Orthodoxia

Faith & Evidence / The historical Jesus

How are claims about his miracles evaluated?

AdvancedHistoricalPhilosophicalAnswer available

Revision 1, updated

The answer

A miracle claim is weighed like any testimony: how early are the sources, how close are the witnesses, and do other explanations fit the facts? One question comes first: is a miracle possible at all? If God exists and made the world, He can act in it, and a miracle is not ruled out in advance. On this footing the witness to Jesus is strong. The Gospels report His healings and His casting out of spirits, and even His opponents admitted the deeds, explaining them as the work of evil powers. The Church receives His works as the acts of the Creator restoring His creation, signs that point to who He is.

  • History can establish what the sources report and how reliable they are; whether God acted depends also on whether one allows that God exists and acts.
  • Hume argued that testimony for a miracle will hardly ever outweigh our uniform experience. But that argument assumes what it sets out to prove.
  • For anyone who believes in God, a healing is not impossible; the question is whether the evidence for a particular event is good.
  • Jesus' opponents in the Gospels and a later critic, Celsus, put His wonders down to evil powers or magic. They did not deny the deeds.
  • The Church tests claims of the miraculous and warns against false signs. Her faith rests on Christ Himself, to whom His works point.

Why this question matters

Many people reject the Gospels at once because they report miracles. That is not an argument but a starting assumption. The real questions are whether the sources are good, and whether one's starting view lets the evidence count.

The subject also protects believers. A Church that welcomed every report of wonders would be easy to deceive, and the Fathers and the Scriptures themselves teach discernment.

A miracle is usually defined as an event brought about by God, or by a power beyond nature, that exceeds the ordinary course of the world and serves a purpose of revelation or mercy. The Gospels call such acts mighty works, wonders and signs. Not every unusual event is a miracle, and not every report of the unusual is reliable.

In the eighteenth century David Hume argued that a wise person proportions belief to evidence, and that the evidence from the regularity of nature is stronger than the evidence of any testimony to its violation. The argument has been much discussed. Critics say it either assumes that miracles never happen, or confuses the question of what happens normally with the question of whether it can ever be otherwise. Others have restated it in terms of probability.

Historians face a further limit. The historical method works by analogy with ordinary experience and looks for natural explanations. It is not designed to name God as a cause, and a historian who does so is moving from history to a wider judgement.

Terms used

  • Primary source: A text or object from the period being studied, such as an ancient letter, a manuscript or an inscription.
  • Eyewitness: A person who saw an event first-hand. A writer who reports what others said is not an eyewitness.
  • Resurrection: In Christian teaching, Jesus’ bodily rising from the dead to a transformed life. It is a different claim from the claim that his followers came to believe it.
  • Miracle: An event believed to result from God acting beyond the ordinary course of nature.
  • Theism: The view that there is one personal God who made and sustains the world.
  • Christology: Teaching about who Christ is, especially how divinity and humanity are united in him.
  • Tradition: In the Orthodox understanding, the Church’s lived and handed-on faith, within which Scripture is read.

The evidence

Whether a miracle occurred depends not on historical method alone but also on whether God acts in the world, and if God exists, He can.

Someone who assumes there is no God will reject every miracle whatever the testimony. Someone who knows that God exists and acts will weigh the reports honestly. The overview of the debate in the Stanford Encyclopedia sets out these positions, the testimony question and the replies to Hume. [1]

Hume's argument, in its classic form, fails: it presupposes the very uniformity it uses to dismiss testimony.

Every witness to a wonder knows that nature is regular; that is why the event is called a wonder. The regularity of nature does not count against a particular event reported by good witnesses, when that event has a sufficient cause in God. [1]

The sources agree that Jesus healed and cast out spirits, and His opponents accepted this while explaining it as the work of evil powers or magic.

Mark reports the accusation that He acted by Beelzebul, and Origen preserves Celsus' charge of sorcery. Opponents do not invent explanations for deeds that never happened. [2] [3]

The Gospels and the Church treat miracles as signs that point beyond themselves, and call for discernment, not credulity.

St John says that the signs were written so that readers might believe; Jesus refuses to give a sign on demand and warns of false signs; and the letter of St John calls on believers to test the spirits. [4] [5] [6] [7]

The deeds of Jesus were part of His reputation among friends and enemies from the beginning, and no source of the time denies them. The question is then not whether something happened, but what it was.

