Orthodoxia

Faith & Evidence / God’s existence and knowledge

Can science establish or exclude every kind of divine action?

IntermediatePhilosophicalScientificAnswer available

Revision 1, updated

The answer

No. Science studies the natural order by seeking natural causes and testing them, and it does this very well. But by its very method it cannot reach beyond that order to its Maker. It cannot show that the world does not depend on God, and it cannot show that God does not act. “Miracles cannot happen” is a philosophical belief brought to science, not a result of science. Science can help check whether a reported event happened, for example whether a disease was present and then gone; whether God acted is then weighed by the evidence and by reason. The Church confesses that God holds all things in being at every moment, works through the order He made, and also acts freely by signs and miracles, above all in raising Christ from the dead.

  • Science seeks natural explanations and tests them. It is silent about whether the natural order is itself God’s creation and gift.
  • It can investigate whether an unusual event occurred and whether known natural causes account for it. It cannot detect an agent who is not part of the natural order, or tell us what such an agent would or would not do.
  • “Laws of nature” describe how things regularly behave when nothing else acts. A free act of their Creator does not contradict them; to say it would, one must first assume the world is a closed system.
  • Hume argued that testimony could never establish a miracle; but his argument assumes what is in question, and testimony must be weighed case by case.
  • The Church confesses that God sustains the world, works through natural causes, and also acts by signs that point to Him.

Why this question matters

Many people assume, without having thought it through, that science has shown miracles to be impossible, or that science and faith live in separate worlds. Others take every unexplained event to be a divine act. Seeing clearly what science does and does not do frees a believer from all three mistakes.

It also matters for everything else on this site. The Christian faith rests on events, above all the resurrection of Christ, that are acts of God in history. A believer should know that science does not rule them out, and that they can be examined on the evidence.

The sciences proceed by seeking natural explanations for events and testing them against observation. This is called methodological naturalism, and it has been very successful. It is a rule of method, not a conclusion about what exists. It is why a scientist, whatever his or her religion, does not write “God did it” as an answer in a laboratory report, and why a scientist who is a Christian can use that method with integrity. It is not the same as philosophical naturalism, the view that nature is all there is, and science itself does not establish that view.

What would a scientific test of divine action look like? Experiments need repeatable conditions, controls and a prediction that could fail. An agent who is not part of the natural order, and who acts freely, does not provide any of these. So science cannot establish that God acts, in the way it can establish that a drug works. For the same reason it cannot exclude that He acts: the failure to find a natural cause in a given case shows that a cause has not been found, not that there is none, and that a natural cause was found does not show that the natural order is not itself God’s work. Science can, however, investigate a claim about an event: whether a recovery occurred, what the medical records show, and what natural explanations are available. Reports of unexplained events are open to such checks.

Philosophers have argued at length about miracles. The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy sets out the main debates, including how to define a miracle (a violation of a law of nature, or an event brought about by God that natural causes alone would not produce) and the argument of David Hume (1711–1776), who held that since the evidence for the regularity of nature is very strong, the testimony needed to establish a miracle would have to be stronger still, which he thought it never was. Philosophers, religious and not, still discuss the argument. Hume’s defenders add that reports of marvels are common and often false. But that is a reason to weigh each report carefully, not to rule them all out in advance: Hume’s argument either assumes that miracles do not occur or mishandles probability, and the right question is how probable a report is on all the evidence, including the reasons we have to believe in God.

Terms used

  • Apologetics: The reasoned defence and explanation of a belief. It offers arguments and evidence for examination; it does not replace faith or guarantee agreement.
  • Resurrection: In Christian teaching, Jesus’ bodily rising from the dead to a transformed life. It is a different claim from the claim that his followers came to believe it.
  • Miracle: An event believed to result from God acting beyond the ordinary course of nature.
  • Theism: The view that there is one personal God who made and sustains the world.
  • Tradition: In the Orthodox understanding, the Church’s lived and handed-on faith, within which Scripture is read.

The evidence

Science, as a method, seeks and tests natural explanations; it is therefore silent on whether the natural order depends on God, and it cannot by its own method establish or exclude a free act of God.

