Faith & Evidence / God’s existence and knowledge
Can the universe be eternal?
The answer
No. God alone is eternal; the world was created and has a beginning. Scripture opens with it: in the beginning God created the heavens and the earth. Reason points the same way: a past made of real events, added one after another, could never have reached an infinite length, and a strong tradition, from Bonaventure among Christians to al-Ghazali among Muslims, has argued that an actual infinite series of past events cannot exist. Science fits this picture well: the universe is expanding from a very hot, dense state about 13.8 billion years ago, and important theorems make a past with no beginning hard to maintain. And even a world without a first moment would still exist only because God gives it being at every moment.
- An eternal universe would be one with no first moment. The question is whether that is possible, and whether our universe is like that.
- An actual infinite series of real events cannot be built up one event at a time, so the past must be finite.
- Cosmology shows an expanding universe from a hot dense state about 13.8 billion years ago, a picture that fits a beginning.
- Models proposed to avoid a beginning (bounces, cycles, eternal inflation) remain unconfirmed, and many of them still seem to need a beginning further back.
- Christian faith teaches that the world was created, and Genesis 1:1 speaks of a beginning. It also teaches that everything depends on God whatever its age.
- The question matters for the kalam argument, but not for the contingency argument, which would apply to an eternal universe as well.
Why this question matters
People often hear that the universe has simply always been there, so it needs no Creator. Looking carefully at what reason and physics say shows that this is not so.
It also helps believers see what their faith rests on. The beginning of the world is taught by Scripture, supported by reason, and well matched by science; and the world’s dependence on God holds firm whatever any future model of physics says.
Ancient thinkers divided on the question. Aristotle held that the world has always existed. Jewish, Christian and Muslim thinkers generally held that the world was created and had a beginning, and several of them argued philosophically that an infinite past is impossible, among them the Muslim thinker al-Ghazali and the Christian Bonaventure. The argument is the root of the kalam form of the cosmological argument. Thomas Aquinas, by contrast, held that reason cannot demonstrate that the world began and that the beginning is known by faith.
The philosophical argument has two forms. One says that an actual infinite collection of things cannot exist, and a past with no beginning would be such a collection of past events. The other says that even if an actual infinite is possible, it could not be formed by adding one event after another, so the series of past events cannot be infinite. Some object that mathematics treats infinite sets without contradiction and that the past need not be built up from a first member. But an infinite that is consistent on paper is not the same as an endless series of real events that has actually been gone through, one after another, to reach today. The discussion is technical and goes on among philosophers, theist and non-theist.
The scientific picture is that the universe is expanding, and that running the expansion backwards leads to a very hot, dense state about 13.8 billion years ago. This is the standard Big Bang model. The model describes the development of the universe from that state and does not itself say what, if anything, came before. Classical general relativity predicts a singularity where its own equations fail, and most physicists regard that as a sign that the theory is incomplete at those scales and a quantum theory of gravity is needed. Proposals about what lies before include a bounce from a previous contracting phase, cycles, eternal inflation producing many regions, and models without a sharp boundary. Theorems about expanding universes have been taken to show that a past without any beginning is hard to maintain in many models, while their authors and others note that the assumptions can be avoided. None of these models has been confirmed.
Scripture, read as an ancient text, opens with a beginning: in the beginning God created the heavens and the earth (Genesis 1:1), and the Gospel of John echoes this with the Word who was in the beginning, through whom all things came to be (John 1:1–3). A psalm contrasts the created world with God who is from everlasting to everlasting (Psalm 90:2). Athanasius of Alexandria teaches that the world was brought into being from nothing through the Word (S52). The Christian tradition therefore holds that the world has a beginning, and it also teaches that time itself is created.
Richard Swinburne’s works examine the cosmological argument within a cumulative case and take it in a form that does not rest on the universe having a beginning (S39 for the full presentation). They are cited as whole works for their overall approach, because only the publisher pages have been consulted.
Terms used
- Theism: The view that there is one personal God who made and sustains the world.
- Cosmological argument: An argument from the existence or beginning of the universe to a cause or explanation beyond it.
- Inspiration: The Christian belief that God worked through the human authors of Scripture. It is a theological claim, distinct from the preservation of manuscripts.
The evidence
A past with no beginning faces a deep difficulty: an actual infinite series of real events cannot be formed by adding one event after another.
