Faith & Evidence / Early Christianity and Coptic Orthodox doctrine
What are the differences between Miaphysitism and Eutychianism?
The answer
They are not the same, and the Coptic Orthodox Church condemns Eutychianism. The Church teaches that Christ is perfect in divinity and perfect in humanity, of one essence with the Father in His divinity and of one essence with us in His humanity. His humanity keeps its own reality: it is not absorbed, mingled or changed. Eutyches was condemned for teaching that after the union the humanity was swallowed up in the divinity, and that Christ’s body is not of the same kind as ours. The Church’s confession of the one incarnate nature of God the Word is the teaching of St Cyril of Alexandria, who affirmed the full humanity, and St Severus of Antioch wrote expressly against Eutyches. The modern dialogues with the Chalcedonian churches have recorded that the Coptic faith is not the faith of Eutyches.
- Eutyches, an archimandrite in Constantinople, was condemned at a local synod in 448, and the Council of Chalcedon in 451 also rejected his teaching.
- The charge against him was that Christ’s humanity was absorbed into the divinity and was not of one essence with ours.
- The Coptic Church teaches that Christ is of one essence with us in His humanity, with a real body, a rational soul and a human mind.
- The Church’s formula is St Cyril’s, who died before Eutyches was condemned, and St Severus of Antioch, one of its great teachers, expressly condemned Eutyches.
- The same word “one nature” carries a different meaning: for the Church it is the one incarnate Word, in whom the humanity remains complete.
- The Church does not accept the label “monophysite”; it calls its own teaching miaphysite.
Why this question matters
For centuries the Coptic Church has been called “monophysite” and linked to Eutyches. The link has shaped how other Christians regard it and how Copts explain their faith. A clear answer, drawn from what the Church actually confesses, removes the confusion.
There is also a wider lesson: a label one side gives another does not show what the other believes. The fair test is to ask what the Church itself confesses and what it condemns, and the Coptic Church condemns Eutyches by name.
Eutyches was the head of a monastery in Constantinople. In 448 he was summoned before a synod under Flavian, patriarch of Constantinople, and was condemned. The reports record that he affirmed Christ as from two natures before the union but denied two natures after it, and that he declined to say that Christ’s body is of the same substance as ours. These reports come from his accusers, and historians do not all agree on what exactly he taught.
Pope Dioscorus of Alexandria presided over a council at Ephesus in 449 that restored Eutyches. The Council of Chalcedon in 451 deposed Dioscorus and condemned Eutyches. The Coptic Church holds that Dioscorus did not teach the error of Eutyches, and that his judgement was about the procedure and the faith of Cyril, not a defence of the denial of Christ’s humanity.
Cyril of Alexandria, who died in 444, before Eutyches was condemned, taught that the Word took a complete humanity, with a rational soul, from the Virgin. Severus of Antioch, an early sixth century patriarch whom the Oriental Orthodox honour, wrote explicitly against Eutyches and against those who deny the full human nature of Christ.
The terms are these. Miaphysite, from mia (one) and physis (nature), names the teaching that Christ is one incarnate nature of the Word. Monophysite, from monos (only) and physis, is the name given by opponents and suggests a single nature, divine only. Dyophysite names the Chalcedonian teaching of two natures. Eutychianism names the error that the humanity is swallowed up.
Terms used
- Christology: Teaching about who Christ is, especially how divinity and humanity are united in him.
- Miaphysitism: The Coptic Orthodox teaching, from Cyril of Alexandria, that Christ is one incarnate nature of the Word, from two natures united without mixture, confusion or alteration. It rejects the idea of a single blended nature.
- Theotokos: A Greek title for Mary, “God-bearer”, affirming that the child she bore is God the Word incarnate.
- Tradition: In the Orthodox understanding, the Church’s lived and handed-on faith, within which Scripture is read.
The evidence
The Coptic Orthodox Church teaches that Christ is consubstantial with us in humanity and condemns the teaching that the humanity was absorbed into the divinity.
This is the Church’s own confession of its faith, prayed in its liturgy and taught by its Fathers and teachers, and the joint declarations record it. [1] [2] [3]
St Cyril of Alexandria taught that the Word took a complete humanity, and the Alexandrian formula of one incarnate nature was his, not Eutyches’.
