Orthodoxia

Faith & Evidence / God’s existence and knowledge

What do cosmological arguments establish, if successful?

AdvancedPhilosophicalAnswer available

Revision 1, updated

The answer

The cosmological arguments lead reason to a Creator. The universe does not explain itself: it depends on something that does not itself depend on anything else, a first cause and necessary being. A cause that brought time, space and matter into being stands outside them, so it is timeless, non-physical and immensely powerful; and a timeless cause that produces a world in time points to a free choice, and so to a personal Creator. Reason can come this far. Who the Creator is, the Holy Trinity whose Son became incarnate for our salvation, God has made known in Christ. The arguments prepare the way; revelation fulfils it.

  • The universe does not explain itself: it has an independent ground, a first cause and necessary being.
  • That cause is outside time and space, because it brought them into being, and it is immensely powerful.
  • A timeless cause that produces a world in time points to a free choice, and so to a personal Creator.
  • Reason sees the Creator through creation (Romans 1:19–20); His goodness and His love are made known fully in His self-revelation.
  • The Trinity and the incarnation are known through revelation, received by the Church.
  • Christian theologians have long treated such arguments as a preparation for faith, not as a replacement for revelation.

Why this question matters

A common mistake on both sides is to treat the cosmological arguments as all or nothing. Some believers speak as if a first cause were the God of the Church; some sceptics speak as if, were the arguments to fail, all of Christian faith would be unsupported. Both miss the right relation between what reason shows and what God reveals.

Seeing that relation clearly helps the believer, who can give a reason for the hope within, and helps the enquirer, who is led from the Creator seen in creation to the Creator revealed in Christ.

The cosmological arguments take different forms. The kalam argument holds that whatever begins to exist has a cause, that the universe began, and so it has a cause. The contingency argument holds that what could have failed to exist needs an explanation, that the universe is such, and so it has an explanation outside itself. Aquinas’s “ways” also reason from motion, causation and dependence to a first source, and he is reported to end each with the remark that this is what everyone calls God. In the same work he goes on to argue separately for the divine attributes, which shows that he did not think the first step alone delivered them.

Defenders have drawn several conclusions from such an argument. A cause that produced time and space is not itself in time and space, and so is timeless and non-physical. Producing a whole universe indicates great power. A cause that is not caused needs no explanation of its own nature. One may argue that there is one such cause rather than many because we should not multiply causes beyond what is needed. And some argue that a timeless cause with no necessity behind its acting could have produced a temporal effect only through a free choice, which would make it personal. Critics grant the logic of some of these steps if the premises are granted but regard the last as the least secure, and point out that a necessary ground could be an impersonal principle.

Some things the arguments do not show. They do not show that the cause is good, since goodness is not part of the idea of a cause. They do not show that it knows or cares about creatures. They do not show that it is the God of Israel, the Father of Jesus Christ, or the Holy Trinity. Richard Swinburne, who defends the cosmological argument within a larger cumulative case, holds that it is the other considerations taken together that get from a ground of the universe to the God of theism (S39 for the full case, S38 for a general reader).

Scripture, read as an ancient text, does not argue from the cosmos to a first cause in this manner, but it does say that creation points beyond itself. A psalm says that the heavens declare God’s glory (Psalm 19:1), and St Paul the Apostle says that God’s power and divine nature have been perceived in the things made, so that people are without excuse (Romans 1:19–20). In Athens, St Paul says that God made the world and that people are meant to seek him, though he is not far from each of us, and then goes on to proclaim the resurrection of Jesus (Acts 17:24–31). The sequence is itself instructive: he begins with what can be known of the Creator and ends with what has been made known in Christ.

Terms used

  • Theism: The view that there is one personal God who made and sustains the world.
  • Cosmological argument: An argument from the existence or beginning of the universe to a cause or explanation beyond it.
  • Miaphysitism: The Coptic Orthodox teaching, from Cyril of Alexandria, that Christ is one incarnate nature of the Word, from two natures united without mixture, confusion or alteration. It rejects the idea of a single blended nature.
  • Trinity: The Christian teaching that God is one in essence and three in persons: Father, Son and Holy Spirit.

The evidence

The cosmological arguments show that the universe depends on an independent ground: a first cause and necessary being.

Whatever begins to exist has a cause, and the universe began; whatever could have failed to exist needs an explanation outside itself. Each main form of the argument reaches the same ground from its own starting point. [4] [5]

From that ground follow further attributes: it is timeless, non-physical and immensely powerful, and it is best understood as a personal Creator.

