Orthodoxia

Faith & Evidence / God’s existence and knowledge

Does the universe need an explanation beyond itself?

IntermediatePhilosophicalAnswer available

Revision 1, updated

The answer

Yes. Everything in the universe might not have existed, and the universe itself, with its particular laws and contents, could have been otherwise. Things that need not exist do not explain their own existence. Adding more of them, even an endless chain, does not explain why the chain exists at all. So the explanation must lie in something that exists in its own right and depends on nothing else. We rely on the principle that things have reasons in science, in law and in daily life, and there is no fair reason to abandon it at the very largest question. This argument leads to an independent ground of all that is. The Church knows that ground by name: God, who made all things through His Word and holds them in being at every moment.

  • A contingent thing is one that might not have existed. Such things call for an explanation, and the universe, with its particular laws and contents, is contingent.
  • The central premise is a principle of sufficient explanation, which we rely on everywhere in science and ordinary life.
  • Explaining each link of a chain by the one before does not explain why the whole chain exists; a collection of dependent things is itself dependent.
  • Scientific explanations work inside the universe; this question concerns the existence of the universe as a whole.
  • The argument leads to an independent, non-contingent ground of reality; further reasons and God’s revelation show who that ground is.
  • The Christian faith confesses that the universe depends moment by moment on God, who gives it existence.

Why this question matters

The claim that the universe needs an explanation is often stated as if it were obvious, and often dismissed as if it were absurd. It deserves better than either. The argument has a clear structure, and each step can be examined and seen to be reasonable.

It also helps to see what the argument is not. It does not say that science is incomplete, and it does not rely on a gap in our knowledge. It asks about the very existence of the universe, a question science, by its nature, does not answer.

The argument has a long history. Greek, Islamic, Jewish and Christian philosophers used forms of it, and Leibniz stated it in terms of a principle of sufficient reason. The contingency form runs: (1) whatever exists has an explanation, either in the necessity of its own nature or in something else. (2) The universe, with its laws and contents, does not exist by the necessity of its own nature, since it could have been otherwise. (3) So its explanation lies in something else. (4) That something cannot be a further member of the universe, so it lies outside it. Different versions word the steps differently.

The first premise is the contested one. Defenders argue that it is presupposed in science, in detective work and in ordinary life, and that to deny it for the universe as a whole is arbitrary. Critics distinguish between explaining events and explaining everything. Hume held that if each member of a collection has a cause, the collection as a whole does not need a further one, since we have explained each part. Later critics asked whether the principle might be false at the level of the whole, or true only as a working assumption. Kant argued that the concept of cause is for objects of experience and cannot be stretched to the universe as such.

Some philosophers object to the second premise, holding that the universe, or its basic laws, might exist necessarily, so nothing outside it would be required. But the physical universe has features, such as particular matter and particular laws, which are not necessary in the way a mathematical truth is; they could have been otherwise, and so they call for an explanation.

Scripture, read as an ancient text, presents the dependence of the world on God, not as a philosophical argument but as a claim: all things were made through the Word, and in him all things hold together (John 1:3; Colossians 1:16–17). Athanasius of Alexandria teaches that created things have being only through the Word and would fall back into nothing without him (S52). These texts state the Christian understanding and do not claim to settle the philosophical premises.

Richard Swinburne has defended a version of the argument within a cumulative case, holding that God is a simpler and more fruitful explanation of the universe than a brute fact (S39 for the full presentation, S38 for a general reader). They are cited here as whole works for their overall approach, because only the publisher pages have been consulted. His approach differs from the older argument from necessity and is itself disputed.

Terms used

  • Theism: The view that there is one personal God who made and sustains the world.
  • Cosmological argument: An argument from the existence or beginning of the universe to a cause or explanation beyond it.
  • Inspiration: The Christian belief that God worked through the human authors of Scripture. It is a theological claim, distinct from the preservation of manuscripts.

The evidence

The universe is contingent, and what is contingent needs an explanation; therefore the universe has an explanation beyond itself.

The reasoning is valid, and both premises are strong. The physical universe has particular matter, particular laws and a particular history, none of which has the necessity of a mathematical truth. And the principle that things have explanations is one we rely on everywhere; giving it up only for the universe as a whole would be arbitrary. [3] [4]

The Church teaches that the universe depends continually on God for its existence, as Scripture and St Athanasius proclaim.

St John the Evangelist says that all things came to be through the Word, and St Paul the Apostle says that in the Son all things hold together. St Athanasius of Alexandria teaches that created things were brought from nothing through the Word and are kept in being by Him. What the argument reaches by reason, the faith confesses as revealed truth. [1] [2]

This is a philosophical argument, not a historical one. Its long history, among Greek, Jewish, Muslim and Christian thinkers, shows how naturally the human mind rises from the world to its source.

In Scripture

Colossians 1:16–17

King James Version

16 For by him were all things created, that are in heaven, and that are in earth, visible and invisible, whether they be thrones, or dominions, or principalities, or powers: all things were created by him, and for him:

17 And he is before all things, and by him all things consist.

What the Church teaches

The Church confesses that the world is not self-sufficient but held in being by the Word of God. This does not rest on the premise of sufficient explanation, which is philosophical, but on revelation. For a believer the philosophical argument is a way of seeing that what faith teaches is not irrational, and not a foundation on which faith is built.

The Coptic Orthodox liturgy confesses the Son as the one through whom all things were made, and prays to God as the one who sustains all. The doctrine of continuing dependence is therefore familiar in worship, even though the Church does not require believers to hold any particular version of the philosophical argument.

Objections answered

The principle that everything has an explanation is a plausible rule of thumb, not a truth we know. Even if each thing within the universe has a cause, the universe as a whole need not, and to suppose so is to commit a fallacy of composition.

The argument does not reason from parts to whole in the way this objection supposes. It points out that a collection of dependent things, however large, is itself dependent, because nothing in it supplies what each member lacks. A thousand borrowed lamps do not make light without a source.

And the principle is not a mere rule of thumb. We rely on it in every field and never find a clear exception. Quantum events are no exception: they occur within physical laws and fields, which are themselves part of the contingent universe that needs explaining.

[3]

The universe might be a necessary being, or its laws might be. Then the universe is its own explanation and no further ground is needed.

What is necessary cannot fail to exist and cannot be otherwise. The physical universe shows every mark of being otherwise possible: its particular constants, its particular matter, its particular history. Things that change and are made of parts are exactly the kind of things that might not have been.

To call the universe necessary is to give it a property it does not show. A ground that is necessary, unchanging and the source of all else fits what we find far better than a universe declared necessary without reason.

Even if the argument shows a ground of the universe, it tells us nothing about it. To call it “God” is to put a familiar name on something unknown.

The argument does reach a limited conclusion, and the Church has never claimed to derive the Trinity or the Incarnation from it. But what it reaches is not nothing: a ground of all reality that exists in its own right, depends on nothing, and gives existence to everything else.

Other reasons say more: the order of the universe, the existence of minds and of moral truth. Above all, God has made Himself known in Jesus Christ. The argument opens the door; revelation shows who stands there.

Conclusion

The universe does not explain its own existence. It is contingent, and a chain of contingent things, however long, still needs a ground that exists in its own right. Reason points to that ground, and the Church confesses Him: God, the Maker of all things visible and invisible, who through His Word holds the world in being. Faith does not rest on this argument alone, but the argument shows that what faith teaches is deeply reasonable.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close