St Cyril died in 444, before Eutyches was condemned in 448, so the formula cannot have come from Eutyches. St Cyril’s writings and the Formula of Union plainly affirm the full humanity of Christ, with a rational soul, taken from the Virgin. [2]
The two teachings differ on the central point: whether the humanity of Christ remains complete and of one substance with ours after the union.
The Church affirms that the humanity remains complete and of one essence with ours; Eutyches was condemned for denying it. On this central point the two teachings stand on opposite sides. [1] [3]
The history supports the Church. The Alexandrian formula is older than Eutyches; St Cyril, St Severus and the Church’s liturgy affirm the full humanity of Christ; and the name “monophysite” was given from outside. The Church’s condemnation of Eutyches stands on record in the writings of St Severus.
The Church’s faith is known from its own confessions, liturgy and Fathers, and these speak with one voice: Christ is truly God and truly man, and His humanity is not swallowed up.
In Scripture
Luke 24:39
King James Version
39 Behold my hands and my feet, that it is I myself: handle me, and see; for a spirit hath not flesh and bones, as ye see me have.
What the Church teaches
The Church confesses that the Word became truly man in order to save us, and that if His humanity were not real, ours would not be healed. This is why it rejects both Nestorius, who divided Christ, and Eutyches, who dissolved His humanity.
The Church also confesses that the union does not abolish the difference between what is divine and what is human in Christ. It teaches that the difference remains, and that the union is a union of the divinity and humanity without mingling, confusion or alteration.
The Coptic Orthodox Church uses the word miaphysite for its own teaching and rejects the name monophysite. In its liturgy it confesses that the Lord took from the Virgin a body, a soul and a spirit, that is, a complete humanity. It anathematises Eutyches, and Pope Shenouda III and other leaders have repeated this when speaking of Chalcedon.
The dialogues of the twentieth century did not ask the Church to change its teaching. They recorded that the Church’s faith is not the faith of Eutyches, and that the Chalcedonian churches had misunderstood it.
Objections answered
To say “one nature” after the union is to say what Eutyches said. The Coptic Church is therefore Eutychian whatever it claims.
The phrase is similar, but the meaning is opposite. By the one nature of the incarnate Word the Church means the union of divinity and humanity in one concrete being, as body and soul make one human being, with the humanity complete and unchanged. Eutyches was condemned for saying that the humanity was swallowed up and was not of one essence with ours, and the Church condemns that too.
The true test of a teaching is what it affirms and denies about Christ’s humanity. By that test the Coptic faith confesses the full humanity of Christ, of one essence with us, and the teaching of Eutyches does not.
Dioscorus restored Eutyches at Ephesus in 449, so the Church of Alexandria was in fact defending him.
The council of 449 did restore Eutyches, but it did so on the basis of his profession of the faith of Nicaea and of St Cyril. St Dioscorus received a confession of faith; he did not endorse a denial of Christ’s humanity.
The Church of Alexandria’s own teaching shows where it stood: before and after 449 it confessed the full humanity of Christ, and its Fathers, St Severus above all, condemned Eutyches’ error by name. A judgement about one man’s sincerity does not change the faith the Church confessed.
If the Coptic Church truly holds the full humanity, it should say “two natures” like Chalcedon; refusing the words shows a hidden attachment to Eutyches’ view.
The Church avoids the two-natures wording for the opposite reason: it guards against dividing Christ into two subjects, as Nestorius was understood to teach. Its refusal is a refusal of the council’s wording, not of the full humanity, which it confesses in every liturgy.
The joint statements say that both sides confess the same Christ, perfect in divinity and perfect in humanity, and that they had used the words nature and hypostasis in different senses. Holding to St Cyril’s formula is faithfulness to the Church’s own tradition, not a hidden doctrine.
Conclusion
The Coptic Orthodox Church and Eutyches are not the same. The Church confesses the full humanity of Christ, of one essence with ours, united with the divinity without mingling, confusion or alteration, and it condemns the teaching that the humanity was absorbed. Its confession of the one incarnate nature of God the Word is the faith of St Cyril, which guards both the unity of Christ and the fullness of His humanity.
Sources
- The Creed (Pope Shenouda III books online) · Pope Shenouda III
- On the Unity of Christ · Cyril of Alexandria
- Luke 24:39
No inbox has been set up yet, so nothing is sent. This copies a short report with the page address and revision for you to pass on.