Orthodoxia

Faith & Evidence / The Bible: transmission, authorship, canon and interpretation

Are the Gospels independent eyewitness accounts?

AdvancedTextualAnswer available

Revision 1, updated

The answer

Yes, in the sense that matters most: the Gospels rest on the testimony of those who saw and heard Jesus. The Church receives the Gospels of Matthew and John as the work of apostles, the Gospel of Mark as the preaching of St Peter, and the Gospel of Luke as an account carefully gathered from eyewitnesses, as St Luke the Evangelist says in his opening lines. The Gospel of John states plainly that its witness saw what he reports. The first three Gospels share much of their material and wording, so they are not three entirely separate reports. Their strength lies in the faithful handing on of the apostles’ testimony, and the distinct tradition of John and the earlier letters of St Paul the Apostle confirm the same core independently.

  • The Gospels rest on eyewitness testimony: St Luke says his account goes back to eyewitnesses, and the Gospel of John says its witness saw what he reports.
  • The Church receives Matthew and John as written by apostles, and Mark as the preaching of St Peter.
  • The first three Gospels share much material, so their agreement is not counted three times; it shows a common, carefully kept tradition.
  • The Gospel of John follows its own tradition and confirms the same central events.
  • St Paul’s letters, written earlier, name living witnesses of the risen Christ and confirm the core of the Gospel story.

Why this question matters

Some say the Gospels are “four independent eyewitness accounts”; others call them “four anonymous copies of one another”. Neither phrase is right. A believer should know exactly what the Gospels are, so that the defence of the faith is accurate and strong.

Seeing how the Gospels rest on testimony, and how other early evidence confirms them, shows why the Church trusts them as the apostolic witness to Christ.

The Synoptic problem concerns the close similarity of Matthew, Mark and Luke, which often share the same stories in the same order and sometimes in nearly the same words. The most widely held solution is that Mark was written first and was used by Matthew and Luke. Many add a second shared source, usually called Q, for material found in Matthew and Luke but not Mark; some propose instead that Luke used Matthew. Scholars who hold other solutions exist, for example those who think Matthew came first. On almost every solution, the three Gospels are connected by copying and not three separate reports.

John tells a different story in many respects: a ministry across several visits to Jerusalem, long discourses, different miracles, and different timing for some events. Most scholars therefore see John as drawing on its own tradition. Some argue that John knew one or more of the other Gospels. All the Gospels refer to some events in common, such as the feeding of the multitude, the passion and the empty tomb, and this gives some independent overlap.

On what the books say about their own sources: Luke’s prologue refers to eyewitnesses handing down what they saw and to earlier accounts, which the author used and arranged. The Gospel of John says of the one who saw the piercing at the cross that his testimony is true, and, at its close, speaks of the disciple who testifies to these things. The First Letter of John, whose author is a matter of discussion, opens by speaking of what was heard, seen and touched. Mark and Matthew do not describe their sources in the text. Early Christian writers such as Papias, as quoted by Eusebius, said that he preferred the living voice of those who had followed the elders to what is written in books, and linked the Gospel of Mark with Peter’s teaching.

Richard Bauckham argues that the Gospels preserve the testimony of named eyewitnesses, and that features of the texts, such as the names of minor characters and the shape of the narratives, point to it. Bart Ehrman and others stress the distance in time and the role of oral retelling. Both agree that the first three Gospels are closely related; the question between them is how directly the eyewitness testimony was kept, and the early Church’s answer is that it was kept faithfully, within the communities the apostles themselves taught.

Terms used

  • Primary source: A text or object from the period being studied, such as an ancient letter, a manuscript or an inscription.
  • Secondary source: A modern study that interprets primary sources, such as a scholarly book or article.
  • Independent attestation: Two sources report the same thing without one copying the other. Two copies of one source are one witness, not two.
  • Eyewitness: A person who saw an event first-hand. A writer who reports what others said is not an eyewitness.
  • Gospel: An early Christian account of the life, death and resurrection of Jesus. “Gospel” also means the good news they proclaim.
  • Synoptic Gospels: Matthew, Mark and Luke, which share much material and are read side by side.

The evidence

Matthew, Mark and Luke share a common body of material and wording, so they are not three wholly separate reports.

The three often tell the same stories in the same order and in nearly the same words, as a comparison of the feeding of the five thousand shows. This literary connection means their agreement is one strand of testimony, not three. It also shows how carefully the tradition was kept and passed on. [1]

St Luke and the Gospel of John state that their accounts rest on eyewitness testimony.

St Luke writes that he carefully traced what was handed on by eyewitnesses. The Gospel of John says of the one who saw the blood and water at the cross that his testimony is true, and it closes by naming the disciple who bears witness and wrote these things. The First Letter of John speaks in the same way of what was heard, seen and touched. [2] [3] [4]

The Gospels carry eyewitness testimony: they rely on traditions going back to people who saw Jesus.

Richard Bauckham argues that features of the Gospels, such as the names of minor characters who could still be asked, point to named eyewitnesses behind them. Bart Ehrman stresses the years between the events and the writing, and the role of oral retelling. Yet the testimony was handed on in the apostles’ own lifetime, within communities they led, which kept it faithfully. [5] [6] [4]

St Paul’s letters give early evidence for the death and resurrection of Christ, independent of the Gospels.

In his first letter to the Corinthians, St Paul hands on the message he received and names witnesses of the risen Lord, most of whom were still alive. In his letter to the Galatians he tells of his visits to Peter and James in Jerusalem. These letters are earlier than the Gospels and do not depend on them. [7] [8]

The Gospels are early accounts, written within the lifetime of the first generation or soon after, that rest on the testimony of people who knew Jesus. The first three share a common tradition, and John adds a distinct one. St Paul’s letters, which are earlier still, give separate evidence for the core: the death of Christ, His burial, His resurrection and His appearances to named witnesses.

