Faith & Evidence / God’s existence and knowledge
Does disagreement among religions weaken belief in God?
The answer
No. Religions really do disagree, but disagreement does not mean that no one is right. People disagree about history, science and morals, and the truth is not lost. On the first question, whether there is a God, the religions of the world largely agree. On the second, which faith tells the truth about Him, the answer is found by examining the claims, not by counting believers. Christianity rests on a claim that can be examined: that Jesus of Nazareth was crucified and rose from the dead. That one’s faith is first received from family does not make it false; it invites us to know why we believe. The Church confesses that Christ is the way, the truth and the life, that God desires all to be saved, and that the judgement of every person belongs to God.
- Disagreement does not decide truth. Experts disagree in every field, and in many of them one side is right.
- Separate two questions: is there a God (broad agreement across history), and which faith has the truth about Him (where the claims must be examined).
- The argument from birthplace is true of nearly every belief, including scepticism, and says nothing about whether a belief is true.
- Christianity rests on events in history, above all the resurrection of Christ, which can be examined.
- The Church confesses Christ as the way, the truth and the life, honours truth found elsewhere, and leaves the judgement of persons to God.
Why this question matters
A classmate, friend or neighbour of another religion is a normal part of life today, and so is the thought that one’s own faith might be an accident of birth. Many young believers meet this objection first in conversation and are unsure how to answer. Many seekers use it as a reason not to commit to anything.
Christians have sometimes spoken harshly or carelessly about others on this question. The right answer states the Church’s faith in Christ plainly and treats people of other faiths with love and respect.
Religions disagree on many things: whether God is one or many or beyond personal terms, whether the world has a beginning, what happens after death, what is wrong with human beings and what can be done about it, and who Jesus was. At the same time, many religious traditions share a sense that the world depends on a reality beyond itself and that there are moral demands that are not simply human choices. The philosophy of religion distinguishes the questions that follow from this, and the Stanford Encyclopedia’s entry on religious diversity gives a standard overview of the main positions.
Three positions are usual. Exclusivism holds that one religion has the truth about salvation and the others are mistaken on essential points. Inclusivism holds that one religion has the truth in its fullness, while others may contain real truth and may, in ways known to God, be means of salvation. Pluralism, associated with the philosopher John Hick, holds that the major traditions are different responses to one ultimate reality, and that none is uniquely true. Critics of pluralism observe that it requires reading the traditions’ own claims as secondary to a theory none of them holds. Critics of exclusivism ask how it can be justified given the number of sincere people on other paths.
There is also a distinct argument from the way people get their beliefs. Most people stay in the religion of their family and region, and a person born elsewhere would probably hold a different one. Philosophers who write on disagreement distinguish cases where the other person is as informed and as careful as oneself (where some think one should lower one’s confidence) from cases where there is reason to think one has better evidence or has reasoned more carefully, and they disagree about how these principles apply to religion.
Terms used
- Apologetics: The reasoned defence and explanation of a belief. It offers arguments and evidence for examination; it does not replace faith or guarantee agreement.
- Theism: The view that there is one personal God who made and sustains the world.
- Christology: Teaching about who Christ is, especially how divinity and humanity are united in him.
- Miaphysitism: The Coptic Orthodox teaching, from Cyril of Alexandria, that Christ is one incarnate nature of the Word, from two natures united without mixture, confusion or alteration. It rejects the idea of a single blended nature.
- Tradition: In the Orthodox understanding, the Church’s lived and handed-on faith, within which Scripture is read.
The evidence
The existence of disagreement among religions does not show that none of them is true, or that there is no God.
People disagree in science, history, ethics and philosophy, yet no one concludes that there is no truth in these fields. Disagreement calls for careful examination of the reasons, and the Christian faith welcomes that examination. [1]
The question of God’s existence and the question of which faith is true are different, and religious diversity bears on them in different ways.
Across history and cultures, people have widely held that there is a reality beyond the physical world on which it depends. The deeper differences concern the character of God, salvation, and Christ. The first question is answered in the articles on the arguments for God; the second in the articles on the historical Jesus and the resurrection. [1]
That a person’s religion is shaped by upbringing does not show it is false; it is an invitation to know the reasons for one’s faith.
Where a belief came from is one thing; whether it is true is another. This holds for beliefs in science and politics as much as in religion. Many who received the faith from their parents have examined it and found it well founded. [1]
The Church confesses that Jesus Christ is the way, the truth and the life, that God desires all people to be saved, and that the judgement of every person belongs to God; she also holds that people everywhere have some knowledge of God and of the good.
This is the teaching of Scripture and the Fathers: Christ alone is Saviour, God wills the salvation of all, and the Word enlightens every human being. St Justin Martyr already taught in the second century that every truth spoken anywhere belongs to Christ. [2] [3] [4] [5] [6]
The number of religions in the world does not decide which is true. Christianity stands or falls with what happened to Jesus of Nazareth: His death under Pontius Pilate and His resurrection on the third day. That evidence is set out in the articles on the historical Jesus and the resurrection, and it is there that the question is answered.
