Faith & Evidence / Early Christianity and Coptic Orthodox doctrine
How can Christ suffer or die?
The answer
God the Word, in His divine nature, does not suffer or die. Yet He truly suffered and died in the flesh that He made His own. Because that humanity belongs to the Word, what happens to it happens to Him, the one Lord. So St Paul the Apostle can say that the Lord of glory was crucified, and the Coptic Church prays to the Holy God, the Holy Mighty, the Holy Immortal, who was crucified for us. His divinity did not die, and it was not separated from His body in the tomb or from His soul in Hades. This is the great mystery of the Incarnation: the Immortal One tasted death for us, without His divine nature changing.
- The Gospels show Jesus truly suffering: agony in Gethsemane, scourging, crucifixion and a real death.
- The divine nature is impassible, that is, not subject to change or pain; the Word suffered in the flesh.
- The New Testament itself says that the Lord of glory was crucified and that God purchased the Church with His own blood.
- The Coptic Trisagion confesses that the Holy Immortal was crucified for us.
- His divinity never left His body or soul at death; the humanity died, and the Word was not changed.
- When Muslim and Jewish readers say that God cannot die, the Church agrees about the divine nature, and confesses that the Word died in His flesh.
Why this question matters
The words “God was crucified” shock many hearers. To Jews and Muslims they can sound like a denial of what it means to be God; to philosophers they raise the old question of an unchanging God in a changing world. A clear statement of what the Church confesses removes much of the misunderstanding.
The question matters inside the Church too. It decides whether the death of Christ is only the death of a good man or the saving act of God Himself. The Coptic Church places the cross at the centre of her worship because the answer is the second.
The Gospels record Jesus’ suffering in detail: sorrow and prayer in Gethsemane, arrest, trial, scourging, crucifixion and a death that Roman and Jewish sources also mention. Historians treat the crucifixion as one of the best attested events of his life, and the article on his execution under Pilate sets out that evidence.
The Church’s teaching has a long background. God is said to be impassible, that is, not changed or harmed by creatures. At the same time, the apostles speak of Christ’s suffering as the suffering of the Lord. The Fathers resolved this by saying that the Word, who is God, took a real body and soul and that suffering belongs to that humanity, but is his, since he is the one person.
Cyril of Alexandria made this a rule of speech in his controversy with Nestorius: the Word suffered in the flesh, and the flesh is his own. He rejected the picture in which a man suffers and God merely stands near. The Coptic Church shares that rule and speaks of the God who is crucified, while holding that the divine nature does not change.
Terms used
- Crucifixion: A Roman method of execution by fixing a person to a cross or stake.
- Theodicy: An attempt to explain why a good God permits evil and suffering.
- Christology: Teaching about who Christ is, especially how divinity and humanity are united in him.
- Miaphysitism: The Coptic Orthodox teaching, from Cyril of Alexandria, that Christ is one incarnate nature of the Word, from two natures united without mixture, confusion or alteration. It rejects the idea of a single blended nature.
- Theotokos: A Greek title for Mary, “God-bearer”, affirming that the child she bore is God the Word incarnate.
- Tradition: In the Orthodox understanding, the Church’s lived and handed-on faith, within which Scripture is read.
The evidence
The New Testament presents Jesus as truly suffering and dying, and speaks of the one who suffered in divine terms.
St Paul writes that the rulers of this age crucified the Lord of glory (1 Corinthians 2:8), and in Acts 20:28 the Church is said to be purchased by God with His own blood. The apostles did not hesitate to name the crucified one as Lord and God. [1] [2]
The Word suffered and died in the flesh, and His divine nature did not change or die.
This is the teaching of the Fathers, St Athanasius and St Cyril of Alexandria above all, and the prayer of the Coptic liturgy. It keeps the one person of Christ undivided and the divinity and humanity without confusion. [3] [4] [5]
This language is not a contradiction: suffering is said of the one person according to His humanity, and changelessness according to His divinity.
A contradiction would assert and deny the same thing in the same respect. Here the respects differ. Even a human being is one subject who both feels bodily pain and thinks; in the same way the one Lord suffers in His flesh while remaining unchanged as God. [5]
The sufferings and death of Jesus are among the best attested facts about Him, and in the earliest letters of St Paul the first Christians already speak of the crucified one as Lord. They and their opponents felt the scandal of a crucified Lord, so this confession is no later invention.
