Faith & Evidence / God’s existence and knowledge
Does religious experience count as evidence?
The answer
Yes. Religious experience is real evidence, and the Church has always known how to receive it wisely. For the person who has it, an encounter with God in prayer is a reason to believe, just as seeing or hearing is, unless there is good reason to doubt it. For others it is testimony, weighed like any testimony: by the character of the witness and the fruit of the life that follows. Brain science shows how experience happens in us; it cannot show that nothing is there to be experienced. The Church does not rest the faith on experience. Faith rests on what God has done in Christ, and experience confirms and deepens it. That is why the Church tests every experience by Scripture, by her faith, by its fruit, and by the guidance of a spiritual father.
- A sound principle of reasoning: if it seems to you that you experience something, you are entitled to believe it is so, unless you have reason to doubt. This holds for experience of God too.
- For others, a report of experience is testimony, weighed by the witness, the circumstances and the fruit in a life.
- Experiences across religions differ mostly in how they are interpreted, and many bear witness that there is a reality beyond the world that can be met.
- Neuroscience shows that religious experience involves the brain, as every experience does. That shows how we experience, not whether anything is experienced.
- The Church tests experience (“test the spirits”) by faith, fruit and obedience, and values it as a gift, not as the ground of belief.
Why this question matters
For most believers, the reason they believe is not an argument. They have prayed and found themselves in the presence of God, or they have been changed. For many non-believers, this is exactly what makes religion seem private and unprovable. So it matters to see clearly what such experience shows.
It also matters pastorally. A person who treats every feeling as a message from God is exposed to error, and a person who treats all religious experience as delusion dismisses the testimony of most of the human race. The Church has long walked the sure path between the two: receiving experience as a gift and testing it.
Religious experience covers many things: a feeling of the presence of God in prayer, a sense of being forgiven, an overwhelming awe, a vision or voice, a sudden conversion, and the quiet sense of guidance that many believers describe. These differ greatly in intensity, in how public they are, and in how they are interpreted. The question of evidence is different for each.
Richard Swinburne, a philosopher and Eastern Orthodox Christian, has defended a “principle of credulity”: other things being equal, how things seem to a person is a good guide to how they are. If it seems to you that there is a tree ahead, you are entitled to believe it unless there is reason not to. He applies the principle to experiences of God, and balances it with a “principle of testimony”, that we should in general believe what others report. The philosopher William Alston developed a related case in the 1990s, arguing that experience of God is a way of perceiving that has its own rules and checks, like sense perception. Here Swinburne’s work is cited only as a whole.
Against this, critics note that experiences of the divine are reported in every religion and often contradict each other in content; that the brain activity involved in such experiences can be studied and sometimes triggered in a laboratory; that experiences often track the expectations of the person’s culture; and that private experience cannot be checked by others. But these points apply equally to many kinds of ordinary perception and memory, and they do not make those worthless.
Terms used
- Apologetics: The reasoned defence and explanation of a belief. It offers arguments and evidence for examination; it does not replace faith or guarantee agreement.
- Theism: The view that there is one personal God who made and sustains the world.
- Divine hiddenness: The question why a loving God is not more evident to people who sincerely seek him.
- Tradition: In the Orthodox understanding, the Church’s lived and handed-on faith, within which Scripture is read.
- Inspiration: The Christian belief that God worked through the human authors of Scripture. It is a theological claim, distinct from the preservation of manuscripts.
The evidence
For the person who has it, an experience of God is a reasonable ground for belief, as other experiences are, unless there is good reason to doubt it.
We trust our experience in every part of life unless we have reason not to; without that trust no knowledge would be possible. There is no fair reason to make experience of God the single exception. The philosopher Richard Swinburne has defended this principle and applied it to experience of God. [1] [2]
For others, an account of religious experience is testimony, weighed by the character of the witness, the details of the report, the circumstances, and the fruit it bears in a life.
These are the ordinary rules for weighing any testimony, applied fairly, with no stricter standard for religion than for other claims. The testimony of countless people across history, and the lasting change in many lives, give it real weight. [1]
The Church holds that experience of God is a real gift, and that it is to be tested by Scripture, by the faith of the Church, by its fruit in a life, and by spiritual guidance.
This is the practice Scripture itself teaches: St John the Apostle’s call to test the spirits, and the Lord’s word that a tree is known by its fruit. The conversion of St Paul the Apostle shows the pattern: a real encounter, followed by instruction and entry into the Church. [3] [4] [5]
Some experiences are part of history and can be examined as ancient testimony. The most important is the encounter of St Paul the Apostle with the risen Christ, which turned a persecutor of the Church into its apostle. That testimony, together with the appearances of the risen Lord to the disciples, is examined in the articles on the resurrection.
In Scripture
1 John 4:1–3
King James Version
1 Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God: because many false prophets are gone out into the world.
2 Hereby know ye the Spirit of God: Every spirit that confesseth that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is of God:
3 And every spirit that confesseth not that Jesus Christ is come in the flesh is not of God: and this is that spirit of antichrist, whereof ye have heard that it should come; and even now already is it in the world.
Matthew 7:15–20
King James Version
15 ¶ Beware of false prophets, which come to you in sheep’s clothing, but inwardly they are ravening wolves.
