Faith & Evidence / Early Christianity and Coptic Orthodox doctrine
What does Coptic Orthodox Miaphysite Christology mean?
The answer
The Coptic Orthodox Church confesses that Christ is one: God the Word incarnate, in one nature formed of divinity and humanity, united without mingling, confusion or alteration. This is the formula of St Cyril of Alexandria: the one incarnate nature of God the Word. Christ is perfect God and perfect man, with a real body, a rational soul and a human mind. The Church therefore rejects both the division of Christ taught by Nestorius and the dissolving of His humanity taught by Eutyches. It holds the first three ecumenical councils and did not accept Chalcedon, because its language of two natures after the union can be read as dividing the one Christ. In the modern dialogues the churches that accept Chalcedon have recognised that the Coptic Church confesses the true faith in Christ, and that it was never “monophysite” in the sense long charged against it.
- Miaphysite (from mia, one, and physis, nature) names the Church’s own teaching: one nature of the incarnate Word, composed of divinity and humanity. The Church rejects the word “monophysite”, which suggests a single, divine-only nature.
- The union is without mingling, confusion or alteration, and the humanity is complete, with body, soul and mind.
- The formula comes from St Cyril of Alexandria, who also accepted, in the Formula of Union of 433, that the difference of the natures remains in thought.
- The Church holds Nicaea (325), Constantinople (381) and Ephesus (431); it did not accept Chalcedon (451), at which Pope Dioscorus of Alexandria was deposed.
- Just as a human being is one, of body and soul, without either being lost, so Christ is one, of divinity and humanity, without either being lost.
- The joint declaration of 1973 (Pope Shenouda III and Pope Paul VI) and the agreed statements of 1989 and 1990 with the Eastern Orthodox affirm that the Coptic Church confesses the same Christ, perfect God and perfect man.
Why this question matters
For fifteen centuries others have called the Coptic Church “monophysite”, a label it rejects, and its separation from the churches of Chalcedon has shaped its history. Many Copts have not been taught the reasons, and many outside the Church know only the label.
Knowing the Church’s faith clearly lets a Copt confess Christ with confidence and answer the old charge calmly. It also shows why, in the modern dialogues, theologians of both families have said that their predecessors often spoke past each other while meaning the same Christ.
In the fifth century the question was how to speak of the one Christ who is God and man. Nestorius, patriarch of Constantinople, was understood by Cyril of Alexandria to divide Christ into two subjects, and the Council of Ephesus in 431 condemned his teaching and confessed Mary as Theotokos. Cyril wrote that the Word united humanity to himself in a union of hypostasis, and used the phrase “one incarnate nature of God the Word”. He received it in the belief that it came from Athanasius; modern scholars trace the text to Apollinarian circles, but Cyril gave it his own meaning, and the Church holds it in his sense.
In 433 Cyril accepted the Formula of Union with John of Antioch, which spoke of a union of two natures and of a distinction between the natures preserved. Cyril explained that the distinction is made in thought and not as a division between two things. Later, Severus of Antioch, in the early sixth century, spoke of the one composite nature of Christ as a human being is one composite nature of body and soul, in which neither is lost.
In 448 the Synod of Constantinople condemned the archimandrite Eutyches, and at Ephesus in 449 Pope Dioscorus of Alexandria presided over a council that restored him. The Council of Chalcedon in 451 reversed that, deposed Dioscorus, and issued a definition that confessed Christ in two natures, without confusion, change, division or separation, in one person and one hypostasis. It was shaped by the Tome of Pope Leo of Rome. Dioscorus died in exile in 454.
The Coptic Orthodox Church did not accept the definition, and so remained separate from the churches that did. The Church of Alexandria was followed by the Syrian, Armenian, Ethiopian and Indian churches, which together are called the Oriental Orthodox. In the language of the time the word nature (physis) was used by Cyril and Severus for a concrete individual existing being, close to what Chalcedon called hypostasis; Chalcedon distinguished the two and used nature for the kind of being. Much of the modern discussion is about whether this difference of terms accounts for the disagreement.
Terms used
- Christology: Teaching about who Christ is, especially how divinity and humanity are united in him.
- Miaphysitism: The Coptic Orthodox teaching, from Cyril of Alexandria, that Christ is one incarnate nature of the Word, from two natures united without mixture, confusion or alteration. It rejects the idea of a single blended nature.
- Theotokos: A Greek title for Mary, “God-bearer”, affirming that the child she bore is God the Word incarnate.
- Trinity: The Christian teaching that God is one in essence and three in persons: Father, Son and Holy Spirit.
- Tradition: In the Orthodox understanding, the Church’s lived and handed-on faith, within which Scripture is read.
The evidence
The Coptic Orthodox Church teaches that Christ is one incarnate nature of God the Word, perfect in divinity and perfect in humanity, united without mingling, confusion or alteration.
This is the Church’s own teaching, prayed in its liturgy, taught by its Fathers and expounded by its modern teachers such as Pope Shenouda III. [1] [2] [3]
The formula is rooted in Scripture’s witness to the Word who became flesh, and in the Alexandrian Fathers.
Scripture speaks of one subject, the Word, who became flesh: the same Son of Man is in heaven while on earth, and the fullness of deity dwells in Him bodily. St Athanasius and St Cyril read these texts as confessing one incarnate Word, and the formula of the one nature says exactly this. [4] [5]
The Coptic Orthodox Church did not accept the Council of Chalcedon, while holding the same faith in the one Christ, perfect God and perfect man.