A cause that produced time and space is not itself in them, and producing a whole universe shows great power. A timeless cause with nothing compelling it could bring about a world that begins only by choosing to, and choice belongs to a person. [4]

Who the Creator is, the Holy Trinity, and what He has done in the incarnation, are known through revelation as the Church receives it.

The argument begins from the cosmos; the Gospel tells of God acting in history in Jesus Christ. Scripture itself moves from the witness of creation to the proclamation of Christ, as St Paul does in Athens (Acts 17:24–31). [1] [2] [3]

The cosmological arguments are philosophical, and the Gospel is historical: Jesus lived, died and rose again, and the evidence for that is set out in other articles. The two meet: the Creator whom reason glimpses is the God who raised Jesus from the dead.

In Scripture

Psalms 19:1–4

King James Version

1 The heavens declare the glory of God; and the firmament sheweth his handywork.

2 Day unto day uttereth speech, and night unto night sheweth knowledge.

3 There is no speech nor language, where their voice is not heard.

4 Their line is gone out through all the earth, and their words to the end of the world. In them hath he set a tabernacle for the sun,

Romans 1:19–20

King James Version

19 Because that which may be known of God is manifest in them; for God hath shewed it unto them.

20 For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his eternal power and Godhead; so that they are without excuse:

Acts 17:24–31

King James Version

24 God that made the world and all things therein, seeing that he is Lord of heaven and earth, dwelleth not in temples made with hands;

25 Neither is worshipped with men’s hands, as though he needed any thing, seeing he giveth to all life, and breath, and all things;

26 And hath made of one blood all nations of men for to dwell on all the face of the earth, and hath determined the times before appointed, and the bounds of their habitation;

27 That they should seek the Lord, if haply they might feel after him, and find him, though he be not far from every one of us:

28 For in him we live, and move, and have our being; as certain also of your own poets have said, For we are also his offspring.

29 Forasmuch then as we are the offspring of God, we ought not to think that the Godhead is like unto gold, or silver, or stone, graven by art and man’s device.

30 And the times of this ignorance God winked at; but now commandeth all men every where to repent:

31 Because he hath appointed a day, in the which he will judge the world in righteousness by that man whom he hath ordained; whereof he hath given assurance unto all men, in that he hath raised him from the dead.

What the Church teaches

The Church confesses that the God who made the world is the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, and that he has made himself known in the Son. In this view the philosophical arguments can lead a person to see that there is a Creator, and revelation tells who he is: the Holy Trinity, one God, whose Son became incarnate for our salvation. The relation between the two is one of preparation and fulfilment.

In the Coptic Orthodox tradition the knowledge of God comes first from the Church’s worship and the Scriptures, and the Fathers of Alexandria also reasoned about creation to explain the faith to outsiders. The one incarnate nature of God the Word is not a conclusion of any argument from the cosmos but the Church’s confession of what God has done in Christ. The cosmological arguments lead to the first of these confessions, that there is one Creator.

Objections answered

Even a first cause is only a first cause. Calling it “God” smuggles in the attributes of the religious tradition. The argument gives a bare explanatory ground, and we have no reason to think it is a mind.

The first step gives a ground of the universe, and the next steps give it content. A timeless, unchanging principle would produce its effect eternally or not at all; a universe that begins points to a cause that chose to create. Choice is the mark of a mind.

We already explain many things by an agent’s intention, and nothing else explains a beginning freely given. Calling this Creator God smuggles nothing in: it is what Scripture means when it says that God made the heavens and the earth.

[4]

If the arguments reach only a first cause, they are useless to the believer. Christians who use them are trying to prove their religion by a route that cannot arrive.

Christians use the arguments as a preparation, as St Paul did in Athens. They show that belief in a Creator is reasonable, and they open the question of who the Creator is, which God answers in the history of Jesus Christ.

That preparation is a real gift. Many people are kept from the Gospel by the idea that faith in God is irrational; removing that barrier opens the way for them to hear of Christ.

[3] [2]

The first cause might be many causes, or a cause that no longer exists, or a cause that is indifferent or even malevolent. The argument cannot rule these out, so it does not help the religions.

A necessary being cannot cease to exist, so the Creator has not passed away. One ground is enough to explain the universe, and nothing calls for many; the unity of the world points to one Creator.

Goodness is shown by the moral argument and by the order and beauty of creation, and above all by God’s self-giving in Christ. The problem of evil is answered in its own article.

Conclusion

The cosmological arguments show that the universe depends on a first cause, timeless, non-physical and immensely powerful, who freely chose to create. Reason can reach this Creator through the things He has made. Who He is, the Holy Trinity, and how He loved the world by the incarnation of His Son, the Church receives from God’s own revelation. The arguments prepare the way; Christ fulfils it.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close