Faith & Evidence / God’s existence and knowledge
Does fine-tuning support belief in a creator?
The answer
Yes, it points to a Creator. Physics shows that life depends on several features of the universe, certain constants and starting conditions, lying within narrow ranges: change one of them in the models, and there are no stars, no stable atoms, no chemistry for life. Such order is what we would expect if a wise Mind made the world, and it is hard to account for by chance. Appeals to a deeper law or a multiverse only move the question back a step, for they too need explaining. The Church's faith does not rest on physics, but fine-tuning fits what she confesses: God made all things, visible and invisible, and His wisdom shines in the order of creation.
- The scientific part is real: in physical models, small changes to some constants or early conditions would leave no stars, no stable atoms or no chemistry of the kind life needs.
- Order of this kind is what we would expect from a Mind that chose it, and it is hard to explain by chance.
- A deeper law or a multiverse does not remove the question; it moves it back a step, since that law or that multiverse would need explaining too.
- The argument points to a Mind that ordered the universe. The Church knows that Mind fully as the God who has revealed Himself in Christ.
- The Church confesses God as Creator of all things and finds His wisdom in creation. Her faith does not rest on physics, and it welcomes all that physics discovers.
Why this question matters
Fine-tuning is one of the most often quoted arguments for God, and one of the most often misquoted. Popular versions state exact-sounding numbers, while others dismiss the argument in one sentence. A reader deserves to see what is really claimed, and why it carries weight.
It also shows how faith and science fit together: physics describes the order of the world, reason asks what best explains it, and the believer confesses the God who made it.
Physics describes the universe with laws that contain fixed numbers (constants), such as the strengths of the fundamental forces and the masses of particles, together with starting conditions at the beginning of the expanding universe. Theoretical physicists can ask what would happen if one of these numbers were different while the others stayed as they are. In many such models the result is a universe that could not form stars and heavy elements, or could not hold together atoms and molecules, or would expand too fast for matter to gather or collapse too soon. That sensitivity of life-permitting conditions to the values is what is meant by fine-tuning.
Some familiar cases are well established as physics. The abundance of carbon in stars depends on the details of nuclear reactions, and the astronomer Fred Hoyle drew attention to this in the 1950s. The cosmological constant, which governs the acceleration of the expansion, is observed to be extremely small compared with some theoretical estimates, and Steven Weinberg argued in 1987 that a much larger value would have prevented galaxies from forming. The numbers quoted in popular books vary with their assumptions, so this article gives no figures.
The argument built on this has two steps. The first is the scientific claim that life-permitting values occupy a narrow band. The second is philosophical: that such a narrow band is more to be expected if a mind chose the values than if they are as they are by chance or necessity. Richard Swinburne, a philosopher and Eastern Orthodox Christian, defends this type of reasoning as one strand of a wider cumulative case. Here his work is cited only as a whole.
Terms used
- Apologetics: The reasoned defence and explanation of a belief. It offers arguments and evidence for examination; it does not replace faith or guarantee agreement.
- Miracle: An event believed to result from God acting beyond the ordinary course of nature.
- Theism: The view that there is one personal God who made and sustains the world.
- Cosmological argument: An argument from the existence or beginning of the universe to a cause or explanation beyond it.
- Fine-tuning: The observation that some physical constants fall in a narrow range compatible with life, and the debate over what that implies.
- Tradition: In the Orthodox understanding, the Church’s lived and handed-on faith, within which Scripture is read.
The evidence
The narrow life-permitting range of the universe's constants is well explained by a Mind that chose them.
This is an argument to the best explanation, which thoughtful theists such as Swinburne present as one strand of a wider case. A narrow band of life-permitting values is far more to be expected if a Mind chose them than if they fell out by chance. [1]
The Church confesses that creation is ordered and good, and that its order leads people to wonder at its Maker.
This is what the Scriptures teach about creation and its order: the heavens bear witness to God's glory, and His power is seen in what He has made. The Church taught it long before modern physics. [2] [3] [4]
The argument is philosophical rather than historical: it rests not on an event, a text or a witness, but on the structure of the universe.
