Orthodoxia

Faith & Evidence / The Bible: transmission, authorship, canon and interpretation

Who wrote the Gospels, and how certain are the attributions?

IntermediateTextualAnswer available

Revision 1, updated

The answer

The Church has always known the four Gospels as the work of St Matthew the Apostle, St Mark, the companion of St Peter, St Luke, the companion of St Paul, and St John the Apostle, the disciple whom Jesus loved. The books do not sign their names in the text, as was common in ancient writing, but the names come to us early and without a rival. Papias, early in the second century, already connects Mark with Peter and speaks of Matthew’s work; Irenaeus, later in the same century, names all four. No one would invent Mark and Luke, who were not among the Twelve, to lend a book authority. The names are true memory, kept by the Church from the beginning.

  • Like many ancient books, the Gospels do not name their authors in the narrative; the names were attached to the books as they were read in the churches.
  • The Church has received the four Gospels under the names Matthew, Mark, Luke and John since at least the second century, and no rival set of names for these four survives.
  • St Luke describes himself in his prologue as a careful writer who drew on eyewitnesses; the Gospel of John says it rests on the testimony of the beloved disciple, and that his testimony is true.
  • Mark and Luke were not apostles. Names chosen merely to give authority would have been apostles’ names, so their presence points to real memory.
  • In the Coptic Orthodox Church, St Mark the Evangelist is also the apostle of Egypt and the founder of the See of Alexandria.
  • The Church received these Gospels from the apostolic generation and has read them in her worship ever since.

Why this question matters

Readers today often hear that the Gospels were written by unknown authors long after the events, and that the names were attached later to give them weight. It is worth seeing what the texts and the earliest witnesses actually say.

The question matters for trust. The Gospels come from men who walked with the Lord, or who wrote down the preaching of those who did. Knowing this helps the reader hear them as the Church has always heard them: as the apostolic witness to Christ.

In ancient book culture a work could circulate without the author’s name in the text. The Gospels follow this pattern: their narratives are told in the third person, and none states its author’s name. The headings “According to Matthew”, “According to Mark”, “According to Luke” and “According to John” were attached when the Gospels were collected and read together, and they appear in the surviving manuscripts, although the manuscripts themselves are later than the books.

The earliest testimony about authorship comes from outside the Gospels. Papias of Hierapolis, a bishop of the early second century whose words survive in Eusebius, said that Mark, who had been Peter’s interpreter, wrote down accurately but not in order what he remembered of the Lord’s sayings and deeds, and that Matthew put the sayings in order in the Hebrew language. Irenaeus of Lyons, near the end of the second century, names all four Evangelists and defends the fourfold Gospel as the Church’s own. These are the words of men who stood within one or two generations of the apostles, and they agree.

Inside the books the evidence is limited. Luke’s prologue says that many had undertaken to write an account, that the events were handed on by those who were eyewitnesses and servants of the word from the beginning, and that the writer himself had followed things carefully and now writes in order. The Gospel of John says that the disciple who testifies to these things wrote them, and that his testimony is true. Mark and Matthew say nothing of this kind about themselves.

The reasons for trusting the names are strong. The attributions are early and unanimous. Mark and Luke were not apostles, and so were not obvious names to invent for authority. And the books fit what the early witnesses say of them: Luke writes as a careful companion who gathered from eyewitnesses, and John as one who was there. Doubts usually rest on the Gospels not naming their authors in the text, which is ordinary in ancient books, or on Matthew’s use of Mark, which an apostle could well do with a Gospel that carried St Peter’s preaching.

Terms used

  • Primary source: A text or object from the period being studied, such as an ancient letter, a manuscript or an inscription.
  • Secondary source: A modern study that interprets primary sources, such as a scholarly book or article.
  • Eyewitness: A person who saw an event first-hand. A writer who reports what others said is not an eyewitness.
  • Gospel: An early Christian account of the life, death and resurrection of Jesus. “Gospel” also means the good news they proclaim.
  • Synoptic Gospels: Matthew, Mark and Luke, which share much material and are read side by side.
  • Tradition: In the Orthodox understanding, the Church’s lived and handed-on faith, within which Scripture is read.

The evidence

The names Matthew, Mark, Luke and John come to us through the titles of the books and the testimony of the second-century Church.

The narratives are told in the third person, as ancient histories often were. The title headings and the witness of Papias and Irenaeus supply the names, and they all point the same way. [1] [2] [5]

The Gospels were received under these four names early and uniformly, with no rival attribution for these books surviving.

The testimony of Papias, Irenaeus and the manuscript titles agree on the names. Books copied and read in churches across the Roman world carry the same four names, and no other names for these Gospels have ever been found. [1] [5]

The Gospels of Matthew and John carry the witness of the apostles whose names they bear.

