Orthodoxia

Faith & Evidence / God’s existence and knowledge

Who created God?

IntroductoryPhilosophicalAnswer available

Revision 1, updated

The answer

Nobody created God. God is the one who is not made: He has no beginning and depends on nothing, and everything else depends on Him. The question treats God as one more thing inside the universe and then asks where He came from. But the arguments for a creator never say that everything has a cause. They say that whatever begins to exist, or could have failed to exist, has a cause. The universe is that kind of thing; God is not. He is the Maker, and He was never made.

  • Christians do not say that God was created; “God” means the one who is not made and has no beginning.
  • The arguments for a first cause say that what begins to exist, or what is contingent, has a cause. They never say that everything does.
  • Asking who made God treats Him as a part of the universe. He is its Maker, not a member of it.
  • The charge of special pleading misreads the argument: God is not exempted from a rule, He simply does not have the property the rule is about.
  • A designing mind is not complex like a machine. God is not composed of parts, so He is not the kind of thing that needs assembling or explaining.
  • The Son is “begotten, not made” in the Creed: His eternal origin from the Father is not creation.

Why this question matters

This is among the commonest objections to belief in God, often raised in childhood and never answered satisfactorily. It deserves a clear reply, because many people reject the arguments for a creator at this point without looking at what the arguments say.

It also shows how much depends on stating the argument correctly. Once we see what Christians actually say about God, the question answers itself.

The Bible does not treat God as made. Read as an ancient text, a psalm says that from everlasting to everlasting he is God (Psalm 90:2), Isaiah has God say that he is the first and the last and that there is no god besides him (Isaiah 44:6), and Revelation describes him as the Alpha and the Omega, who is and was and is to come (Revelation 1:8). In Exodus God gives his name in a form the tradition reads as “I am” (Exodus 3:14). The Church’s creed calls the Father maker of all things seen and unseen, and says of the Son that he is begotten, not made.

Christian philosophers add that “God” is not a name for the first member of a series of causes. They say that God is the source of every series, of time and of the universe, and is not the kind of thing that begins or ends. If that is the meaning of the word, then “who created God?” is like asking who the unmarried man’s wife is. It supposes what the term excludes.

The arguments for a first cause do not say that everything has a cause. In the kalam form they say that whatever begins to exist has a cause, and that the universe began. In the contingency form they say that things which might not have existed need an explanation, and that something which exists necessarily needs none. So the argument has its own way of excluding God from the requirement. Richard Swinburne, a philosopher and Eastern Orthodox Christian, maintains that God as an ultimate explanation is a simpler one than the universe as a brute fact (S38 for a general reader).

The objection takes another form in the writings of Richard Dawkins: a designer capable of making a universe would have to be at least as complex as what it explains, and so would need an explanation itself. Theists respond that the classical doctrine of God is of one who is not made of parts, and that explanation by a mind does not require that the mind be simple in the physical sense. Swinburne treats this simplicity as part of the case for God (S39).

Terms used

  • Theism: The view that there is one personal God who made and sustains the world.
  • Cosmological argument: An argument from the existence or beginning of the universe to a cause or explanation beyond it.
  • Trinity: The Christian teaching that God is one in essence and three in persons: Father, Son and Holy Spirit.
  • Tradition: In the Orthodox understanding, the Church’s lived and handed-on faith, within which Scripture is read.

The evidence

God is uncreated and without beginning, so the question “who created God?” does not apply to Him.

Scripture and the Creed present God as the first and the last, from everlasting to everlasting, with no maker. That is what the word “God” means. [1] [2] [3] [5]

The arguments for a first cause do not assert that everything has a cause. They assert it of things that begin to exist, or that are contingent, and so they never require a cause for God.

What needs a cause is what might not have been, or what had a beginning. A necessary, eternal being has neither feature. The explanation of everything that might not have been ends in the one who cannot fail to be. [7] [8]

The Son is not created: the Church confesses him begotten of the Father before all ages, and this eternal begetting is not an act of creation.

