show what my heart inclines to, since there is no edification of my neighbor in this, whether by condemning my evils or by displaying my good?
Pope Gregory (the Great)
* He says: I am like those who find consolation in devouring themselves; like those who bite their bodies hard, experiencing a kind of relief of their pains; this is what happens with me when I express myself in this way.
St. John Chrysostom * This is the reason that he takes his flesh in his teeth, their vain, provoking words. He speaks in anger, and wants to calm himself.
Fr. Hesychius of Jerusalem Pope Gregory (the Great) sees that the teeth here refer to the inner senses, which chew what occupies the mind and present it to the belly of memory. [Therefore it was rightly said: "Every man that eateth the sour grape, his teeth shall be set on edge" (Jer 31:30). What is the sour grape but sin? The sour grape is fruit before its time. So whoever desires to be satisfied with the pleasures of the present life is like one who hastens to eat fruit before its time. Therefore the teeth of him who eats the sour grape are set on edge, that is, while he feeds on the delight of the present life he has perceptions unable to eat, that is, unable to perceive spiritual things. For the same reason, since they delight in outward things they become dull of sense with regard to inward things, and while the soul feeds on sin it is unable to eat the bread of righteousness. And since the teeth are bound to the habit of sin, they will not be able to chew that goodness so as to listen within.]
As though Job, wishing to take outward things (his flesh) in spiritual meanings, chews them with the teeth of his spirit to enjoy the spiritual pleasures that his friends do not accept, because they seek the glory of the world and the pleasures of the flesh. They oppose him and seek his destruction, for the carnal cannot endure the spiritual.
Behold, he slayeth me;
I have no hope;
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
only I will justify my way before him [15].
Job resolved to hold fast to his way, and was never willing to give up the rest he had found in walking uprightly with God, however great his afflictions, even to death. So he says with Hezekiah: "Remember now, O LORD, how I have walked before thee in truth and with a perfect heart" (2 Kgs 20:3). Even if trials drive me to my death, I remain trusting in Him, or full of hope in Him, that I may be vindicated before Him. I am His friend and He is my friend; I will not give up clinging to Him, even if He appears as an enemy to me who delivers me to trials unto death.
* [Though he slay me, yet will I trust in him] [15]... A man is truly patient when calamities befall him... Here the righteous mind is distinguished from the wicked; for in the midst of affliction, the former knows that the glory of Almighty God is not shaken by worldly events, and so does not collapse with the collapse of outward glory, but rather affirms that it is stronger when it loses temporal goods.
Pope Gregory (the Great)
* "For as the sufferings of Christ abound in us, so our consolation also aboundeth by Christ" (2 Cor 1:5)... He lifts up our souls by counting these sufferings as His own; what joy fills us to be partakers with Christ, for whose sake we suffer! By faith we perceive the new birth and the resurrection. Those who truly believe in the risen Jesus must offer themselves to sufferings. And those who share in His sufferings will also rise with Him. "That I may know him, and the power of his resurrection, and the fellowship of his sufferings, being made conformable unto his death; if by any means I might attain unto the resurrection of the dead" (Phil 3:10-11).
* The loving man who clings to God always is not harmed by waves, however many; on the contrary, he comes out of them with new strength. But the weak, slack man falls often, even when there is nothing to trouble him.
St. John Chrysostom * If as the sufferings of Christ abound, so also the consolation by Christ increases, let us welcome the encouraging sufferings of Christ. Let them overflow in us, if we truly seek the overflowing consolation with which all who mourn are comforted, even if it is not alike for everyone. For if the consolation were alike for everyone, it would not have been written that as the sufferings of Christ abound in us, so our consolation by Christ abounds exceedingly. Those who share in the sufferings will also share in the consolation, according to their fellowship in the sufferings of Christ.
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
Origen He also shall be my salvation: for an hypocrite (a hypocrite) shall not come before him [16].
He does not mean here temporal salvation, for his hope of deliverance from his trials in this world and of returning to what he had been was almost nonexistent; rather he hopes for his eternal salvation, where he will meet with God and see Him face to face. As for the secret of his confidence in his eternal salvation, it is that he knows that his relationship with God has in it no hypocrisy or deviation, for God does not cling to hypocrites, and will not allow them to stand before Him enjoying His glory.