The Gospel of Matthew tells of the call of the tax collector Matthew, one of the Twelve. The Gospel of John says plainly that it rests on the beloved disciple, who saw these things and whose testimony is true. An apostle could well use St Mark’s account of St Peter’s preaching without ceasing to be a witness himself. [3] [4] [6]

The Church receives the four Gospels as Scripture within her Tradition, as the apostolic witness written down by the four Evangelists.

By the middle of the second century the memoirs of the apostles, called Gospels, were already read at the Sunday gathering. The Church has handed them on and read them in worship ever since, as the proclamation of the apostles. [7]

The historical evidence points one way. The four books were received under four names early and everywhere. The earliest testimony ties Mark to St Peter’s preaching. St Luke describes his own method as that of a careful writer who relied on eyewitnesses. St John points to the disciple who was there and whose witness is true.

Justin Martyr, around the middle of the second century, calls the Gospels the memoirs of the apostles and says they were read at the Sunday gathering. The Church did not have to guess where her Gospels came from; she had received them.

In Scripture

Mark 1:1

King James Version

1 The beginning of the gospel of Jesus Christ, the Son of God;

Luke 1:1–4

King James Version

1 Forasmuch as many have taken in hand to set forth in order a declaration of those things which are most surely believed among us,

2 Even as they delivered them unto us, which from the beginning were eyewitnesses, and ministers of the word;

3 It seemed good to me also, having had perfect understanding of all things from the very first, to write unto thee in order, most excellent Theophilus,

4 That thou mightest know the certainty of those things, wherein thou hast been instructed.

John 21:24–25

King James Version

24 This is the disciple which testifieth of these things, and wrote these things: and we know that his testimony is true.

25 And there are also many other things which Jesus did, the which, if they should be written every one, I suppose that even the world itself could not contain the books that should be written. Amen.

Matthew 9:9

King James Version

9 ¶ And as Jesus passed forth from thence, he saw a man, named Matthew, sitting at the receipt of custom: and he saith unto him, Follow me. And he arose, and followed him.

What the Church teaches

The Church confesses that the Gospel is one, proclaimed in four forms, and that the Holy Spirit inspired the Evangelists. Her tradition names Matthew, Mark, Luke and John as those through whom the apostolic preaching came to be written. In this the Church reads her own memory, kept faithfully from the apostolic age.

The Coptic Orthodox Church honours St Mark the Evangelist as the writer of the second Gospel and as the apostle who preached in Egypt and founded the Church of Alexandria, whose successors sit on his throne. The Church’s tradition identifies him with the Mark of the Acts of the Apostles. This is the Church’s tradition, held and celebrated in her liturgical life.

In the Coptic Mass the Gospel is read with special honour: the people stand, the book is carried in procession and the priest proclaims it. The four Evangelists are commemorated in the Church’s hymns. This practice shows how the Church receives the Gospels: as the Gospel of Christ proclaimed through four witnesses, not as four books whose value depends on a scholarly verdict about their authors.

Objections answered

The Gospels are anonymous, so the names were added by later Christians to give the books authority.

Many ancient books did not name their authors in the text, and their authorship was known from the people who received and copied them. The Gospels are the same. The churches that read them knew where they came from.

If the aim had been to give the books authority, the choice of Mark and Luke, who were not among the Twelve, would make no sense; Peter or Paul would have been the obvious names. The four names are early, unanimous and unexpected, which is exactly what a true memory looks like.

[1] [5]

Matthew copies about half of Mark, so Matthew the apostle would not have needed to borrow from a non-eyewitness; the Gospel cannot be by the apostle.

Using Mark is no sign that the writer was not an apostle. Papias tells us that Mark wrote down the preaching of St Peter, the chief of the apostles. An apostle who took up that account was not borrowing from a stranger; he was building on Peter’s own witness, which he had heard himself.

Matthew also adds a great deal that is his own: the Sermon on the Mount, many parables, and his own call from the tax booth, told by the man who knew it best. Sharing material with Mark fits a Gospel written by an apostle within a Church that already treasured Peter’s preaching.

[4] [6]

If the authorship is uncertain, the Gospels cannot be reliable witnesses to Jesus.

Uncertainty about a name is not the same as uncertainty about reliability. Historians use many ancient works of unknown or disputed authorship, and judge them by their sources, their date, their genre and their agreement with other evidence.

The Gospels pass these tests well. They were written in the first century, close to the events; St Luke tells us he drew on eyewitnesses; and St John points to the disciple who saw. And the Church that received them knew the names of those who wrote them.

[2]

Conclusion

The four Gospels were written by St Matthew and St John, apostles of the Lord, by St Mark, who set down St Peter’s preaching, and by St Luke, the companion of St Paul. The Church received them under these names early, everywhere and without rival, and the names include two men no one seeking borrowed authority would have chosen. The texts fit the testimony: St Luke writes from eyewitnesses, St John as the disciple who saw. Through these four the one Gospel of Christ was given to the Church, and she reads it still with reverence.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close