Orthodoxia

Faith & Evidence / Moral and comparative questions

How should competing religious truth claims be compared?

IntermediatePhilosophicalAnswer available

Revision 1, updated

The answer

Religions make different claims about God, human nature, history and salvation, and where they contradict each other they cannot all be true; saying so is honest, not unkind. A fair comparison asks the same questions of every tradition: what does it claim, is it coherent, what evidence does it offer, does it rest on events that can be examined, and what life does it produce? The Christian faith welcomes these questions. Its centre is not a private vision but public events: Jesus of Nazareth was crucified under Pontius Pilate and rose on the third day, and He appeared to many witnesses who proclaimed it in the city where it happened. That claim can be examined, and it holds. The Church therefore confesses with confidence and with respect for all people that Jesus Christ is the Son of God, the way, the truth and the life.

  • Where religions contradict each other on central claims, they cannot all be true as stated; saying so is not an insult to anyone.
  • The idea that all religions say the same thing is not what their own followers believe; respect means taking each at its word.
  • Fair questions for any tradition: what does it claim, how coherent is it, what evidence does it offer, does it rest on events open to examination, and what does it do to those who follow it.
  • The tests should be applied equally, and a tradition should be described as its own adherents describe it.
  • Christianity rests on public events in history, above all the death and resurrection of Jesus, and these can be examined; they stand up to examination.
  • The Church recognises truth and goodness wherever they are found, as gifts of the one God, and confesses that their fullness is in Christ.

Why this question matters

Most people hold the religion they were born into, and many are aware of it. Others live among neighbours of other faiths, as Copts do in Egypt, and know them as honest and devout. For both, the question of how to think about competing claims is real and not academic.

There are two easy mistakes. One is to say that all religions are saying the same thing, which most of their adherents would deny. The other is to say that people of other faiths have nothing true or good, which the Church does not say. The better course is to ask the same honest questions of each, and to follow where they lead.

The reference entry on religious diversity (S46) describes the main positions. Exclusivism holds that the central claims of one religion are true and those of rival religions false where they conflict. Inclusivism holds that one religion is true and that others may share in its truth or salvation in ways it recognises. Pluralism holds that the major traditions are different responses to one ultimate reality, none of them uniquely true. Each position has serious defenders and serious critics, and the entry sets out the arguments.

A further problem is religious disagreement itself. If equally intelligent and sincere people reach different conclusions, ought a person to doubt his own? Philosophers answer in different ways. Some say that disagreement should reduce confidence; others that a person may keep his belief if he has reasons that others do not share. The entry surveys these replies.

Religious experience and miracle claims are made in several traditions, and they bear on comparison. They are treated in a separate article, and so is the question of what historical evidence can show.

Terms used

  • Apologetics: The reasoned defence and explanation of a belief. It offers arguments and evidence for examination; it does not replace faith or guarantee agreement.
  • Primary source: A text or object from the period being studied, such as an ancient letter, a manuscript or an inscription.
  • Miracle: An event believed to result from God acting beyond the ordinary course of nature.
  • Theism: The view that there is one personal God who made and sustains the world.

The evidence

Where religions make contradictory claims on a central matter, they cannot all be true as stated.

This is simple logic. Either Jesus died on the cross or He did not; either God is a Trinity or He is not. Even the pluralist view, that all religions are partial responses to one reality, is itself a claim that contradicts what most believers of every faith hold. [1]

A fair comparison asks the same questions of every tradition: what it claims, how coherent it is, what kind of evidence supports it, whether it depends on events open to examination, and what it does in the lives of those who follow it.

These are the criteria used in the philosophical discussion of religious diversity and of testimony, and anyone can apply them. They treat every tradition alike, describing each as its own followers describe it, and weighing testimony by the same standards whoever gives it. [1] [2]

The New Testament itself invites its readers to test what they are told, so the Christian claim asks to be examined and not only believed.

St Paul the Apostle urges believers to test everything and hold to what is good, and the Beroeans are praised in Acts for examining the Scriptures to see whether what they were told was so. The apostles did not ask for blind assent; they pointed to what they had seen and heard, and the other articles on this site show how well their witness stands. [3]

Christian claims about Jesus are historical claims. The earliest Christian documents present them openly and name witnesses; St Paul the Apostle lists those to whom the risen Lord appeared, most of them still alive when he wrote. The crucifixion is recorded even by non-Christian writers such as Tacitus and Josephus. The articles on the resurrection show that it is the best explanation of the evidence.

In Scripture

1 Thessalonians 5:21

King James Version

21 Prove all things; hold fast that which is good.

What the Church teaches

The Church confesses that Jesus Christ is the Son of God made man, that in him God has fully made himself known, and that salvation is through him. It also confesses that God is the Creator of all, that his image is in every human being, and that truth and goodness found anywhere come from him. It therefore speaks of other faiths with respect and without agreeing that their central claims are the same as its own.

The Church’s own approach is to give a reason for its hope with gentleness and respect, and to let the claims be tested. Reasons open the way, and faith, which is also a gift of God and a response of the heart, receives Christ Himself.

Copts live beside Muslim neighbours and have done so for centuries. The Church’s life has been shaped by that, and its witness has been one of faithfulness to its own confession together with honest respect for those who hold another. The Church teaches that people of every faith are made in God’s image and are to be loved, and it teaches Christians to give an account of their hope with gentleness.

Objections answered

The world’s religions are cultural products. Which one a person holds depends mainly on where he was born, and no method will lift one above the rest. Any claim to unique truth is arrogance.

Upbringing does shape belief, and this should make every believer humble. But where a belief came from does not decide whether it is true; the same would apply to a person’s scientific or political beliefs. Many people, from the first century to today, have come to Christ from outside the faith of their birth, drawn by its reasons and by Christ Himself.

The charge of arrogance also applies to the pluralist, who claims that all traditions are partial responses to one reality and that their adherents have misunderstood themselves. No position is free of a claim to truth.

[1]

All traditions produce saints, good works and experiences of God. If moral and spiritual fruit are the measure, no religion can claim to be better.

The Church gladly recognises goodness in people of other faiths; every person bears the image of God, and all goodness comes from Him. But moral fruit is a sign, not the whole case. The Christian claim is that something has happened in history: God the Word became man, died and rose. That is a different kind of claim from producing good people, and it can be examined on its own evidence.

The same is true of experience. People of many traditions are sincere in their experiences of the divine. Sincerity is not the question; what has actually happened is. The article on other religions’ miracle and experience claims shows how such reports are weighed.

[2]

Asking the same questions of every religion sounds fair, but the questions have been chosen to suit Christianity, which is a historical religion. Other traditions do not rest on public events and cannot be judged this way.

Each tradition should be asked what kind of evidence it offers for its own claims, and judged by that: a revelation to one person, a way of practice, a sacred text. Coherence and the fruit of life apply to every tradition alike.

That Christianity rests on public events is not a rule chosen to favour it; it is what the apostles themselves proclaimed. By grounding its faith in history, the Church accepts a test that could have refuted it, and that is a mark of its confidence, not an unfair advantage.

[3]

Conclusion

Religions that contradict each other cannot all be true, and saying so is a matter of honesty, not contempt. A fair comparison asks the same questions of every tradition. The Christian faith rests on public events that can be examined, above all the death and resurrection of Jesus, and that witness stands. The Church confesses Jesus Christ as the Son of God and the Saviour of the world, and she gives the reason for her hope with gentleness and love toward every neighbour.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close