Experiments need repeatable conditions, controls and predictions that could fail. A free Creator who is not part of nature provides none of these. Failing to find a natural cause shows only that one has not been found; finding one does not show that nature is not God’s work. This is the ordinary understanding of methodological naturalism: a rule of method, not a conclusion about what exists. [1]

Science can examine whether a reported unusual event occurred and what natural explanations are available, so claims of miracle are open to honest investigation.

Whether an event happened is examined by the evidence: records, witnesses, medical findings. Whether it was an act of God is then judged by reason, by what the event means and by everything else we know of God. Both questions can be answered rationally; neither is closed by science. [1] [2]

Hume’s argument does not show that miracles are impossible or that testimony can never establish one.

Hume set the regularity of nature against every report of a miracle. But if nature is counted as never interrupted only by refusing every report of an interruption, the argument assumes its conclusion. The right question is how probable a report is on all the evidence, including the reasons we have to believe in God. At most, Hume teaches us to weigh reports carefully, which the Church has always done. [2]

The Church teaches that God creates and sustains all things at every moment, works through natural causes, and also acts by signs and miracles that point to Him; it does not regard these as breaking the order He made, but as His free action within it.

Scripture says that God sends His word and the snow melts (Psalm 147), and that the Son upholds all things by the word of His power (Hebrews 1:3). The Gospels present Christ’s miracles as signs that reveal His glory, and the risen Lord answered St Thomas’s request to see and touch. This is the Church’s teaching on providence and miracles, from Scripture and the Fathers. [3] [4] [5] [6]

Whether a particular event reported as an act of God happened is a historical question, examined on the evidence. Science does not exclude such an event in advance, and the philosophical objections to miracles do not close the question. The most important case, the resurrection of Jesus, is examined in the articles on the crucifixion and resurrection, where the evidence is shown to be early, multiple and strong.

In Scripture

Psalms 147:15–18

King James Version

15 He sendeth forth his commandment upon earth: his word runneth very swiftly.

16 He giveth snow like wool: he scattereth the hoarfrost like ashes.

17 He casteth forth his ice like morsels: who can stand before his cold?

18 He sendeth out his word, and melteth them: he causeth his wind to blow, and the waters flow.

Hebrews 1:3

King James Version

3 Who being the brightness of his glory, and the express image of his person, and upholding all things by the word of his power, when he had by himself purged our sins, sat down on the right hand of the Majesty on high;

John 2:1–11

King James Version

1 And the third day there was a marriage in Cana of Galilee; and the mother of Jesus was there:

2 And both Jesus was called, and his disciples, to the marriage.

3 And when they wanted wine, the mother of Jesus saith unto him, They have no wine.

4 Jesus saith unto her, Woman, what have I to do with thee? mine hour is not yet come.

5 His mother saith unto the servants, Whatsoever he saith unto you, do it.

6 And there were set there six waterpots of stone, after the manner of the purifying of the Jews, containing two or three firkins apiece.

7 Jesus saith unto them, Fill the waterpots with water. And they filled them up to the brim.

8 And he saith unto them, Draw out now, and bear unto the governor of the feast. And they bare it.

9 When the ruler of the feast had tasted the water that was made wine, and knew not whence it was: (but the servants which drew the water knew;) the governor of the feast called the bridegroom,

10 And saith unto him, Every man at the beginning doth set forth good wine; and when men have well drunk, then that which is worse: but thou hast kept the good wine until now.

11 This beginning of miracles did Jesus in Cana of Galilee, and manifested forth his glory; and his disciples believed on him.

John 20:24–29

King James Version

24 ¶ But Thomas, one of the twelve, called Didymus, was not with them when Jesus came.

25 The other disciples therefore said unto him, We have seen the Lord. But he said unto them, Except I shall see in his hands the print of the nails, and put my finger into the print of the nails, and thrust my hand into his side, I will not believe.

26 ¶ And after eight days again his disciples were within, and Thomas with them: then came Jesus, the doors being shut, and stood in the midst, and said, Peace be unto you.

