Faith & Evidence / Moral and comparative questions
What about other religions’ miracle and religious-experience claims?
The answer
Reports of wonders and of experiences of the divine are found in many religions, and the Christian can say so honestly and respectfully. The Church never taught that a wonder proves a teaching. Scripture itself warns that signs must be tested by the teaching they accompany and by their fruit, and that a sign can come from a source other than God. God is near to every person, and His grace is not bound by the visible Church; yet the fullness of His self-revelation is in Christ. That is why the Christian faith does not rest on miracles in general but on one particular event: the resurrection of Christ, proclaimed within the first generation by named witnesses who staked their lives on it. Reports in other religions do not weaken that witness, because no rival claim stands on the same kind of foundation.
- Miracle and experience claims are made across religions, and the Church does not call sincere people liars.
- Scripture teaches that signs must be tested by the teaching and the fruit; wonders alone do not prove a message (Deuteronomy 13; 1 John 4).
- God is near to all and may act where He wills; the Church does not need to explain every report in another tradition.
- The Christian faith rests on the resurrection of Christ, a particular event proclaimed by named witnesses in the first generation, not on miracle claims in general.
- Every claim, Christian or not, should be weighed by the same fair questions: how early, how close to the event, how many witnesses, and at what cost to them.
- Within her own life, too, the Church tests wonders by humility, love and faithfulness to Christ.
Why this question matters
The question is often put as one of fairness: if a Christian accepts the miracles of the Gospels, on what ground does he set aside the wonders reported at the shrines of other faiths? It is an honest question, and the Christian has a clear answer.
It also matters because many people have had experiences of peace in prayer, of a presence, of an answer, within traditions that are not Christian. The Church does not deny or mock these. She points to the One in whom God has made Himself fully known.
There are three questions here, which are often run together. The first is whether the reports are true: whether what is said to have happened happened. The second is what explains them if they did: natural causes, the effects of expectation, human psychology, the grace of God, or spiritual forces. The third is what they prove: whether a miracle, if real, shows that the religion in which it occurs is true.
The reference entry on miracles (S41) sets out the main philosophical discussion: how testimony to events outside the ordinary should be weighed, the classical argument of Hume that such testimony will rarely if ever be strong enough, and the replies to him. The entry on religious diversity (S46) sets out how competing claims of experience and revelation bear on one another. Both discussions apply to Christian and non-Christian claims alike.
On the third question the Bible does not say that a miracle proves a message. It records that false prophets may give signs, and tells the people to judge the sign by whether the teaching leads to the God they already know. The New Testament says the same of the last days. John’s first letter calls on Christians to test the spirits.
Terms used
- Apologetics: The reasoned defence and explanation of a belief. It offers arguments and evidence for examination; it does not replace faith or guarantee agreement.
- Resurrection: In Christian teaching, Jesus’ bodily rising from the dead to a transformed life. It is a different claim from the claim that his followers came to believe it.
- Miracle: An event believed to result from God acting beyond the ordinary course of nature.
- Theism: The view that there is one personal God who made and sustains the world.
The evidence
Reports of miracles and of profound religious experience are made in many religious traditions, and the sincerity of those who report them is not in question.
That such reports are made is plain to anyone who looks. The Church can acknowledge it freely, because her faith was never built on the bare fact of wonders. [1] [2]
Scripture itself teaches that signs and wonders do not by themselves prove a message, and that a sign must be tested by the teaching it accompanies and by its fruit.
Deuteronomy 13 warns of a prophet whose sign comes true but whose message leads away from the Lord. The Lord Himself warns that false prophets will show great signs (Matthew 24:24), and St John tells believers to test the spirits by their confession of Christ. The texts are clear. [3] [4] [5]
The Christian faith rests on one specific event, the resurrection of Christ, proclaimed by named witnesses within the first generation, and not on the existence of miracles in general; so parallels elsewhere do not weaken it.
St Paul the Apostle grounds the Christian message on the resurrection and says that without it the faith would be in vain. He names the witnesses, many of them still living when he wrote. A report elsewhere would weigh against this only if it rested on the same kind of witness, and none does. [6]
Each miracle claim is assessed on its own sources, and for the Christian faith the decisive question is the resurrection: what St Paul the Apostle and the Gospels report, how early they are, and what explains the sudden rise of the Christian movement in Jerusalem. That witness is early, public and costly to those who gave it, and it is treated fully in the articles on the resurrection. The same fair questions can be put to any other report.
In Scripture
Deuteronomy 13:1–5
King James Version
1 If there arise among you a prophet, or a dreamer of dreams, and giveth thee a sign or a wonder,
2 And the sign or the wonder come to pass, whereof he spake unto thee, saying, Let us go after other gods, which thou hast not known, and let us serve them;
3 Thou shalt not hearken unto the words of that prophet, or that dreamer of dreams: for the LORD your God proveth you, to know whether ye love the LORD your God with all your heart and with all your soul.
4 Ye shall walk after the LORD your God, and fear him, and keep his commandments, and obey his voice, and ye shall serve him, and cleave unto him.