16 Ye shall know them by their fruits. Do men gather grapes of thorns, or figs of thistles?
17 Even so every good tree bringeth forth good fruit; but a corrupt tree bringeth forth evil fruit.
18 A good tree cannot bring forth evil fruit, neither can a corrupt tree bring forth good fruit.
19 Every tree that bringeth not forth good fruit is hewn down, and cast into the fire.
20 Wherefore by their fruits ye shall know them.
Acts 9:1–9
King James Version
1 And Saul, yet breathing out threatenings and slaughter against the disciples of the Lord, went unto the high priest,
2 And desired of him letters to Damascus to the synagogues, that if he found any of this way, whether they were men or women, he might bring them bound unto Jerusalem.
3 And as he journeyed, he came near Damascus: and suddenly there shined round about him a light from heaven:
4 And he fell to the earth, and heard a voice saying unto him, Saul, Saul, why persecutest thou me?
5 And he said, Who art thou, Lord? And the Lord said, I am Jesus whom thou persecutest: it is hard for thee to kick against the pricks.
6 And he trembling and astonished said, Lord, what wilt thou have me to do? And the Lord said unto him, Arise, and go into the city, and it shall be told thee what thou must do.
7 And the men which journeyed with him stood speechless, hearing a voice, but seeing no man.
8 And Saul arose from the earth; and when his eyes were opened, he saw no man: but they led him by the hand, and brought him into Damascus.
9 And he was three days without sight, and neither did eat nor drink.
What the Church teaches
The Christian claim is that God is not only a conclusion of argument but a Person who can be known, and that He makes Himself known in prayer, in the Scriptures, and in the sacraments of the Church. That is why the Church’s life includes many experiences of the presence of God, and why it does not rest the faith on any of them. Faith has its ground in what God has done in Christ and in the apostolic witness, and experience confirms, deepens and humbles faith.
The Church’s teaching on discernment is guarded. It tells the believer to test every spirit, to expect fruit in love and humility, to be wary of the person who claims special revelation, and to submit private experiences to the faith and guidance of the Church. For the person who has no such experience the Church does not say that faith is lacking.
The Coptic tradition of the desert, associated with St Antony and the monks of Egypt, is a long school in discernment. The spiritual father is the guide to whom the monk and the lay believer bring experiences for testing, and the Fathers warn against pride and against trusting dreams and visions without counsel. Spiritual experience is valued, and is understood as the fruit of prayer, fasting, humility and the sacraments, not as an end to be sought for itself.
This is the Church’s approach to experience in its own terms. It is not offered as proof of God’s existence to someone who does not share the faith.
Objections answered
Religious experiences differ and sometimes contradict one another: a Hindu, a Muslim, a Buddhist and a Christian report experiences that support their own traditions. They cannot all be right, so the argument from experience cancels itself.
The differences lie mainly in how experiences are interpreted, not in the core of what is experienced. Across many traditions, people bear witness that there is a holy reality beyond the world that can be encountered. That shared witness supports, rather than cancels, the reality of what they meet.
Disagreement in reports does not make us discard perception in any other field; we investigate and correct. In the same way, the Christian tests experience by the revelation of God in Christ, which rests on public, historical events and not on private experience alone.
Neuroscience can explain religious experience. Brain activity accompanies such states, they can be provoked by drugs, fasting, sleep loss, or electrical stimulation, and they resemble effects of epilepsy. So there is no need to suppose a divine cause.
Every experience has its activity in the brain, whether seeing a tree or solving a sum, and no one concludes that the tree is unreal. Showing how an experience happens in the brain does not show that nothing beyond the brain is met in it.
If God made us and wishes to be known, it is natural that He would meet us through the faculties He gave us. That some states can be imitated by drugs or illness no more disproves real encounter with God than illusions disprove real sight.
Private experience cannot be checked. Others cannot see, hear or measure it. A claim that only the claimant can verify is not evidence for anyone else.
For others, experience comes as testimony, and testimony is real evidence even when we cannot check the original, as with a report of pain or a memory. Most of what we know, we know from the testimony of others.
And experience of God is not invisible: it shows itself in what a person does and becomes. The saints whose lives were transformed in love, humility and courage are a public witness that anyone can see.
Believers also have experiences of the Virgin, of angels or of the saints, and they sometimes disagree with each other about them. If the experiences are unreliable, so is the Christian one; if they are reliable, then some of them must be mistaken.
This is exactly why the Church does not treat experience as self-authenticating. Reports of visions are received with care and tested against Scripture, the faith of the Church, and their fruits. A spiritual father or the bishop is consulted, and private devotion is kept humble. Testing does not make the faith unreliable; it is how the Church keeps the gift of God free from error.
Conclusion
Religious experience is real evidence. It gives the person who has it a reason to believe, and it gives others the weight of testimony, confirmed by changed lives. Brain science shows how we experience, not that nothing is there. The Church honours the experience of God as His gift, tests it with wisdom, and rests the faith on what God has done in Christ.
Sources
- The Existence of God · Richard Swinburne
- Is There a God? · Richard Swinburne
- 1 John 4:1–3
- Matthew 7:15–20
- Acts 9:1–9
No inbox has been set up yet, so nothing is sent. This copies a short report with the page address and revision for you to pass on.