Orthodoxia

Faith & Evidence / Crucifixion and resurrection

What do martyrdom traditions establish, and what do they not establish?

AdvancedHistoricalAnswer available

Revision 1, updated

The answer

The martyrdom traditions show that the first witnesses of the risen Christ held to their testimony at the cost of their lives. The early sources are clear: St Stephen was stoned; St James the son of Zebedee was put to the sword by Herod Agrippa; Josephus records that St James the brother of the Lord was stoned in Jerusalem; and Tacitus tells of a great multitude of Christians put to death in Rome under Nero. St Paul the Apostle describes his own beatings and dangers, the Gospel of John foretells the death by which St Peter would glorify God, and St Clement of Rome speaks of the sufferings of St Peter and St Paul. The Church’s tradition remembers the martyrdom of the other apostles too, with St John alone dying in old age. People who know a story is false do not suffer and die for it. And the apostles did not die for a belief received from others, but for what they themselves had seen: the risen Lord.

  • Early and clear: St Stephen’s stoning and the execution of St James the son of Zebedee (Acts 7; 12:1–2); the stoning of St James the brother of the Lord (Josephus, Antiquities 20.200); Nero’s persecution in Rome (Tacitus, Annals 15.44).
  • Early witness to St Peter and St Paul: St Paul’s own lists of his sufferings, the Lord’s word that Peter would die stretching out his hands (John 21:18–19), and St Clement’s letter on their sufferings.
  • The Church’s tradition preserves the memory of the martyrdom of the other apostles, written down in later accounts.
  • The Coptic Church honours St Mark the Evangelist as founder of the Church of Alexandria and as her first martyr bishop.
  • Martyrdom shows sincerity, and it rules out deliberate fraud. The apostles died for what they had seen, not for what they had been told.

Why this question matters

Christians often say that the apostles died for their testimony to the resurrection. A believer should know exactly what the early sources record, so that this witness is spoken of with accuracy and strength.

The subject is close to the heart of the Coptic Church, the Church of the Martyrs. Knowing the martyrs’ story well serves both the truth and the honour the Church gives them.

Christians suffered intermittently in the first century: from Jewish authorities in Jerusalem, from local rulers such as Herod Agrippa I, and under Nero at Rome. A general, empire-wide persecution came only in the third century, and the most severe was under Diocletian, whose accession in AD 284 the Coptic Church takes as the start of the Era of the Martyrs.

In the New Testament the death of only a few leaders is narrated. Acts tells of Stephen and James the son of Zebedee, and not of the deaths of Peter or St Paul. Other early documents hint at them. The letter of the Roman church to Corinth, usually called First Clement and dated around AD 96, speaks of the sufferings of Peter and St Paul and of St Paul's testimony before the rulers. The writers who give details, such as that Peter was crucified and St Paul beheaded at Rome, are from the late second century onward.

The Acts of individual apostles (of Peter, St Paul, Andrew, Thomas, John and others) are literary works of the second and third centuries. They contain some traditions that may be old, and a great deal of legend. They were not accepted into the canon, and historians generally treat them with caution.

Terms used

  • Primary source: A text or object from the period being studied, such as an ancient letter, a manuscript or an inscription.
  • Independent attestation: Two sources report the same thing without one copying the other. Two copies of one source are one witness, not two.
  • Eyewitness: A person who saw an event first-hand. A writer who reports what others said is not an eyewitness.
  • Canon: The list of books a community receives as Scripture.
  • Resurrection: In Christian teaching, Jesus’ bodily rising from the dead to a transformed life. It is a different claim from the claim that his followers came to believe it.
  • Tradition: In the Orthodox understanding, the Church’s lived and handed-on faith, within which Scripture is read.

The evidence

Early Christians, including their leaders, were persecuted, and some were put to death because of their faith.

Christian sources (Acts and St Paul), a Jewish historian (Josephus on St James) and a hostile Roman historian (Tacitus on Nero’s persecution) all report it, and by about AD 110 a Roman governor’s letter treats the punishment of Christians as established practice. Witnesses from every side agree. [1] [2] [3] [4]

Among the leaders, St James the son of Zebedee and St James the brother of the Lord are recorded as executed in early sources, and St Peter and St Paul gave their lives in Rome.

The deaths of the two Jameses are in Acts and Josephus. For St Peter, the Gospel of John records the Lord’s word about the death by which he would glorify God; St Clement of Rome, writing at the end of the first century, speaks of the sufferings of both St Peter and St Paul; and the Church’s tradition remembers their martyrdom in Rome under Nero. [1] [2] [5] [6]

The Church’s tradition preserves the memory of the deaths of the other apostles; these accounts were written down later, and the Church honours them as her tradition.