5 And that prophet, or that dreamer of dreams, shall be put to death; because he hath spoken to turn you away from the LORD your God, which brought you out of the land of Egypt, and redeemed you out of the house of bondage, to thrust thee out of the way which the LORD thy God commanded thee to walk in. So shalt thou put the evil away from the midst of thee.
Matthew 24:24
King James Version
24 For there shall arise false Christs, and false prophets, and shall shew great signs and wonders; insomuch that, if it were possible, they shall deceive the very elect.
1 John 4:1–3
King James Version
1 Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God: because many false prophets are gone out into the world.
2 Hereby know ye the Spirit of God: Every spirit that confesseth that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is of God:
3 And every spirit that confesseth not that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is not of God: and this is that spirit of antichrist, whereof ye have heard that it should come; and even now already is it in the world.
1 Corinthians 15:12–20
King James Version
12 Now if Christ be preached that he rose from the dead, how say some among you that there is no resurrection of the dead?
13 But if there be no resurrection of the dead, then is Christ not risen:
14 And if Christ be not risen, then is our preaching vain, and your faith is also vain.
15 Yea, and we are found false witnesses of God; because we have testified of God that he raised up Christ: whom he raised not up, if so be that the dead rise not.
16 For if the dead rise not, then is not Christ raised:
17 And if Christ be not raised, your faith is vain; ye are yet in your sins.
18 Then they also which are fallen asleep in Christ are perished.
19 If in this life only we have hope in Christ, we are of all men most miserable.
20 But now is Christ risen from the dead, and become the firstfruits of them that slept.
What the Church teaches
The Church confesses that God is the Creator of all and is near to all, and that his grace is not bound by the visible Church. It also confesses that the fullness of his self-disclosure is in Christ. Miracles in the Christian understanding are signs, not proofs; they point to Christ and to the life of the kingdom, and they have no value apart from that.
The Church therefore tests every claim of wonder, within its own life as well as outside it, by the Gospel, by humility and by fruit. A wonder that leads a person away from love, repentance and Christ is not accepted, however impressive. A wonder that leads toward them is received with thanks and without boasting.
The Coptic Church has a long life of reported wonders, healings and visions among its saints, and it keeps them in its synaxarium and its devotional life. It also has a deep tradition, from the desert Fathers, of caution about visions and extraordinary experiences: the monastic teachers urged a person not to seek them, to doubt his own, and to test them with a spiritual father. The Coptic approach is that humility and obedience, not wonders, are the signs of a sound spiritual life.
Objections answered
Christians accept the miracles of their own tradition and dismiss the others on no better ground than that they are their own. The standards of evidence are applied unequally, and a consistent sceptic would reject all of them.
The standards should be equal, and the Christian welcomes that. Each claim is weighed by the same questions: how early the report is, how close to the event, how many witnesses there were, and what they gained or lost by their testimony.
Measured this way, the resurrection of Christ stands apart: proclaimed within a few years in the very city where He was buried, by witnesses who gained nothing on earth and some of whom died for it. The Church does not ask belief in every devotional story; she asks faith in the risen Lord, whose witness meets the strictest test.
If people of other religions have experiences of peace, healing and presence just as Christians do, the best explanation is that they are natural, psychological and the same in every tradition. Christians’ own experiences are no different.
Prayer, ritual and community do have real human effects, and the Church has always warned against taking feeling for proof. But that experiences resemble one another does not show that they are merely natural. God made every person for Himself and is not far from any of us, as St Paul the Apostle told the Athenians.
The Christian faith does not rest on experience at all. It rests on what God has done in history in Jesus Christ, above all in His resurrection. Experience of God in prayer is received with thanks, but the foundation is Christ.
To say that miracles in other religions may be spiritual deception is insulting to millions of sincere people and is simply a way of protecting one’s own claims.
The Church does not say that sincere people are deceivers, and she does not pronounce on any particular case. The warning in Scripture that signs can mislead is given to Christians about themselves first, so that they test every wonder, including their own, by Christ.
The Church can also speak of God’s grace working in ways we cannot trace. She does not need to explain every report; she needs only to point to Christ, in whom God has spoken fully.
Conclusion
Reports of wonders and of the divine are found in many religions, and the Church receives this calmly and with respect for every sincere person. A wonder does not prove a teaching, as Scripture itself says. The Christian faith rests on the resurrection of Christ, borne witness by those who saw Him risen, and on the fullness of God’s self-revelation in Him. In Him the Church invites everyone to find the God who is already near.
Sources
- Miracles · Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy · whole entry (testimony, probability and Hume’s argument; section not cited)
- Religious Diversity (Pluralism) · Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy · whole entry (competing truth claims and religious disagreement; section not cited)
- Deuteronomy 13:1–5
- Matthew 24:24
- 1 John 4:1–3
- 1 Corinthians 15:12–20
No inbox has been set up yet, so nothing is sent. This copies a short report with the page address and revision for you to pass on.