In Scripture
Psalms 19:1–4
King James Version
1 The heavens declare the glory of God; and the firmament sheweth his handywork.
2 Day unto day uttereth speech, and night unto night sheweth knowledge.
3 There is no speech nor language, where their voice is not heard.
4 Their line is gone out through all the earth, and their words to the end of the world. In them hath he set a tabernacle for the sun,
Romans 1:19–20
King James Version
19 Because that which may be known of God is manifest in them; for God hath shewed it unto them.
20 For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his eternal power and Godhead; so that they are without excuse:
What the Church teaches
A Christian may rightly take the fine-tuning of the universe as a reason for wonder and a pointer to the Creator. The Church does not teach that people come to faith by calculating odds. It teaches that the God who made all things has made Himself known in His Word, and that He is worshipped in truth in the life of the Church.
Scripture is not a physics text, and the Church does not read Genesis or the Psalms as predictions about constants. What they teach is that the world is God’s work, ordered and good, and that its order speaks of Him. The confession in the Creed, “maker of heaven and earth, and of all things visible and invisible,” is a confession about who God is, and it holds whatever physics finds.
The Alexandrian Fathers spoke of creation as the work of the Father through the Word, from nothing, so that everything that exists depends on God at every moment. St Athanasius, in his writings against the pagans, also pointed to the harmony and order of creation as a witness to the Word who orders it. The Church’s use of the Psalms in the daily hours keeps this wonder in prayer: the believer praises the Creator for the heavens before ever calculating anything about them.
For this reason the Coptic Orthodox Church can welcome what physics discovers about the universe’s structure with interest and without fear, and it does not need to defend a particular scientific model in order to confess the Creator.
Objections answered
We have no way to say how probable the actual values were. To call a range “narrow” you need to know the range of values that were possible and a measure of how likely each was. Physics gives neither, so there is no probability to be astonished at (the normalisation problem).
The argument does not need exact numbers. It needs only the judgement that the life-permitting set is a small part of what could be varied. That is a comparative claim, like judging that a tiny target is hard to hit by chance without knowing the exact odds.
We make such judgements all the time without a precise measure. When a sequence of events lines up exactly as a purpose would require, we rightly look for a purpose, even if we cannot put a number on the odds.
A deeper physical theory may fix the values, so that they could not have been otherwise. Then there is nothing to explain by design, and the sense of improbability disappears. Physics has repeatedly explained as consequences of deeper laws what once looked like arbitrary numbers.
A deeper law may fix some of the values. But that law would itself have a form and constants of its own, so the question of why this law, with these features, would remain; it would only have moved back a level.
The objection does not remove the question of order; it changes where the question is asked. A law that makes life possible is itself a sign of a Lawgiver.
We only know of life like ours. Different physics might allow other kinds of complexity or life, so the claim that life needs these values is too narrow. And we exist, so of course we find conditions that permit us.
The argument speaks of life based on chemistry like ours, or at least of complex structure; without stars, atoms and chemistry, there is no complexity of any kind. The observer selection effect explains why we observe such a universe, but not why there is one; that exchange is taken up in the article on the selection effect and the multiverse.
If the argument is that God is needed because science cannot yet explain the values, it is a “God of the gaps”. If science explains them later, God will be pushed out and faith will be shaken.
A Christian should avoid any argument that rests on a gap in science. The argument from fine-tuning rests instead on the fact that the laws exist and have the character they have, which every future physics will also have to take as given.
If physics one day explains the constants, creation will still be God's work. The Church teaches that God sustains all that exists, including the laws by which it works, and no discovery can push Him out of His own creation.
Almost all of the universe is hostile to life, and the history of life includes enormous waste and suffering. A designer who wanted life would have made a universe better suited to it, so the evidence points away from a caring creator.
The argument says that the universe's basic structure makes life possible, not that life is its only purpose. A large and old universe may be the necessary setting for any life at all, and its vastness speaks of the greatness of its Maker. Suffering is a separate and serious question, taken up in the articles on the problem of evil.
Conclusion
The universe allows life only within narrow ranges of some constants and conditions, and that is a striking fact. It points to a wise Mind behind the world, and the alternatives only move the question back. The Church's faith in the Creator does not rest on physics, but she welcomes this witness of creation with wonder and gives glory to the God who made all things.
Sources
- The Existence of God · Richard Swinburne
- Psalms 19:1–4
- Romans 1:19–20
- The Holy Bible, as read on this site (KJV with Apocrypha; Arabic Van Dyck) · Various ancient authors; translations as listed on the Sources page · Wisdom of Solomon 13:1–5
No inbox has been set up yet, so nothing is sent. This copies a short report with the page address and revision for you to pass on.