For St Andrew, St Thomas, St Bartholomew, St Matthias, St Philip and others, the written narratives come from the third century and later, and they differ in places and details. The Church keeps their memory day by day in her Synaxarium. The tradition about St John, by contrast, is that he lived to old age at Ephesus. [5] [6]

Willingness to suffer for a testimony shows that the witness was sincere, and the apostles’ testimony was to something they had seen.

Many people have died for convictions they received from others. The apostles were in a different position: they claimed to have seen the risen Lord with their own eyes. They could not have been simply mistaken about a teaching passed down to them; they knew whether they had seen Him. Their readiness to suffer rules out a lie, and points to the reality of what they saw. [4] [7] [8]

The early sources show that Christian leaders were persecuted, that some were killed, and that St Paul lived a life of suffering for his message. This rules out deliberate fraud and gives strong reason to trust the sincerity of the first witnesses.

Their witness was to what they had seen. Together with the empty tomb and the appearances of the risen Lord, examined in other articles, the faithfulness of the martyrs is part of the evidence for the resurrection.

In Scripture

Acts 12:1–2

King James Version

1 Now about that time Herod the king stretched forth his hands to vex certain of the church.

2 And he killed James the brother of John with the sword.

2 Corinthians 11:23–27

King James Version

23 Are they ministers of Christ? (I speak as a fool) I am more; in labours more abundant, in stripes above measure, in prisons more frequent, in deaths oft.

24 Of the Jews five times received I forty stripes save one.

25 Thrice was I beaten with rods, once was I stoned, thrice I suffered shipwreck, a night and a day I have been in the deep;

26 In journeyings often, in perils of waters, in perils of robbers, in perils by mine own countrymen, in perils by the heathen, in perils in the city, in perils in the wilderness, in perils in the sea, in perils among false brethren;

27 In weariness and painfulness, in watchings often, in hunger and thirst, in fastings often, in cold and nakedness.

What the Church teaches

The Church honours the martyrs not as a proof but as the fruit of the resurrection: those who have seen the victory of Christ over death do not fear it. The word martyr means witness, and the Church holds that the blood of the martyrs is the seed of the Church. This faith in the witness of the martyrs is in the Church's life and does not depend on the quality of every narrative of their deaths.

The Coptic Church is called the Church of the Martyrs. Its calendar counts years from the accession of Diocletian in AD 284, the Era of the Martyrs, and its Synaxarium commemorates martyrs day by day. St Mark the Evangelist is held by the Church to be the founder of the see of Alexandria and to have been martyred there. The Church receives this as its own tradition. Early writers credit him with founding the church of Alexandria, and the Church keeps the account of his martyrdom, written down in later narratives, as a treasured part of her tradition.

The Church also keeps the memory of the apostles and prays for their intercession, and it does so without making the faith depend on the details of how each of them died.

Objections answered

We do not know that the apostles died as martyrs. The claim that all of them did is a pious legend that has been repeated until it seems to be fact.

The early sources themselves record the executions of St James the son of Zebedee and St James the brother of the Lord, and give early witness to the sufferings of St Peter and St Paul. That is not legend. For the other apostles, the Church’s memory was written down later, and it is honoured as tradition.

What the sources make certain is enough: the first leaders of the Church were persecuted, some were killed, and none is known to have denied what he had seen. Their testimony held under threat of death.

[1] [2] [5] [6]

People die for false beliefs all the time. Martyrdom proves nothing about whether the resurrection happened.

Martyrdom shows sincerity, and that matters greatly: people who know a story is a lie do not accept suffering and death for it. So the apostles’ suffering rules out the idea that they invented the resurrection.

And the apostles were not like believers who die for a doctrine received from others. They claimed to know a fact by sight, that they had seen, heard and touched the risen Lord, not once but many times and together. Their witness, sealed with their blood, is why the Church gives it such weight.

[7] [8] [4]

The apostles could have saved themselves by recanting, but we have no record that anyone was ever offered that choice. The martyrdom stories are written to inspire later Christians.

Many later martyr stories were written to edify, and they are read for that purpose. The early reports used here, Acts, Josephus, Tacitus and Pliny, are of a different kind: the first three describe particular deaths, and the last records the choice put to the accused.

Pliny’s letter, written about AD 110, shows that Christians were indeed offered the choice to deny Christ and go free, and that those who refused were put to death. That was the setting in which the apostles and their generation bore witness.

[1] [2] [3] [4]

Conclusion

The early sources record the persecution of the first Christians and the deaths of several of their leaders, and the Church’s tradition remembers the martyrdom of the other apostles. Those who had seen the risen Lord did not deny Him under threat of death. Their faithfulness shows that they were not deceivers, and the Church honours them as true witnesses, the fruit of the resurrection: those who have seen Christ’s victory over death do not fear it.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close