* [For a hypocrite shall not come before him] [16]... We must keep in mind that we come before the Lord in two ways.
We call ourselves to account for our sins here, and judge ourselves before Him and punish ourselves with weeping. For whenever we remember our awareness of the power of our Creator, we are like those who stand before Him. Thus Elijah, the man of God, rightly said: [As the LORD God of Israel liveth, before whom I stand] (a).
The other way is that we come before God when we present ourselves before His judgment seat only at the last judgment. So the hypocrite, in the final reckoning, comes before the Judge; but since he shuts his eyes against looking at his sins here and lamenting them, he refuses to come before the Lord... And since his mind is corrupted by the words of praise directed to him, he does not call it to recognize sin, nor does he realize that he opposes the inward Judge, and does not fear His firmness... Thus his eyes are not directed to the firmness of God, since he is greedy to please the eyes of men.
* [But I reprove my ways before him, he shall be my salvation] [15]. The Apostle Paul says: "For if we would judge ourselves, we should not be judged" (1 Cor 11:31). The Lord is our salvation insofar as we reprove our sins in the fear of God.
Pope Gregory (the Great)
* I will judge myself, so that He may not judge me, who afterward will judge the living and the dead (2 Macc 7:18-19).
St. Augustine * [Consider yourself, then] until you attain the vision of God.
St. Basil the Great * Let this be your first concern, that you do not deceive yourself.
St. Melito, Bishop of Sardis * Hypocrisy is hateful to God and abhorred by men; it brings no reward, and is of no use at all for the salvation of the soul, but rather destroys it.
If anyone escapes by hypocrisy lest his affair be discovered, it is only for a while, for it does not last long, but everything is revealed, and brings shame upon its owner. Thus he is like an ugly woman whose outward adornment, put on her by artificial means, is stripped from her.
Hypocrisy is therefore foreign to the saints, for it is impossible that anything of what we do or say should escape the eyes of the Godhead, since it was said: [For there is nothing covered, that shall not be revealed; neither hid, that shall not be known] (Lk 12:2). If all our words and deeds will be revealed on the Day of Judgment, then hypocrisy is wearisome and without profit. It is fitting for us to be approved as true worshipers who serve God with sincere and open countenances.
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
St. Cyril the Great Hear diligently my speech, and my declaration with your ears [17].
He calls them again to cease their accusations and to give ear, so that they may enjoy with him the meeting with God through sincerity, purity and love.
Pope Gregory (the Great) sees that Job repeats the word "hear" because he wants them not to hear only with their outward ears, but also to listen with their inward ears, so that they may understand the depths of his words in a spiritual way.
Behold now, I have ordered my cause;
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
I know that I shall be justified [18].
He has no need of their testimony, for he has ordered his cause well before God, and has presented to Him the sincerity of his conscience and the purity of his heart, and so enjoys innocence through the grace of God.
* [Behold, I am very near my judgment, I know that I shall be found righteous]. This is the judgment of which it is said in another book: [He shall bring forth thy righteousness as the light, and thy judgment as the noonday] (b). But he did not say: [I am already so], but [I am very near]. For if the judgment he means was not so as he experienced it, it will be so on the last day, when all are judged, and those who pray sincerely are found righteous: [Forgive us our debts, as we forgive our debtors] (Mt 6:12). For through this forgiveness they are found righteous, since the sins they committed here are blotted out by the works of love they practiced (by their forgiveness of others).
St. Augustine * [Behold, I am near my Judge]. It is fitting for the adversary to have his tongue silenced, and for the Judge to be the one who speaks...
* [I know that I shall appear righteous], for I have fulfilled all the Law, and carried out all the commandments. I did not care about my unknown sins, and those I committed willingly, for I have washed them with prayer and tears. [I know that I shall appear righteous]. Although the enemy wishes to hide my righteousness by stirring up my companions to accuse me, even in this I shall appear righteous, when the veil of this present life is opened, while the clouds of the state of this life are corrupt; but even now I appear righteous as long as my patience stands to the end, and I shall show courage in trials to the very end.
Fr. Hesychius of Jerusalem Pope Gregory (the Great) sees that what blessed Job said about himself carries humility, for God Himself testified of him that there is none like him on the earth, and there is a great difference between God's testimony to him and Job's saying about himself in his dispute with his friends, who had become his accusers that he was righteous. He refused to describe himself as greater than others, contenting himself with justifying himself against the accusations of his companions.
