Orthodoxia

Faith & Evidence / The Virgin Mary

Why is Mary called Theotokos or Mother of God?

IntermediateTheologicalAnswer available

Revision 1, updated

The answer

The title is a statement about Christ before it is a statement about Mary. The child born of Mary is not a man to whom God was later joined but God the Word himself, who took flesh from her. A mother is mother of the person she bears, so Mary is rightly called the one who bore God, the Theotokos. The Council of Ephesus (431) confirmed this against Nestorius, following St Cyril, who taught that the Word was born in the flesh of the Virgin. The title does not say that Mary is the source of God’s divinity; it confesses that her Son is truly God, and so honours her as the Mother of God.

  • The title answers the question “who is the child?”: God the Word incarnate.
  • Scripture gives the ground: Elizabeth calls Mary the mother of her Lord (Luke 1:43); Galatians 4:4 says God sent his Son born of a woman; John 1:14 says the Word became flesh.
  • Nestorius, patriarch of Constantinople, preferred Christotokos (“Christ-bearer”); St Cyril of Alexandria answered that this divides Christ into two.
  • The Council of Ephesus in 431 affirmed the title; the Coptic Church receives it as the third of the councils she accepts.
  • The title says Mary is the mother of the person of the Word in his humanity; it does not say she is the origin of his divine nature.

Why this question matters

The title seems to many outside the Church to say that God has a mother, or to raise Mary above her place. Seeing the argument behind it shows that it protects the truth about Christ.

It was also a decisive moment in the history of the Church of Alexandria, whose bishop led the defence of the title; the Coptic Church today still keeps the memory of that council in her faith.

The biblical ground. John 1:14 says the Word, who was with God and was God, became flesh. Galatians 4:4 says God sent his Son, born of a woman. Matthew 1:23 gives the name Emmanuel, God with us. Luke 1:43 has Elizabeth call Mary the mother of her Lord, and “Lord” in Luke’s Gospel is the title of God and of Christ. St Athanasius, in his treatise on the incarnation, says the Word took a body in a virgin who had known no man (chapter 8), and the Alexandrian writers of the fourth century spoke of Mary as Theotokos, a term already in use before Nestorius.

The controversy. In 428 Nestorius became patriarch of Constantinople, and objected to the title, preferring Christotokos because he feared that “Mother of God” suggested that the divine nature was born of a woman. St Cyril, bishop of Alexandria, wrote to him that the Word was born in the flesh of the Virgin, so that Christ is one, not two. He taught the one incarnate nature of God the Word. The Council of Ephesus met in 431, confirmed the title and condemned the separation of Christ into two sons. In 433 the Formula of Union reconciled Cyril with the Antiochene bishops, who accepted the title.

The shape of the argument. If the child in Mary’s womb were only a man, later joined to the Word, then there would be two subjects, the Son of God and the son of Mary. The Church confesses that there is one: the Word himself, who is born in time of Mary in his humanity as he is born from the Father before all ages in his divinity. Because the two births belong to the one Son, what is true of him is said of the one person: so Mary is Theotokos, and the Church can also say that God suffered in the flesh.

Terms used

  • Christology: Teaching about who Christ is, especially how divinity and humanity are united in him.
  • Miaphysitism: The Coptic Orthodox teaching, from Cyril of Alexandria, that Christ is one incarnate nature of the Word, from two natures united without mixture, confusion or alteration. It rejects the idea of a single blended nature.
  • Theotokos: A Greek title for Mary, “God-bearer”, affirming that the child she bore is God the Word incarnate.
  • Trinity: The Christian teaching that God is one in essence and three in persons: Father, Son and Holy Spirit.
  • Tradition: In the Orthodox understanding, the Church’s lived and handed-on faith, within which Scripture is read.

The evidence

The New Testament calls Mary the mother of the Lord and speaks of the Son of God as born of a woman, and these are the biblical ground of the title.

The statements are plain in Luke 1:43, Galatians 4:4 and John 1:14. If the Word who is God became flesh, and the Son whom God sent was born of a woman, then the woman who bore Him is rightly called the Theotokos. The title simply gathers what these verses say into one word. [1] [2] [3] [4]

The title was affirmed at Ephesus in 431 as a defence of the unity of Christ against Nestorius, under the leadership of St Cyril of Alexandria.

The council, its date, St Cyril’s role and the matter of the title are well documented in the Church’s history, and both sides of the controversy are known from their own writings. The title was already in use in Alexandria before the dispute began. [5]

The Church holds that the Word took flesh from the Virgin, so that the one born of her is God the Word incarnate.

St Cyril of Alexandria teaches that Christ is one Son, the Word made flesh, not two persons joined together. This is exactly what the Gospel of John means when it says that the Word became flesh. [5]

The history is clear: the title was used in the Alexandrian church before 431, the controversy with Nestorius and the Council of Ephesus are well documented, and the Formula of Union in 433 brought the Antiochene bishops to accept the title. Many Protestant traditions also accept it as a statement about Christ.

In Scripture

Luke 1:43

King James Version

43 And whence is this to me, that the mother of my Lord should come to me?

Galatians 4:4

King James Version

4 But when the fulness of the time was come, God sent forth his Son, made of a woman, made under the law,

John 1:14

King James Version

14 And the Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us, (and we beheld his glory, the glory as of the only begotten of the Father,) full of grace and truth.

Matthew 1:23

King James Version

23 Behold, a virgin shall be with child, and shall bring forth a son, and they shall call his name Emmanuel, which being interpreted is, God with us.

What the Church teaches

The Church confesses that the Son of God became a man of the Virgin Mary without ceasing to be God. Because the child is the Word himself, Mary is the Theotokos. The title honours Mary and, first, confesses the Lord.

St Cyril, the twenty-fourth pope of Alexandria, is called the Pillar of Faith, and the Coptic Church keeps Ephesus among the three ecumenical councils she receives. The Church confesses Christ in the words of Cyril, one incarnate nature of God the Word, and calls Mary Theotokos in the Liturgy, the Theotokia and the Agpeya. For the Church the title is not a Marian addition but a confession about the incarnation.

Objections answered

“Mother of God” suggests that God has a mother, or that Mary existed before God. The Bible never says it, and a more careful title would be Mother of Christ.

The title does not say Mary is the mother of the divine nature. It says she is the mother of the person who is God the Word. A woman is the mother of a person, not of his soul or his nature, and we say that a mother bears her son though she did not make his soul.

“Mother of Christ” is true, but it does not answer the question of who Christ is. “Christ” is the name of the one Lord, who is God and man; leaving out the divine side can suggest that the one born of her was another than the Word. The Church uses the title to keep the unity of Christ, and Elizabeth already called Mary the mother of her Lord.

[1] [5]

The title was imposed by politics: the rivalry of Alexandria and Constantinople, not theology, settled it.

Human rivalries were present at Ephesus, as they are in every age of the Church. But they do not decide whether a teaching is true. The title was in use in Alexandria before the dispute, and St Cyril’s argument is theological: it rests on Scripture and on the one Christ.

The Church has received the council’s faith in her worship for centuries, and the Formula of Union in 433 brought the bishops of Antioch to accept the title too. A teaching imposed by politics alone would not have become the prayer of the whole Church.

Conclusion

The Virgin Mary is the Theotokos because the One she bore is God the Word incarnate. The title rests on the plain words of Scripture, was defended by St Cyril of Alexandria and confirmed at Ephesus in 431, and is prayed by the Church every day. It is a confession about Christ before it is an honour for Mary, and in honouring her the Church confesses her Son as true God.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close