It is the teaching of the Nicene Creed, defended by St Athanasius against those who said the Son was a creature. The Word is the one through whom all things were made, so He stands on the side of the Maker. [4] [5] [6]

The objection is old in the sense that the early Church had to say clearly what was meant by an uncreated God, over against those who held that the Son was a creature or that matter was eternal. The Council of Nicaea in AD 325 is the best-known moment. The answer the Church gave then is the answer she gives now: God alone is uncreated, and all else was made by Him.

In Scripture

Psalms 90:2

King James Version

2 Before the mountains were brought forth, or ever thou hadst formed the earth and the world, even from everlasting to everlasting, thou art God.

Isaiah 44:6

King James Version

6 Thus saith the LORD the King of Israel, and his redeemer the LORD of hosts; I am the first, and I am the last; and beside me there is no God.

Revelation 1:8

King James Version

8 I am Alpha and Omega, the beginning and the ending, saith the Lord, which is, and which was, and which is to come, the Almighty.

John 1:1–3

King James Version

1 In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God.

2 The same was in the beginning with God.

3 All things were made by him; and without him was not any thing made that was made.

What the Church teaches

The Church confesses God as the one who is, without cause and without need, and who made the world by a free act of love. The answer to “who created God?” in her teaching is therefore simply that God is not a creature. The question belongs to the world of things that are made, and God is not one of them.

The Coptic Orthodox Church confesses the Father as unbegotten source, the Son as begotten of the Father before all ages, and the Holy Spirit as proceeding from the Father, one God in three persons. The Church’s prayers speak of God as without beginning and without end, and they pray to the Son as of one essence with the Father. This is the teaching Athanasius of Alexandria defended at Nicaea and afterwards.

Objections answered

This is special pleading. The argument says everything needs a cause, then makes an exception for God. If one thing can exist without a cause, the universe can too.

The argument never says that everything needs a cause. It says that what begins to exist, or what is contingent, needs one, and the reason lies in those very properties. God is not exempted from a rule; He simply lacks the features the rule is about.

Nor can the universe take God’s place. It is made of changing, dependent parts, and it bears every mark of something that might not have been. What needs no cause must be eternal, unchanging and dependent on nothing, and that is what Christians mean by God.

[7] [8]

A mind able to design a universe would be extraordinarily complex, and complex things are the kind that need explaining. So a designer explains nothing: it raises the question of its own origin.

The Christian tradition describes God as not composed of parts and as having no physical structure. A mind is not complex in the way a machine is, and explanation by an agent’s intention is among the simplest we have. The explanation of the universe is then not a more complex object but a single will.

Knowing much is not the same as being made of many pieces. Complexity that needs explaining is the complexity of parts arranged together, and God has no parts to arrange. So the designer does not raise the question of His own origin; He is where explanation rightly comes to rest.

[8]

If the Son is begotten of the Father, and the Holy Spirit proceeds from him, then God has an origin after all, and the Christian God is not uncaused.

The Church distinguishes between being begotten or proceeding within the one God and being created. The Father is the source within the Trinity, but the Son and the Spirit share the one divine nature and are eternal; they do not begin to exist. The Council of Nicaea set this against those who held that there was a time when the Son was not.

To be begotten eternally is not to begin. The Father was never without His Word, as the sun is never without its radiance. God has a source within Himself, the Father, but no cause outside Himself and no beginning. The Church confesses this mystery with reverence.

[5] [6]

Conclusion

No one created God. Christians have never said that God was made, and the arguments for a first cause have never said that everything needs a cause, so the question rests on a misreading of both. Whatever begins or depends needs a cause; God neither begins nor depends. He is the uncreated Maker of heaven and earth, and the Son, begotten of the Father before all ages, is with Him from eternity. It is a good question, and it has a clear answer.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close