27 Then saith he to Thomas, Reach hither thy finger, and behold my hands; and reach hither thy hand, and thrust it into my side: and be not faithless, but believing.

28 And Thomas answered and said unto him, My Lord and my God.

29 Jesus saith unto him, Thomas, because thou hast seen me, thou hast believed: blessed are they that have not seen, and yet have believed.

What the Church teaches

The Christian faith understands the world as made by God and held in being by Him. Within that, the ordinary course of nature is itself God’s gift and faithfulness, and the miracles of Scripture are His special acts, which the Church receives as signs of the kingdom and of Christ’s divinity. The greatest of them is the resurrection of Christ, which the Church takes to be the beginning of the new creation.

The Church does not need science to prove miracles, and it does not fear that science will disprove them. It asks the believer to be thankful for the order of nature, to be open to the wonder of God’s action, and to be honest in weighing reports.

The Coptic Orthodox Church has a lived tradition of miracles: healings and answered prayers are recounted in the lives of its saints, and the Church sees in the sacraments, above all the Eucharist, God’s action through material things. At the same time it has always asked for discernment, for examination of claims under the guidance of the bishops and spiritual fathers, and for care not to make wonders the foundation of faith.

The foundation is Christ Himself, risen from the dead; the wonders God works through His saints point back to Him.

Objections answered

The laws of nature have never been observed to fail. Every time a mysterious event has been investigated, a natural cause has been found. Rationally, then, we should assume that natural causes will always be found, and treat claims of miracles as mistakes or fraud.

The objection treats a strong general regularity as if it settled every particular case, which is exactly what is in question. The laws of nature describe what happens when nothing else acts. They say nothing about whether their Creator acts, so a report that He did does not contradict them.

The success of science gives good reason to look for natural causes, and the Church does so too; many miracle reports are rightly set aside. But "usually" does not mean "always", and a rule that every report must be a mistake or a fraud is a decision made before looking at the evidence.

[2]

If God acts in the world, then He fills the gaps that science has not yet closed, and each time science explains something the space for God shrinks. A faith that depends on unexplained events is doomed.

The Church’s faith is not a "God of the gaps". Her first teaching is that God gives being to everything and holds it in being at every moment. Natural processes are, so to speak, God’s ordinary way of working, and every success of science in explaining them shows more of the wisdom of the Creator.

Signs and miracles are not gaps either. They are events in which God acts in a way that reveals who He is, and their meaning lies in what they show, not in the absence of a natural explanation. The resurrection of Christ is not a gap in biology; it is the beginning of the new creation.

[3] [4]

To say that God acts in the world, one has to say how. Either He breaks the laws of physics, which is incoherent, or He acts only by working through them, in which case there is no difference between divine action and natural causes.

The dilemma is false. God is not one cause among others inside the world, competing with natural causes for room. He is the Creator who gives every cause its being and its power. He can work through the order He made, and He can also act directly, as its Lord, without contradicting it, just as an author can add a new chapter without breaking the rules of his own story.

The Church confesses that God acts; she does not need a mechanism for the Creator. We do not know how God raised Christ, but we know that He did.

Every religion reports miracles, and they contradict one another. If miracle reports from other religions are unreliable, so are Christian ones, and if they are all reliable, they cancel out.

Reports are weighed one by one: who the source is, how close to the event, how specific, what evidence there is apart from the report, and what the event means. Some are far better supported than others, and the Church herself does not accept every report of a wonder. Careful weighing of testimony is a Christian principle.

All-or-nothing is not how evidence works, in history or in a court. The resurrection of Christ, proclaimed publicly within a few years by many witnesses in the city where it happened, can be weighed on its own evidence, and it stands.

[2]

Conclusion

Science cannot exclude divine action. It studies the order of nature, and it cannot by its method reach beyond that order to the Creator who gives it being. The claim that miracles cannot happen is a philosophy, not a finding. The Church gives thanks for the order of nature as God’s faithful gift, confesses that He also acts freely by signs that reveal Him, and proclaims the greatest of them: Christ is risen.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close