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
Who is he that will contend with me, that now I should hold my peace and give up the ghost? [19]
In assurance of God's wide mercies to sincere believers, he does not care about their contention, nor does he fear divine discipline, but in tranquility gives up his spirit and finds eternal rest.
Job presents to us a living picture of the Christian who enjoys a true vision of the work of the Cross in his life, how it freed him from the devil his adversary, and put him to shame, so that the enemy became under his feet. Thus he does not fear him nor tremble, but mocks him.
* Since he saw in his outward conduct no possibility for anyone to blame him, therefore in complete freedom he looks toward any accuser of his.
Pope Gregory (the Great)
* The spirits fall into grief, and since they want our destruction, they are destroyed by us with the same destruction they desire for us. But their defeat does not mean that they leave us for good...
When their strength perishes and they fail in their struggle with us, we say: [Let them be ashamed and put to shame that seek after my soul to destroy it; let them be turned backward and put to shame that rejoice at my hurt] (Ps 40:14). And Jeremiah also says: "Let them be confounded that persecute me, but let not me be confounded: let them be dismayed, but let not me be dismayed: bring upon them the day of evil, and destroy them with double destruction" (Jer 17:18), since no one can doubt that when we have overcome them they perish with a double destruction.
Fr. Serenus * If you say that the opposing power is very strong, and that evil has complete dominion over man, then you ascribe injustice to God when He judges men for their submission to Satan, because Satan is very strong and subjects mankind with an irresistible force. In this way you make Satan greater and stronger than the soul, and then you tell me not to submit to Satan. This is like a fight between a young man and a small child, where the child, when defeated, is condemned for his defeat. This is a great injustice!
St. Macarius the Great * The thoughts of Satan are merely a mental image of something (or a deed) that is evil, and what enables it to take possession of us, or even simply to approach our mind, is the weakness of our faith. For after we have received the commandment, that we cast away from us all distractions and keep our hearts with all vigilance (Prov 4:23), and seek the Kingdom of God which is within us, when the mind has abandoned the heart and the aim we are pursuing, we have at once made room for Satan's imaginations, and the mind has become lax in accepting any evil counsel.
Even to this extent, Satan has no authority to move our thoughts; otherwise he would not have pity on us, but would plant in us all kinds of evil thoughts and allow us no good. Rather, his power is limited to merely offering false counsel at the beginning of every thought, to test to which side our heart inclines: does it incline to his counsel or to God's counsel? For they are opposites.
St. Mark the Ascetic * We go out from the house of our old father... since we were by nature children of wrath, even as others, fixing our eyes upon the things above.
St. Paphnutius
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
Verses 20–22
20 "Only do not two things unto me: then will I not hide myself from thee. 21 Withdraw thine hand far from me: and let not thy dread make me afraid. 22 Then call thou, and I will answer: or let me speak, and answer thou me."
Only do not two things unto me: then will I not hide myself from thee [20].
With all that has befallen Job, he does not want to hide from the face of God like his father Adam, but wants to appear in His presence.
Although Job confesses his sins in more than one place, he wants to be always with God. "Make me to know my transgression and my sin. Wherefore hidest thou thy face, and holdest me for thine enemy?" (Job 13:23-24).
Job desired two things by which he might stand in the presence of the Judge, not in fear of trial, but before a loving Creator of His believers.
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
This is what drives him to long to stand before God, and not to wish to hide from His presence as our first parents did when they thought that the shade of the fig tree would hide them from their Creator. But what are these two things? He pointed to them in the following phrase [21].
* God Himself says through the prophet: "I am the God who is near, and not the God who is far off" (Jer 23:23) LXX.
Fr. Theodoret, Bishop of Cyrrhus * Wherever you are, God comes to you if He finds chambers in your soul in which He can dwell.
St. Gregory of Nyssa * The Holy Trinity is near to all things, but not all things are near to Him.
The so-called Dionysius the Areopagite * Let the living God be present always in your mind. For your mind itself is in His likeness, also invisible and incomprehensible, and not represented in any form, and yet by its will the whole body is moved.
St. Melito, Bishop of Sardis Withdraw thine hand far from me: and let not thy dread make me afraid [21].
