Orthodoxia

Faith & Evidence / The Bible: transmission, authorship, canon and interpretation

What about noncanonical gospels?

IntermediateTextualAnswer available

Revision 1, updated

The answer

The noncanonical gospels are real ancient writings, but they are not the apostles’ witness to Christ. Most are later than the four Gospels, they carry the names of apostles who did not write them, and many teach what contradicts the faith the churches had received, for example that Christ did not truly take flesh or that the material world is the work of a lesser god. They were not suppressed by a single decree: they were simply never read in the churches’ worship, and from the second century bishops and teachers named and rejected them. The four Gospels, read from the beginning on the Lord’s Day, are the Gospel the Church received from the apostles.

  • St Luke’s preface shows that many accounts of Jesus were written early, so the Church has always had to recognise which writings carry the apostolic witness.
  • Most noncanonical gospels come from the second century or later and carry the name of an apostle who did not write them.
  • Several, such as the Gospel of Judas, which St Irenaeus already names as a forgery, teach that the material world is the work of a lesser god, contrary to the faith in one Creator.
  • By about AD 150 St Justin describes the Gospels being read in Sunday worship; no noncanonical gospel has a comparable record.
  • The Coptic Church has a particular interest: the Nag Hammadi books were found in Egypt and written in Coptic, and St Athanasius warned the Egyptian monasteries against such writings in 367.

Why this question matters

Many readers first meet these writings in a documentary or a novel, with the claim that the Church buried “lost gospels” that tell a different story of Jesus. The believer deserves a clear answer to that claim.

The answer also shows the Church’s confidence. She does not fear these writings or treat them with contempt: they show how some groups on the edge of the churches imagined Jesus, and seeing them beside the four Gospels makes plain why the Church received the four.

Luke’s preface, read as an ancient text, says that many had already taken in hand to set down an account of Jesus. So writings about Jesus were multiplying early. The four Gospels in the New Testament are the ones the churches came to read.

The Gospel of Thomas, known fully from a Coptic copy found at Nag Hammadi in Egypt in 1945 and in part from Greek fragments from Oxyrhynchus, is a collection of 114 sayings with little narrative. Some sayings are close to sayings in the Gospels, and others are quite different. The Gospel of Peter survives in part in a manuscript found at Akhmim, and it tells of the passion and resurrection with unusual details. Serapion, a bishop of Antioch around AD 200, is reported to have first allowed it to be read in a church and then to have judged it to contain false teaching.

The Gospel of Judas, known from a Coptic manuscript published in the early 2000s, is a gnostic text that Irenaeus, in the late second century, already mentions as a forgery of a heretical group. The Protoevangelium of James, from the second century, tells the story of Mary’s birth and childhood, and it is the source of the names of her parents; it has been widely used in Christian tradition for details, though it is not Scripture.

In Egypt, Athanasius in his Festal Letter of AD 367 wrote to the monasteries to say which books are to be received as the canon and warned them against apocryphal writings composed under the names of saints.

Terms used

  • Manuscript: A handwritten copy of a text on papyrus, parchment or paper.
  • Codex: An early book made of folded pages bound together, replacing the scroll.
  • Canon: The list of books a community receives as Scripture.
  • Gospel: An early Christian account of the life, death and resurrection of Jesus. “Gospel” also means the good news they proclaim.
  • Synoptic Gospels: Matthew, Mark and Luke, which share much material and are read side by side.
  • Christology: Teaching about who Christ is, especially how divinity and humanity are united in him.
  • Perpetual virginity: The teaching that Mary remained a virgin throughout her life. It is a separate claim from the virginal conception.
  • Tradition: In the Orthodox understanding, the Church’s lived and handed-on faith, within which Scripture is read.

The evidence

The four Gospels were read in worship earlier and far more widely than the noncanonical gospels, which have no comparable early record of church use.

St Justin describes the Sunday reading of the apostles’ memoirs, called Gospels, around AD 150, and church writers after him treat the Gospel texts as Scripture. For the noncanonical gospels we have instead the notices of church writers who reject them. [2]

The Church holds that the four Gospels alone are the apostolic witness she received as Scripture, and that she tests other writings by that witness.