Read simply as ancient documents, then, the Gospels are the kind of source a historian values most: close to the events and grounded in testimony.

In Scripture

Mark 6:30–44

King James Version

30 And the apostles gathered themselves together unto Jesus, and told him all things, both what they had done, and what they had taught.

31 And he said unto them, Come ye yourselves apart into a desert place, and rest a while: for there were many coming and going, and they had no leisure so much as to eat.

32 And they departed into a desert place by ship privately.

33 And the people saw them departing, and many knew him, and ran afoot thither out of all cities, and outwent them, and came together unto him.

34 And Jesus, when he came out, saw much people, and was moved with compassion toward them, because they were as sheep not having a shepherd: and he began to teach them many things.

35 And when the day was now far spent, his disciples came unto him, and said, This is a desert place, and now the time is far passed:

36 Send them away, that they may go into the country round about, and into the villages, and buy themselves bread: for they have nothing to eat.

37 He answered and said unto them, Give ye them to eat. And they say unto him, Shall we go and buy two hundred pennyworth of bread, and give them to eat?

38 He saith unto them, How many loaves have ye? go and see. And when they knew, they say, Five, and two fishes.

39 And he commanded them to make all sit down by companies upon the green grass.

40 And they sat down in ranks, by hundreds, and by fifties.

41 And when he had taken the five loaves and the two fishes, he looked up to heaven, and blessed, and brake the loaves, and gave them to his disciples to set before them; and the two fishes divided he among them all.

42 And they did all eat, and were filled.

43 And they took up twelve baskets full of the fragments, and of the fishes.

44 And they that did eat of the loaves were about five thousand men.

Luke 1:1–4

King James Version

1 Forasmuch as many have taken in hand to set forth in order a declaration of those things which are most surely believed among us,

2 Even as they delivered them unto us, which from the beginning were eyewitnesses, and ministers of the word;

3 It seemed good to me also, having had perfect understanding of all things from the very first, to write unto thee in order, most excellent Theophilus,

4 That thou mightest know the certainty of those things, wherein thou hast been instructed.

John 19:35

King James Version

35 And he that saw it bare record, and his record is true: and he knoweth that he saith true, that ye might believe.

1 John 1:1–3

King James Version

1 That which was from the beginning, which we have heard, which we have seen with our eyes, which we have looked upon, and our hands have handled, of the Word of life;

2 (For the life was manifested, and we have seen it, and bear witness, and shew unto you that eternal life, which was with the Father, and was manifested unto us;)

3 That which we have seen and heard declare we unto you, that ye also may have fellowship with us: and truly our fellowship is with the Father, and with his Son Jesus Christ.

1 Corinthians 15:3–7

King James Version

3 For I delivered unto you first of all that which I also received, how that Christ died for our sins according to the scriptures;

4 And that he was buried, and that he rose again the third day according to the scriptures:

5 And that he was seen of Cephas, then of the twelve:

6 After that, he was seen of above five hundred brethren at once; of whom the greater part remain unto this present, but some are fallen asleep.

7 After that, he was seen of James; then of all the apostles.

Galatians 2:9

King James Version

9 And when James, Cephas, and John, who seemed to be pillars, perceived the grace that was given unto me, they gave to me and Barnabas the right hands of fellowship; that we should go unto the heathen, and they unto the circumcision.

What the Church teaches

The Church confesses that the apostles were chosen witnesses of the resurrection, and that the Gospel is the apostolic witness written under the Holy Spirit. For her, the four Gospels are not four sources to be counted, but one Gospel in four forms, received together.

The historical evidence above and the faith of the Church point the same way: the Gospels are the faithful witness of those who saw the Lord.

The Coptic Orthodox Church receives the Gospel as the preaching of the apostles. She holds that St Mark, whom she honours as the founder of the Church of Alexandria, wrote the second Gospel, and she reads the four Gospels together in her services, without setting them against one another.

Objections answered

If the Gospels depend on one another, then their agreement proves nothing, and the claim of four witnesses is false.

Agreement between a source and those who drew on it counts once, not several times, and so the phrase “four independent witnesses” is best avoided.

But a writer who uses an earlier source can preserve it faithfully, and the Evangelists did. The case rests on the faithful handing on of apostolic testimony, confirmed independently by the distinct tradition of John and by the letters of St Paul. That is a strong foundation.

[1] [2] [7]

The Gospels are anonymous and were written in Greek by people who were not Galilean fishermen, so they are not eyewitness accounts.

The Gospels do not name their authors in the text, and they were written in Greek. Neither fact counts against eyewitness testimony. Greek was widely used in the region, and the early Church named the authors consistently.

The Church holds that Matthew and John were apostles, that St Mark wrote down St Peter’s preaching, and that St Luke gathered his account from eyewitnesses. Writing in Greek, or with the help of others, fits all of this. The article on authorship sets out the evidence in full.

[2] [3] [4]

The differences between the Gospels in the resurrection accounts show that they cannot be accurate eyewitness reports.

The accounts differ in details such as who was at the tomb and the order of events. They agree on the heart of the matter: the tomb was found empty, and women were the first witnesses. All four report it.

Differences in secondary detail are what honest reports of a stirring event usually show. A perfectly matched account would suggest collusion. The article on apparent contradictions shows how the accounts fit together.

[7]

Conclusion

The Gospels are the apostolic witness to Jesus Christ. They rest on the testimony of those who saw Him: Matthew and John were apostles, St Mark wrote down St Peter’s preaching, and St Luke gathered his account from eyewitnesses. The first three share a common tradition, John adds his own, and the earlier letters of St Paul confirm the same core. The Church receives them together as one Gospel in four forms.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close