Perhaps by the two things he meant the following: 1. "Withdraw thine hand far from me": perhaps he asked Him not to remove the trial from him, but to lighten it. In lightening it he finds his opportunity for calm and freedom from distress, so that he may be free to speak with God. He does not ask for relief of his pains to boast before his friends that he is not wicked as they claimed, for what concerns him is to stand in the presence of God. 2. Job knows the awe of God; this awe is a source of joy and delight to the faithful believer, and not a source of terror!
* [I need two things, and then I will not hide myself from thy face] [20]. What are the two things that Job needs from God; these two which, he says, if he obtains them he will not hide himself from the face of the Judge?
[Hold back thine hand from me, and let not thy fear terrify me] [21]... Of this David said: [Remove thy strokes from me; I am wasted by the might of thine hand] (Ps 39:10)... You are incorruptible, but I am corruptible (Rom 1:23). You are the Lord, and I am a servant, like a wrestler in training, like an armed soldier. You speak, and I answer; not in boldness do I oppose, but out of desire to obtain wisdom, and to learn through speaking and listening.
Fr. Hesychius of Jerusalem Pope Gregory (the Great) sees in these two requests, that He hold back His hand and not let His fear terrify him, a prophecy of the longing for the age of grace, in which the blows of divine wrath for breaking the Law do not befall believers, and in which believers no longer worship God through fear as in the Old Testament, but through love. [Righteousness cannot be perfected by fear, and according to the voice of John: [Perfect love casteth out fear] (1 Jn 4:18). And Paul offers rest to the children of adoption, saying: "For ye have not received the spirit of bondage again to fear; but ye have received the Spirit of adoption, whereby we cry, Abba, Father" (Rom 8:15). Therefore, in the voice of humanity longing for the removal of the severity of the stroke of the Law, and with a fervent desire to advance from fear to love, he specifies in prayer two things that God should remove from him, saying: [Withdraw thine hand far from me, and let not thy dread make me afraid]. Remove me from the severity of the stroke, lift the weight of terror; and when the grace of love shines upon me, pour upon me the spirit of assurance. If I am not removed from the rod and from the terror, I know that I shall not be withdrawn from the firmness of Your examination. He who serves You not on the basis of love but on the basis of fear cannot be justified before You.]
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
Then call thou, and I will answer: or let me speak, and answer thou me [22].
By these two things he is in the presence of God and enters into a delightful dialogue. God speaks and Job answers, and Job speaks and God answers. This is the mutual love between God and His believers. This is the wonderful boldness we have when we stand before the throne of divine grace.
* [Call me, and I will answer; or let me speak, and answer thou me]... God's call to us is His esteem of us in love and His choosing of us, and our answer is our submission in obedience to His love by good works... He who runs eagerly, longing for the eternal world, examines his works, sets himself to act with great precision, and examines himself thoroughly lest there be found in him anything by which he would oppose the face of his Creator.
Pope Gregory (the Great)
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
Verses 23–28
23 "How many are mine iniquities and sins? make me to know my transgression and my sin. 24 Wherefore hidest thou thy face, and holdest me for thine enemy? 25 Wilt thou frighten a driven leaf? and wilt thou pursue the dry stubble? 26 For thou writest bitter things against me, and makest me to possess the iniquities of my youth, 27 so that thou hast put my feet in the stocks, and lookest narrowly unto all my paths; thou hast dug upon the roots of my feet. 28 And I am like a thing that is consumed by decay, like a garment that is moth eaten."
How many are mine iniquities and sins?
Make me to know my transgression and my sin [23].
Now, standing in the presence of the Lord, Job asks God about his iniquities and sins, that He may reveal them to him, so that he may confess them and ask pardon for them in a spirit of humility, not fearing exposure before himself.
Pope Gregory (the Great) says that there is a difference between crimes and iniquities. Crimes are far heavier than the measure of sin, whereas iniquity does not exceed the weight of sin. When an offering is commanded according to the Law, it is without doubt imposed for "sin" and at the same time for "iniquity" also. A crime is not accomplished except by deed, while iniquity is usually committed in thought alone.
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
Wherefore hidest thou thy face, and holdest me for thine enemy? [24]
Job confesses that he is a sinner and iniquitous, but in a spirit of humility and repentance he asks his divine Savior not to hide His face from him, nor to count him an enemy; for with all his weaknesses and sins he will not cease to ask, that he may enjoy fellowship with God his Creator.