If the past had no beginning, an infinite number of days would already have passed before today, and today could never have arrived. Mathematics can describe infinite sets as abstract objects, but real days happen one after another. This argument, carefully developed by Jewish, Christian and Muslim thinkers, remains strong. [5]
The Christian tradition teaches that the world was created and has a beginning, and also that it depends on God whatever its age.
Genesis 1:1 opens with the beginning; St John tells us that all things came to be through the Word, who was in the beginning; Psalm 90 sets the everlasting God apart from a world that came to be; and St Athanasius teaches that God brought all things into being from nothing through His Word. [1] [2] [3] [4]
History shows that the Church held the beginning of the world long before modern cosmology. When Greek philosophy, following Aristotle, taught that the world had always existed, the Fathers confessed that it was created from nothing, and Christian thinkers such as Bonaventure argued from reason that the past cannot be infinite. Twentieth-century physics, by finding that the universe is expanding from a hot dense state, came to a picture far closer to the Church’s confession than to Aristotle’s.
In Scripture
Genesis 1:1
King James Version
1 In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth.
John 1:1–3
King James Version
1 In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God.
2 The same was in the beginning with God.
3 All things were made by him; and without him was not any thing made that was made.
Psalms 90:2
King James Version
2 Before the mountains were brought forth, or ever thou hadst formed the earth and the world, even from everlasting to everlasting, thou art God.
What the Church teaches
The Church confesses that the world is created, that it has a beginning in God’s will, and that time itself is a creature. She does not depend on the physics: if the universe turned out to have no first moment in physical time, the faith would still hold that it exists only because God gives it being. God alone is without beginning; everything else receives its being from Him.
The Coptic Orthodox Church reads Genesis as the revelation that God made all things, and its teachers have read the details of the creation account in different ways, literal, symbolic or moral. The Church’s teaching does not tie her to a particular age for the universe or a particular model, but to the confession that everything that exists was made by the Father through the Son in the Holy Spirit.
Objections answered
The argument against an actual infinite fails. Mathematics works with infinite sets without contradiction, and a past that has no first moment does not need to be “completed” by counting from a start.
Mathematical sets are abstract; real events in time actually occur, one after another. What holds for numbers on paper need not hold for the world. When we imagine real infinities, such as a hotel with infinitely many rooms that is full yet can always take more guests, the results are absurd.
Nor does it help to say that a beginningless past has no starting point to count from. The problem is not where the counting starts but that it must be finished: every past day has actually happened, and an infinite series cannot be completed one step at a time.
The Big Bang theory does not say the universe began from nothing. It describes the expansion from a hot dense state, and physics may find that the universe has an older history or is part of something larger. To claim a beginning is to claim more than the science says.
The Church does not rest her faith on a physical model. She knows the beginning of the world from God’s revelation, and reason supports it. The Big Bang model describes the expansion from a hot dense state, and its very earliest moments lie beyond current physics.
But the science fits the Christian picture far better than the old idea of a changeless, eternal cosmos. The models proposed to avoid a beginning have serious difficulties of their own, none has been confirmed, and theorems about expanding universes make an absolute beginning hard to avoid in many of them.
If the universe could be eternal then the argument for a creator fails, since there would be no moment at which a cause was needed.
This is true of the kalam form, which depends on the universe having begun. It is not true of the contingency form, which asks why a universe of any age exists and so applies to an eternal universe as well. The Fathers who held that the world was created also held that it is sustained at every moment by God, which does not depend on its having a first moment.
The principle behind it, that what could have failed to exist needs a reason for existing, is one we rely on everywhere in life and science, as the article on whether the universe needs an explanation shows. An eternal universe would still need its Creator.
Conclusion
The universe is not eternal; God alone is. Scripture teaches that the world had a beginning, reason shows that an infinite past of real events could never have been completed, and modern cosmology fits a universe that began. Most deeply of all, the world exists at every moment only because God gives it being. In the beginning God created the heavens and the earth, through His Word, by whom all things were made.
Sources
- Genesis 1:1
- John 1:1–3
- Psalms 90:2
- On the Incarnation · Athanasius of Alexandria · ch. 1–3 (creation through the Word, and from nothing)
- The Existence of God · Richard Swinburne
No inbox has been set up yet, so nothing is sent. This copies a short report with the page address and revision for you to pass on.