If God does not act, the reports need another explanation, and none fits well. If God acts, they are what they claim to be: acts of power and mercy. The resurrection, the central miracle, is treated in its own articles.

In Scripture

Mark 3:20–30

King James Version

20 And the multitude cometh together again, so that they could not so much as eat bread.

21 And when his friends heard of it, they went out to lay hold on him: for they said, He is beside himself.

22 ¶ And the scribes which came down from Jerusalem said, He hath Beelzebub, and by the prince of the devils casteth he out devils.

23 And he called them unto him, and said unto them in parables, How can Satan cast out Satan?

24 And if a kingdom be divided against itself, that kingdom cannot stand.

25 And if a house be divided against itself, that house cannot stand.

26 And if Satan rise up against himself, and be divided, he cannot stand, but hath an end.

27 No man can enter into a strong man’s house, and spoil his goods, except he will first bind the strong man; and then he will spoil his house.

28 Verily I say unto you, All sins shall be forgiven unto the sons of men, and blasphemies wherewith soever they shall blaspheme:

29 But he that shall blaspheme against the Holy Ghost hath never forgiveness, but is in danger of eternal damnation:

30 Because they said, He hath an unclean spirit.

John 20:30–31

King James Version

30 ¶ And many other signs truly did Jesus in the presence of his disciples, which are not written in this book:

31 But these are written, that ye might believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God; and that believing ye might have life through his name.

Matthew 12:38–39

King James Version

38 ¶ Then certain of the scribes and of the Pharisees answered, saying, Master, we would see a sign from thee.

39 But he answered and said unto them, An evil and adulterous generation seeketh after a sign; and there shall no sign be given to it, but the sign of the prophet Jonas:

Matthew 24:24

King James Version

24 For there shall arise false Christs, and false prophets, and shall shew great signs and wonders; insomuch that, if it were possible, they shall deceive the very elect.

1 John 4:1

King James Version

1 Beloved, believe not every spirit, but try the spirits whether they are of God: because many false prophets are gone out into the world.

What the Church teaches

The Church confesses Christ as the Word who made all things, so that his works of healing and mercy are the acts of the Creator restoring his creation, as St Athanasius teaches. They are signs of the kingdom and of his person, and they are never the whole of faith. The Church also warns, with the Lord, against false wonders, and requires that every claim be tested against the faith handed down.

The Coptic Church lives with the miraculous in her own history: the saints, the martyrs and the monastic fathers are remembered with accounts of healings, and the Church prays for the sick with the anointing of the sick. At the same time the Church’s spiritual tradition urges caution, so that miracles do not become a ground for pride, and so that no wonder is accepted against the teaching of the Church. The Church’s own spiritual tradition therefore combines openness with discernment.

Objections answered

Experience shows that miracles do not happen. Every report of one that has been investigated has turned out to have an ordinary explanation, so the odds of any new one are tiny.

Most reports of wonders do fail, and the Church shares that caution. But the uniform experience the objection appeals to is not a neutral fact. Those who have witnessed a miracle do not share it, and to count their experience as no evidence assumes the conclusion.

If God exists, an event with a good purpose, such as healing the sick, is not improbable in the way a random break in nature would be. Each testimony is to be weighed on its own, and the case of Jesus stands up to that weighing.

[1]

Every religion has miracle stories, so if miracles prove Christianity they prove all of them, and if they prove none then they prove nothing.

The Church does not say that every miracle story is true, nor that miracles alone prove the faith. Reports must be weighed one by one: how early, how close to the events, how many witnesses, what motive, what other explanation. These differ widely from claim to claim.

What matters most is what a miracle points to. The works of Christ point to His person, His death and His resurrection; they belong to the whole of His life and teaching, not to a contest of wonders. Miracles in other religions are treated in their own article.

[4] [5] [6]

The Gospels were written by believers decades afterwards, so the miracle stories are legend that grew in the telling.

Legends need time and distance from the events. The healings of Jesus are not found only in one late layer; they run through every strand of the Gospel tradition, and they were known while those who had seen Him were still alive.

His opponents, too, accepted that He did these works and argued only about their source. That is strong evidence that the deeds belong to the earliest memory of Jesus, not to later legend.

[2] [3] [8]

Conclusion

History shows that Jesus healed the sick and drove out spirits, and that His opponents did not deny it. Whether God acted depends on whether God exists and acts, and He does. The Church receives the works of Christ as the acts of the Creator restoring His creation, signs that lead to faith in Him, weighed always with discernment.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close