Faith & Evidence / The Bible: transmission, authorship, canon and interpretation
Did Nicaea choose the Bible?
The answer
No. The Council of Nicaea was called to answer Arius, who denied that the Son is truly God, and to settle the date of Easter and some questions of church order. Its creed and its surviving canons contain no list of Scripture, and no ancient account of the council reports a vote on books. Both sides at Nicaea argued from the same Scriptures, which the churches had been reading in worship long before. The first well-known list of exactly the twenty-seven New Testament books comes from St Athanasius, pope of Alexandria, more than forty years later. Nicaea did not make the Bible; it stood on it to confess that the Son is of one essence with the Father.
- Nicaea (AD 325) dealt with Arius’s teaching, the date of Easter and church order; the surviving creed and canons say nothing about a list of Scripture.
- The Arian dispute was an argument over how to read texts that both sides accepted, which shows that Scripture was in use before the council.
- The report that Constantine ordered copies of the Scriptures for Constantinople is about copying, not about choosing the contents.
- Athanasius, who was at Nicaea as a young deacon, gave his list of the New Testament books in AD 367.
- The claim that Nicaea chose the Bible is a modern popular story; it is not found in any ancient account.
Why this question matters
The idea that a council of bishops under an emperor voted on the Bible is widely repeated in popular books, films and online. It carries a serious accusation, that the Scriptures are a political creation, and the history answers it plainly.
The answer also shows what Nicaea was truly about. The council confessed who Christ is in the face of Arius, and that is why the Coptic Church honours it so deeply.
Constantine, the emperor, called the bishops to Nicaea in 325. The tradition of the Church speaks of 318 bishops, and the number is repeated by Athanasius. The controversy was the teaching of Arius, a presbyter of Alexandria, who held that the Son is a creature who came to be, though the first of creatures. Alexander, bishop of Alexandria, opposed him, and his deacon Athanasius, then young, was with him.
The council produced a creed that says the Son is of the same essence (homoousios) as the Father. It also dealt with the date of Easter and issued a set of disciplinary canons, traditionally counted as twenty, on matters such as the ordination of clergy and the reconciliation of those who had lapsed. It also addressed a schism in Egypt associated with Meletius. None of this concerns a list of books.
The Arian crisis did not end at Nicaea. It continued for decades, and the historian Lewis Ayres has written about how the Nicene faith came to be accepted in the later fourth century. In that long conflict, Athanasius defended Nicaea across several exiles, and it was in this setting that he wrote his Festal Letter for AD 367.
The popular claim has a modern history. It spread widely in recent popular fiction and online writing, and is not found in the ancient accounts of the council. A report from Eusebius, who knew Constantine, says that the emperor asked for fifty copies of the Scriptures to be prepared for the churches of his new city. This is a commission for copies, and it does not say that the contents were chosen by him.
Terms used
- Manuscript: A handwritten copy of a text on papyrus, parchment or paper.
- Codex: An early book made of folded pages bound together, replacing the scroll.
- Canon: The list of books a community receives as Scripture.
- Christology: Teaching about who Christ is, especially how divinity and humanity are united in him.
- Trinity: The Christian teaching that God is one in essence and three in persons: Father, Son and Holy Spirit.
- Tradition: In the Orthodox understanding, the Church’s lived and handed-on faith, within which Scripture is read.
The evidence
The Council of Nicaea did not decide the biblical canon.
The business of the council was the Arian dispute, the date of Easter and church order. Its creed and canons contain no list of Scripture, no ancient account mentions one, and the first well-known list of the whole New Testament appears more than forty years later in a letter of St Athanasius. [1] [2]
Nicaea dealt with the divinity of the Son, the date of Easter and church order. The Gospels and the apostolic letters had been read in worship long before. The lists of the fourth century were set out by individual bishops and regional councils in the decades that followed.
St Athanasius’ Festal Letter of 367 gave the New Testament as the Church still receives it, and it did so not by inventing a list but by naming the books the churches had received from the apostles.
What the Church teaches
The Church confesses that the faith defined at Nicaea is the faith of the apostles, held from the beginning and defended against Arius. The Scriptures were not the product of the council; they were the standard by which the council judged the question put to it.
The council and the canon are two moments of one life in which the Church holds the faith she received, guided in each by the Holy Spirit.
The Coptic Church honours the Council of Nicaea as the first of the three ecumenical councils she receives, and she remembers it with the name of the 318. Alexander, the nineteenth pope of Alexandria, took a leading part, and his deacon Athanasius, later the twentieth pope, became the great defender of its faith. The Nicene Creed is prayed in every Coptic liturgy.
The Coptic Church also remembers Athanasius for his Festal Letter of AD 367. In it a pope of Alexandria, writing to his own flock, gave the list of the New Testament books and warned against invented writings. That letter, and not the council, is where the Coptic tradition looks for the early list, and it was a pastoral act of a bishop rather than the decree of an assembly.
Objections answered
Constantine ordered fifty Bibles, and the Bible he had made is the one we have. The emperor therefore decided what went into it.
The report, from Eusebius, is that the emperor asked for copies of the Scriptures to be made for the churches of Constantinople, with care for their quality. It says nothing about choosing books. The books to be copied were those the churches were already reading.
Constantine played a large part in calling and supporting the council, and the Church honours his protection of Christians. But what is Scripture was decided by the Church’s long use, not by an emperor’s order.
Nicaea decided that Jesus is God, and the canon was then shaped to support that decision. The Gospels that did not fit were dropped.
Faith in the divinity of Christ is expressed in texts written long before the council, among them the prologue of St John’s Gospel and the letters of St Paul the Apostle, and the Arian party appealed to the very same books. A canon shaped to remove the opponents’ texts would not have kept John 14:28, one of their favourite verses.
The writings left outside the canon, such as the Gospel of Thomas, are not Arian documents. They belong to other currents, and why the Church did not receive them is treated in the article on noncanonical gospels.
The records of Nicaea are incomplete, so you cannot say what the bishops did or did not discuss.
We have no full minutes, but we have many accounts from participants and later writers, St Athanasius among them. None of them mentions a decision on the canon. And the later history makes the point clear: through the fourth century bishops and regional councils were still setting out their own lists, which would make no sense if Nicaea had already fixed one.
The claim rests on no ancient source at all. The evidence we do have tells one consistent story.
Conclusion
The Council of Nicaea did not choose the books of the Bible. It confessed, against Arius, that the Son is true God of one essence with the Father, and it did so from the Scriptures the Church already read. The New Testament list was later set out by St Athanasius of Alexandria, naming the books received from the apostles. The Coptic Church prays the Nicene Creed in every liturgy and reads the same Scriptures that the Fathers of Nicaea held in their hands.
Sources
- Nicaea and Its Legacy · Lewis Ayres
- The Canon of Scripture · F. F. Bruce
No inbox has been set up yet, so nothing is sent. This copies a short report with the page address and revision for you to pass on.