This is the Church’s confession, resting on her reception of the apostolic faith. The history agrees with it: the four were read from the beginning, and the others were rejected because they did not carry that faith. [1]

The history supports the Church’s judgement. The noncanonical gospels are mostly later than the four Gospels, carry borrowed apostolic names, and were absent from the churches’ worship. Church writers rejected docetic and gnostic teaching long before any formal list existed, and no single act suppressed these books.

The Nag Hammadi writings are valuable witnesses to how some groups thought. Placed beside the four Gospels, with their concrete account of the Lord’s life, death and resurrection, they show clearly why the churches recognised the four as the apostolic witness.

What the Church teaches

The Church confesses that the Word became flesh, truly taking a body, a soul and a mind. Writings that make Christ’s humanity only apparent, or that treat matter as the work of an evil power, cannot be the apostles’ witness. She therefore receives the four Gospels, which give the concrete life, death and resurrection of Jesus.

This is not a rejection of reading the old writings. Believers are free to study them as history, as the Church’s own scholars do, and the Church asks only that they not be placed beside the Gospels as Scripture.

Egypt has a special place here. The Nag Hammadi codices were found in Upper Egypt in 1945 and are written in Coptic, and the Church of Alexandria was the church of Origen, who knew of these currents, and of Athanasius, who warned the monasteries against apocryphal books in 367. The Coptic Church therefore has both a historical interest in the writings and a long-standing judgement on them.

Coptic tradition also keeps several apocryphal narratives and feasts, for instance about the Holy Family’s journey to Egypt and the Dormition of the Virgin. The Church receives these as pious tradition and as part of her worship, distinct from the canon of Scripture. This shows that the Church’s line is between what is the rule of faith and what is memory, and not between what is old and what is new.

Objections answered

The Gospel of Thomas may be as early as the canonical Gospels or earlier, and its sayings may preserve authentic words of Jesus that the churches dropped because they were awkward.

Some sayings in Thomas have parallels in the four Gospels, and the Church has no need to deny that a saying preserved there may echo the Lord’s words. But the book as we have it comes to us in copies far later than the Gospels, the earliest being Greek fragments of about the third century and a Coptic copy of the fourth, and its themes reflect the thought of groups the churches rejected.

Above all, it was never read in the churches’ worship, and early church writers who mention it treat it as heretical. The Church did not drop awkward words of Jesus; she kept the four Gospels, which contain His hardest sayings, and declined a book that did not carry the faith she had received from the apostles.

[1] [2]

Early Christianity was a field of many “Christianities”, and the version that won decided which books survived. The excluded gospels are the voices of the losers.

There were indeed groups with different views in the early centuries, and the Nag Hammadi library preserves some of their writings. The Church has never hidden this; St Irenaeus wrote a whole work describing and answering them.

But the four Gospels were in wide use early, the churches’ judgement against the teaching of the rival writings is recorded by St Ignatius and St Irenaeus long before the fourth-century lists, and the rival writings are mostly later than the Gospels. The apostolic Gospel did not win by suppression; it was the faith handed down from the beginning, and the others departed from it.

[1] [2]

If the Church values details from the Protoevangelium of James, such as the names of Mary’s parents, it is inconsistent to say that the book is not Scripture.

The Church has always distinguished between Scripture, which is the rule of faith, and other ancient writings from which she may keep a pious tradition. The names of Joachim and Anna are kept in the Church’s memory and her feasts, but no article of faith rests on that book.

This is consistent, not contradictory. A late writing can preserve a true memory without being Scripture, just as a family keeps stories that are not part of its founding documents.

[1]

Conclusion

The noncanonical gospels are real ancient texts, but they are not the apostles’ witness. Most are later than the four Gospels, carry names of apostles who did not write them, and often teach what the churches had already rejected as contrary to the received faith. The four Gospels, read in the churches from the beginning, are the Gospel of Christ handed down by the apostles, and the Church can study the other writings calmly as history.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close