The Church’s language of the natures, in which suffering belongs to the flesh and impassibility to the divinity, sets out with care what the apostles proclaimed from the beginning.
In Scripture
Mark 15:33–39
King James Version
33 And when the sixth hour was come, there was darkness over the whole land until the ninth hour.
34 And at the ninth hour Jesus cried with a loud voice, saying, Eloi, Eloi, lama sabachthani? which is, being interpreted, My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?
35 And some of them that stood by, when they heard it, said, Behold, he calleth Elias.
36 And one ran and filled a spunge full of vinegar, and put it on a reed, and gave him to drink, saying, Let alone; let us see whether Elias will come to take him down.
37 And Jesus cried with a loud voice, and gave up the ghost.
38 And the veil of the temple was rent in twain from the top to the bottom.
39 ¶ And when the centurion, which stood over against him, saw that he so cried out, and gave up the ghost, he said, Truly this man was the Son of God.
1 Corinthians 2:8
King James Version
8 Which none of the princes of this world knew: for had they known it, they would not have crucified the Lord of glory.
What the Church teaches
The Church confesses that God did not remain at a distance from suffering but entered it in the flesh, without ceasing to be God. In the Lord’s death she sees the freely given act of God the Word, and not a defeat suffered against his will.
The Church further holds that the divinity was united to the body in the tomb and to the soul in Hades, and that death could not hold the one who is the life. The resurrection is the sign that the one who died is God.
The Coptic liturgy gives the doctrine its words. In the Trisagion the Church prays to the Holy God, the Holy Mighty, the Holy Immortal, who was born of the Virgin, who was crucified for us, who rose from the dead and ascended into heaven, have mercy on us. The same Holy Immortal is said to be crucified, without adding a division.
In the Confession said before communion, the Church declares that the divinity did not part from the humanity for a moment or the twinkling of an eye. The Church also keeps Holy Week with readings and hymns that stress that the one who suffered is the Lord himself.
Objections answered
God is by definition immortal and cannot suffer. A God who dies is a contradiction in terms, and the Church has to choose between divinity and suffering.
The Church agrees that the divine nature does not suffer or die. It confesses something else: that the Word, who is God, took a human nature that can suffer and die, and that the suffering and death happened in that nature, while the one who suffered is the Word Himself. The Church never says that the divine nature died.
One person can act and be acted upon according to different natures. A human being is the subject of both bodily pain and of thought. In the same way, the Word suffers in His flesh and remains, as God, beyond suffering. There is no need to choose between His divinity and His passion.
In Islamic teaching, as in the Qur’an, God does not die and Jesus was not crucified; the Christian doctrine of a crucified God is therefore false.
Muslims hold that God is living and does not die, and so does the Church about the divine nature. On the crucifixion itself, the article on Qur’an 4:157 discusses the verse. Here it is enough to say that the crucifixion of Jesus is reported by Roman and Jewish sources as well as Christian ones.
What the Church asks is that its faith be stated correctly: not that the Eternal ceased to be, but that the eternal Word suffered in the flesh He took for our salvation.
If the divinity did not suffer, then only a man suffered, and his death has no more worth than the death of any martyr.
The humanity of Christ never existed apart from the Word. The one who suffered is the Word in His own flesh, so the act belongs to God and not merely to a man. This is why St Cyril of Alexandria insisted, against Nestorius, that God the Word suffered in the flesh.
That is what gives the cross its saving power: the death of Christ is the death of the Lord of life, freely offered. The article on the incarnation, cross and salvation explains how this death saves.
Conclusion
The Word of God suffered and died in the flesh that He made His own, while His divine nature did not change. That is why the Church prays to the Holy Immortal who was crucified for us. The one who hung on the cross is the Lord of glory, and His death, freely accepted, is the death that destroyed death.
Sources
- Mark 15:33–39
- 1 Corinthians 2:8
- On the Unity of Christ · Cyril of Alexandria
- On the Incarnation · Athanasius of Alexandria
- The Creed (Pope Shenouda III books online) · Pope Shenouda III
No inbox has been set up yet, so nothing is sent. This copies a short report with the page address and revision for you to pass on.