* [Why do You hide Your face, and count me Your enemy?] [24] Man enjoyed the light of inward contemplation in Paradise, but when he was pleased with himself he departed from himself. He lost the light of the Creator, and fled from His face to the trees of Paradise. After he had committed his sin, he feared to see Him whom he had formerly loved. But note that punishment was brought upon him after the sin, yet after the punishment he returned to love, for he found the results of his disobedience, and the Face which he feared while in sin, when he awoke to sound understanding, he began to seek anew through the punishment, in order to flee from the darkness of the state of blindness that had come upon him, and he drew back in terror from this solitude that kept him from seeing his Creator.
Pope Gregory (the Great)
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
Wilt thou frighten a driven leaf? and wilt thou pursue the dry stubble! [25]
Job entreats God, making himself very small before God and before himself, so he counts himself like a dry leaf of a tree that flies in haste and falls to the ground, and dry stubble moved by the winds... He is trodden down by his corrupt nature, so is it fitting for God's dignity that he who is already trodden down should be trodden down? Or to crush a person who has no power to resist?
"Thou carriest them away as with a flood; they are as a sleep: in the morning they are like grass which passeth away" (Ps 90:5).
"When the wicked spring as the grass, and when all the workers of iniquity do flourish; it is that they shall be destroyed for ever" (Ps 92:7).
"My days are like a shadow that declineth; and I am withered like grass" (Ps 102:11).
"As for man, his days are as grass: as a flower of the field, so he flourisheth" (Ps 103:15).
"Let them be as the grass upon the housetops, which withereth afore it groweth up" (Ps 129:6).
"Therefore their inhabitants were of small power, they were dismayed and confounded: they were as the grass of the field, and as the green herb, as the grass on the housetops, and as corn blasted before it be grown up" (Isa 37:27).
"For the sun is no sooner risen with a burning heat, but it withereth the grass, and the flower thereof falleth, and the grace of the fashion of it perisheth: so also shall the rich man fade away in his ways" (Jas 1:11).
"For all flesh is as grass, and all the glory of man as the flower of grass. The grass withereth, and the flower thereof falleth away" (1 Pet 1:24).
* [Has Your authority been shown over a leaf of a tree driven here and there? And will You follow the track of dry stubble (the remains of the harvest)?] [25]
What is man but a leaf that fell from the tree in Paradise?
What is he with whom the wind of temptation plays, whom the storms of his passions lift up, but a leaf of a tree?
The mind of man is stirred by many storms when he suffers temptations. So he is often stirred by anger. And when anger passes, empty merriment follows. He is drawn off by the goad of lust, lifted up by pride, and sometimes plunged by increasing fear to what is under the dust. Thus when a man sees himself raised and carried by many such storms of temptation, he becomes like a leaf of a tree. Therefore it was well said by Isaiah the prophet: [We all do fade as a leaf; and our iniquities, like the wind, have taken us away] (cf. Isa 64:6).
* We see that what we say passes away, while what we write remains; therefore it is said of God not only that He speaks but that He writes bitter things, since His blows upon us remain for a long time. Once it was said to the man who sinned: [Dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return] (c), and angels appeared many times and gave commandments to men. And Moses, the receiver of the Law, defined sins by firm means. And the Son of the Father, the Most High and Only-Begotten, came to save us. He swallowed up death by His death. He declared that He had shown eternal life for us in Himself. Yet this sentence that was passed in Paradise concerning the death of our body has remained unchanged from the beginning of the human race to the end of the world. For "What man is he that liveth, and shall not see death?" (Ps 89:48), and also: [Thou, even thou, art to be feared: and who may stand in thy sight when once thou art angry?] (Ps 76:7). For having been angry once when man sinned in Paradise, He established the sentence of death for our body.
Pope Gregory (the Great)
* [Their years are as things of no value; in the morning they are like grass which passeth away] (Ps 90:5).. Such are these things which did not exist before their coming, and when they come to be here they soon pass away, for they come here only to pass... They come to fall into death, and dry up in a carcass, and wither in the dust. What is this but the body in which are the hateful fleshly lusts?
* Those who do not think uprightly in their hearts look upon the wicked when they are like green grass, that is, when they are prospering for a time. Why do they look upon them? "That they shall be destroyed for ever." They look to their temporary prosperity and imitate them, and wish to prosper with them for a time, and perish with them for ever.