In Scripture
John 14:6
King James Version
6 Jesus saith unto him, I am the way, the truth, and the life: no man cometh unto the Father, but by me.
Acts 17:22–31
King James Version
22 ¶ Then Paul stood in the midst of Mars’ hill, and said, Ye men of Athens, I perceive that in all things ye are too superstitious.
23 For as I passed by, and beheld your devotions, I found an altar with this inscription, TO THE UNKNOWN GOD. Whom therefore ye ignorantly worship, him declare I unto you.
24 God that made the world and all things therein, seeing that he is Lord of heaven and earth, dwelleth not in temples made with hands;
25 Neither is worshipped with men’s hands, as though he needed any thing, seeing he giveth to all life, and breath, and all things;
26 And hath made of one blood all nations of men for to dwell on all the face of the earth, and hath determined the times before appointed, and the bounds of their habitation;
27 That they should seek the Lord, if haply they might feel after him, and find him, though he be not far from every one of us:
28 For in him we live, and move, and have our being; as certain also of your own poets have said, For we are also his offspring.
29 Forasmuch then as we are the offspring of God, we ought not to think that the Godhead is like unto gold, or silver, or stone, graven by art and man’s device.
30 And the times of this ignorance God winked at; but now commandeth all men every where to repent:
31 Because he hath appointed a day, in the which he will judge the world in righteousness by that man whom he hath ordained; whereof he hath given assurance unto all men, in that he hath raised him from the dead.
1 Timothy 2:3–6
King James Version
3 For this is good and acceptable in the sight of God our Saviour;
4 Who will have all men to be saved, and to come unto the knowledge of the truth.
5 For there is one God, and one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus;
6 Who gave himself a ransom for all, to be testified in due time.
John 1:9
King James Version
9 That was the true Light, which lighteth every man that cometh into the world.
What the Church teaches
The Church confesses Christ as the way, the truth and the life, and invites all people to know Him. It also says that God has not left Himself without witness anywhere, that the Word enlightens every person, and that truth and goodness found in other traditions are not to be despised. Since the Church does not know the hearts of persons, it does not declare who is saved or lost, and it prays for the whole world.
The Christian response to the diversity of religions is therefore neither contempt nor the claim that all religions are the same. It is a clear witness to Christ, respect for every person, honesty about differences, and trust that God’s mercy is wider than our knowledge.
The Coptic Orthodox Church, living for centuries beside Judaism, Islam and other communities in Egypt, has had long practice in living with neighbours of other faiths while holding fast to its own confession. Its faith is that Christ, the incarnate Word, is the one Saviour, and that the Church is the body in which His life is given through the sacraments. It has not turned that faith into a claim to know the fate of any particular person.
The Church teaches its children to love their neighbours, to answer questions with gentleness and respect, and to give an account of their hope. That is the Church’s guidance, not a policy decided on this site.
Objections answered
If religions contradict each other, at most one can be right, and most believers are therefore wrong. Since each believer is equally sincere, it is more likely that all of them are wrong. This is a reason to doubt any one of them.
The step from “at most one is right” to “probably none is right” does not follow. Contradictory answers are what we find in every field where there is a right answer. The right response is to examine the evidence of each, not to give a verdict against all.
Sincerity is not evidence of truth in any field; sincere people hold mistaken views in science and history. What matters is the ground of a belief, and Christianity offers a ground of a particular kind: events in history, above all the resurrection of Christ, which can be examined.
Almost everyone adopts the religion of their parents or their country. If you had been born in another place, you would believe something else, so your belief is the product of chance and not of reasons.
The same could be said of almost all our beliefs, including a person’s politics, trust in science, or scepticism. How a belief was acquired is separate from whether it is well founded. Many beliefs first received from parents are later examined and confirmed, and conversions in both directions show that upbringing does not decide the outcome.
The real value of the objection is that it invites the believer to know the reasons for the hope within. The Church welcomes that question and encourages her children to study their faith.
It is arrogant to claim that your religion alone is true. A loving God would not condemn billions of people for being born in the wrong place. Pluralism is the humbler and more moral view.
The Church does not teach that God condemns people for the accident of birth. She confesses that God desires all to be saved, that every person has some light from the Word, and that God alone judges. She holds that salvation is in Christ, and she entrusts to God’s mercy those who have not heard of Him.
Believing that something is true is not arrogance. Pluralism also makes a claim about all religions, one that the religions themselves reject. Humility is shown in how we treat others and in our readiness to give reasons and to listen.
Conclusion
The disagreement among religions does not refute belief in God or the Christian faith. It invites us to examine the reasons, and the Christian faith rests on reasons that can be examined, above all the resurrection of Christ. The Church holds Christ to be the way, the truth and the life, honours the truth found elsewhere, treats every person with love, and entrusts all to God’s mercy.
Sources
- Religious Diversity (Pluralism) · Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy · whole entry (overview of competing truth claims; section not cited)
- John 14:6
- Acts 17:22–31
- 1 Timothy 2:3–6
- John 1:9
- First Apology · Justin Martyr · First Apology, ch. 46
No inbox has been set up yet, so nothing is sent. This copies a short report with the page address and revision for you to pass on.