The Church rejects Chalcedon because its definition can be read as dividing Christ, because it deposed Pope Dioscorus, and because it was shaped by the Tome of Leo. Yet the modern dialogues have confirmed that the Church’s faith in Christ is the orthodox faith, so the separation never meant that the Copts denied His full humanity. [1] [2]
The historical record supports the Church. St Cyril’s writings and the Formula of Union show that he affirmed the full humanity of Christ and the distinction of the natures in thought; the Church of Alexandria repeatedly condemned the teaching of Eutyches; and in the fifth century the word nature had more than one meaning. These facts show that “monophysite”, in the sense of denying Christ’s humanity, was never a fair name for the Coptic faith.
The Church’s continuity also speaks: from St Cyril through St Dioscorus and St Severus to Pope Shenouda III, the same confession of one incarnate Word has been taught and prayed faithfully.
In Scripture
John 3:13
King James Version
13 And no man hath ascended up to heaven, but he that came down from heaven, even the Son of man which is in heaven.
Hebrews 2:14–17
King James Version
14 Forasmuch then as the children are partakers of flesh and blood, he also himself likewise took part of the same; that through death he might destroy him that had the power of death, that is, the devil;
15 And deliver them who through fear of death were all their lifetime subject to bondage.
16 For verily he took not on him the nature of angels; but he took on him the seed of Abraham.
17 Wherefore in all things it behoved him to be made like unto his brethren, that he might be a merciful and faithful high priest in things pertaining to God, to make reconciliation for the sins of the people.
What the Church teaches
The Church confesses that Christ is perfect God and perfect man, and that the Word, in becoming flesh, made the humanity his own, without division. It confesses the one incarnate nature of God the Word, as did Cyril, and holds that this says what the Gospels say: the Son of God who became man is one.
It also holds that to confess two natures after the union without careful words risks speaking of two. It therefore remains with the formula of Cyril, which it understands as the most faithful expression of the one Christ.
The Coptic Orthodox Church counts Dioscorus as its twenty-fifth pope and the defender of the faith of Alexandria at Chalcedon. It does not call itself “monophysite”, and it does not call the Chalcedonian churches “Nestorian”. It honours Athanasius and Cyril, and in the later centuries Severus of Antioch, as its Fathers in this teaching.
In 1973 Pope Shenouda III and Pope Paul VI signed a common declaration of faith in Christ, perfect in his divinity and perfect in his humanity, united in a real and perfect union without mingling, confusion or change. In the dialogue of the Eastern and Oriental Orthodox churches, agreed statements in 1989 and 1990 said that the two families confess the same Christ and had used different terms. The Church welcomes these declarations as expressions of its own faith, and has not thereby accepted the council.
Objections answered
One nature after the union means that the humanity was absorbed into the divinity, so that Christ was not truly man. The Church is monophysite whatever it says.
The Church condemns exactly that teaching. One nature, as St Cyril and the Coptic Church mean it, is not a single divine nature: it is the one nature of the Word incarnate, formed from the divinity and the humanity united, as a human being is one nature formed from body and soul that stay what they are. Christ is perfect man, with body, soul and mind, and His humanity was neither absorbed nor changed.
The Church’s liturgy confesses that the divinity never parted from the humanity, not even for an instant, and that the union was without mingling, confusion or alteration. The modern dialogues, after studying these statements, have recognised that the Coptic Church does not hold the error that the word “monophysite” was used to charge against it.
The Coptic Church separated from the Church of the empire for political and national reasons, and its Christology is a cover for resistance to Byzantium.
Politics was present in this history: emperors at times used force, and the churches of Egypt, Syria and Armenia had their own relations with the empire.
But the sources show that St Dioscorus, St Severus and others argued the question in theological terms, about who Christ is. And the Church kept its confession under rulers of every kind, long after Byzantium ceased to rule Egypt. A political cover would have been dropped when the politics changed; a faith is kept because it is believed.
If the dialogues say that the faith is the same, then the Coptic Church should now accept Chalcedon; to refuse is to keep a division that no longer has a cause.
Agreement on faith in Christ is not the same as accepting a council and its Tome. Chalcedon deposed Pope Dioscorus, the defender of St Cyril’s faith, and put into its definition a formula the Church judges to be open to a Nestorian reading. The Church cannot receive as ecumenical a council it holds to have done these things.
Meanwhile the Church gladly recognises that the Chalcedonian churches confess the same Christ, and it continues in dialogue and love towards full communion. Holding fast to St Cyril’s formula is not a refusal of unity; it is faithfulness to the confession through which the Church has known Christ.
Conclusion
The Coptic Orthodox Church confesses one Christ, perfect in divinity and perfect in humanity, in the one incarnate nature of God the Word, as St Cyril taught, and condemns the errors of both Nestorius and Eutyches. It did not accept Chalcedon, for reasons of faith and of justice to St Dioscorus. Its confession is the ancient faith of Alexandria, and the modern dialogues have recognised it as a true confession of the one Lord Jesus Christ.
Sources
- The Creed (Pope Shenouda III books online) · Pope Shenouda III
- On the Unity of Christ · Cyril of Alexandria
- On the Incarnation · Athanasius of Alexandria
- John 3:13
- Hebrews 2:14–17
No inbox has been set up yet, so nothing is sent. This copies a short report with the page address and revision for you to pass on.