* While you say that in this age everything passes away like a shadow, you do not pass away like a shadow. "My days pass away like a shadow, and I am withered like grass".. But the grass, when it is moistened with the Savior's blood, flourishes again. I have become dry like grass; for as a man I have suffered from Your just judgment, because "Thou shalt arise, and have mercy upon Zion: for the time to favour her, yea, the set time, is come" (Ps 102:13).
* "As for man, his days are as grass" (Ps 103:15). Let man realize what he is; let no man boast. "His days are as grass." Why should the grass boast, which flourishes now and in a short time withers? Why should the grass boast, which blooms only for a brief period, until the sun grows hot? It is therefore good for us that His mercy come upon us, and make gold of the grass! [As a flower of the field, so he flourisheth] (d). All the loftiness of the human race, honors and powers and wealth and pride and threats, is the flower of grass. That house flourishes, and this family is great, and that family grows; how many flourish, and how many years do they live! To you they are many years, but to God it is a short time; God's reckonings are not like yours. Compared with the length of life through long ages, the flower of any house is like the flower of grass. Hardly does the beauty of the year last throughout the whole year. Everything that flourishes, everything that is filled with the warmth of heat, everything that is beautiful will not last, indeed will not remain even a full year...! He has sent us His Word, His Word who abides for ever... Do not marvel that you will share His eternity, for He shared your grass. Will He who took from you what is lowly begrudge giving you what is exalted?
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
St. Augustine For thou writest bitter things against me, and makest me to possess the iniquities of my youth [26].
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
In his talks with his friends, when he compares himself with mankind, he affirms that he is righteous and not wicked as his friends claim. And when he speaks with the Holy One he confesses the iniquities of his youth, and asks Him to explain to him why He leaves him to be consumed as by decay, or like a garment that the moth eats [28]!
He says to God: If You record my sins and falls, they are bitter, and I will not justify myself from them; and if You record my iniquities, they are the iniquities of my youth. I know them well and do not deny them, but I remember Your love, O Forgiver of sins and iniquities.
The prophet David asks the Teacher not to remember his sins but to remember him as His beloved creature, who has his own particular value, not through any merit of his own, but for the sake of God's mercies and goodness, and for His holy name. He says: "Remember not the sins of my youth, nor my transgressions: according to thy mercy remember thou me for thy goodness' sake, O LORD" (Ps 25:7). The thief on the right asked the true Teacher to remember him when He came into His kingdom, and He did not remember his crimes nor his sins, but carried him to Paradise, justified in the merits of the precious Blood. So when we ask the Lord to remember us, He answers, saying: "I, even I, am he that blotteth out thy transgressions for mine own sake, and will not remember thy sins" (Isa 43:25). St. Paul commands his disciple Timothy: "Flee also youthful lusts: but follow righteousness, faith, charity, peace, with them that call on the Lord out of a pure heart" (2 Tim 2:22).
* "Why hast thou written evil things against me, and chargest me with the sins of my youth?" (Job 13:26) LXX.
He truly and fittingly makes this period of life (youth) the cause of his complaint, because in general in this period a person is unsteady with regard to sin.
Truly childhood is marked by innocence, and old age by wisdom. And early manhood, which adjoins the stage of youth, is regarded as the stage of gaining a good reputation, and the person feels ashamed if he commits a sin. But the stage of youth alone bears the mark of weakness and feeble counsel, with zeal in sin, and contempt for those who offer them counsel, while they are prepared to be deceived by pleasures. For the same reason David wonderfully asked pardon from the Lord for all that he fell into in that period, when he said: [Remember not the sins of my youth, nor my ignorance] (Ps 25:7). For in that period the majority suffer from the inflammation of lusts and their burning with the heat of hot blood.
St. Ambrose * [Why do You write my evils against me? and charge me with the sins of my youth?] Concerning the writing, He said: "Cursed is the ground for thy sake; in sorrow shalt thou eat of it all the days of thy life; thorns also and thistles shall it bring forth to thee; and thou shalt eat the herb of the field; in the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat bread, till thou return unto the ground; for out of it wast thou taken: for dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return" (Gen 3:17-19). All mankind was condemned by all these, as though for a good reason these lines were written concerning the righteous and the wicked. In the same way God lays upon each one the sins of Adam's youth, for Adam was still young when he tasted the harmful food. This is the reason that not only he, but we also, his offspring, are prevented from gathering from the tree of life (Gen 3:22-24) which is in Paradise.
Fr. Hesychius of Jerusalem * [Remember not the sins of my youth, nor my ignorance] (Ps 25:7). My transgressions and my impudent boldness and my ignorance, do not keep them for vengeance, but forget them. "According to thy mercy remember thou me" (Ps 25:7). Truly remember me not according to the wrath that I deserve, but according to Your mercy that befits You... not according to my merits but according to Your goodness, O Lord.
St. Augustine so that thou hast put my feet in the stocks, and lookest narrowly unto all my paths; thou hast dug upon the roots of my feet [27].
I have been disciplined because of my weaknesses and the iniquities of my youth; I have become like a prisoner whose feet are put in the stocks, unable to move. I will not flee from the blows of Your discipline.
You know all my paths, and You discipline me even for my hidden thoughts or my wayward glances. You record on the soles of my feet all that I have committed, and I do not deny what I have done.
* [Thou hast put my feet in the stocks], because our feet have been prevented from walking to enjoy the benefits of Paradise. For God [looks narrowly at our works]. Concerning the disobedience of the commandment that Adam committed, God condemned the whole human race which is his offspring. In any case, since He is a doer of good and a lover of man (Wis 7:23), He [looks narrowly at our works]. If they are evil, we ascribe them to ourselves, as being in the likeness of the old Adam, and we fall under the discipline that came upon him. But if they are good works, we shall be saved from the curse, and set free from the penalties (2 Cor 11:4), in the likeness of the new Adam, and through Him we receive the annulment of our great distress.
Fr. Hesychius of Jerusalem * [Thou hast put my feet in the stocks]... This means: You have bound them. [You have dug upon the roots of my feet (my heels)] meaning that You attacked me wholly, and searched me to the depths; You struck my feet and my head, and left no part of me sound. Again, he speaks of the seriousness of his trial; he mocks the lowliness of nature.
St. John Chrysostom * God put man's foot in the stocks, in order to bind his evil entirely by a strong, firm judgment.
* [And thou lookest narrowly unto all my paths, thou settest a print upon the heels of my feet] [27]... The prints of the feet may be the many things that are done wrongly, for they perceive... Usually when we do wrong things and our brothers see them, we are a bad example to them, and our feet have turned aside from the way, and we leave all our crooked footprints to those who follow us, so that by our conduct we have led the consciences of others to stumbling.
But all these things Almighty God examines with precision, and weighs each of them in judgment. But when can man, bound as he is by the weakness of the flesh, have the power to stand against all these precisely and keep the straight line of the thought of the heart without moving? Therefore he says: [Who am I? As a rotten thing that consumeth, as a garment that is moth eaten] [28]... For man is like a rotten thing that perishes, for the corruption of his body scatters him. And because the temptation of uncleanness springs up in him from no other source than himself, like the moth, so temptation destroys the body, as the moth spoils the garment from what comes out of it; for man contains in himself the opportunity from which temptation comes forth, therefore the moth spoils the garment, while the moth comes forth from the garment itself.
Pope Gregory (the Great)
And I am like a thing that is consumed by decay, like a garment that is moth eaten [28].
Job confesses that he goes from corruption to corruption because of his sins, as though the worm had worn out his bones and the moth had eaten his garment (his body); his depths are corrupted by the worm of sin and his body worn out by the moth of iniquity... But there is One who rescues the soul from corruption, and gives the body eternal glory when the corruptible puts on incorruption, and the spiritual body takes the place of the earthly.
* If you wish, you can be a slave to the passions. And if you wish, you can be freed from them and not submit to their yoke, for God created you and gave you this authority.
He who overcomes the passions of the flesh is crowned with incorruption. For if there were no passions, there could be no virtues, and consequently God would not give crowns to those who deserve them.
* He who understands what the body is, that it is corruptible and short-lived, understands also that the soul is heavenly and immortal, that it is a breath from God, and is joined to the body until it advances and rises toward likeness to God.
St. Anthony the Great
I fall into Your hand, O my God,
Fr. Tadros Yacoub Malaty.
This verse has no separate interpretation.
Cross-references