Orthodoxia

Faith & Evidence / Early Christianity and Coptic Orthodox doctrine

What happened at Nicaea?

IntermediateHistoricalAnswer available

Revision 1, updated

The answer

The emperor Constantine called the bishops of the Church to Nicaea in 325 to settle a dispute that began in Alexandria, where the presbyter Arius taught that the Son was brought into being by the Father and was not eternal. The council rejected that teaching and confessed that the Son is begotten, not made, of one essence with the Father. It also dealt with the date of Easter and with questions of Church order. It did not invent the worship of Christ and did not decide the list of biblical books. Its creed was later completed at Constantinople in 381, and the Coptic Orthodox Church confesses it at every Liturgy.

  • The dispute began in Alexandria between its bishop Alexander and the presbyter Arius, who taught that there was a time when the Son was not.
  • Constantine convened the council in 325 at Nicaea in Bithynia, and bishops came from many regions, most of them from the East.
  • The council confessed the Son as begotten from the Father, true God, of one essence with him, and condemned the teaching of Arius.
  • It also set a common rule for the date of Easter and dealt with discipline, including the schism of Meletius in Egypt.
  • It did not vote the Son into divinity and did not select the canon of Scripture; the dispute was between people who already worshipped Christ.
  • Acceptance followed after decades of dispute, with Athanasius as the leading defender of the Nicene faith.

Why this question matters

Nicaea is the most misdescribed event in early Church history. Popular accounts say that the emperor and a vote made Jesus God, that the Bible was chosen there, or that the council suppressed other gospels. A clear account of what happened answers each of these claims.

It also matters because the Coptic Orthodox Church counts Nicaea as its own history: the controversy began in Alexandria, its bishop took part, and its deacon Athanasius became the council’s chief defender.

Arius was a presbyter in Alexandria in the time of Bishop Alexander, whom the Coptic Church counts as its nineteenth pope. Arius taught that the Son is the first and greatest of God’s creatures, brought into being before the ages by the Father, so that there was a time when the Son was not. Alexander and others held that the Son is eternally begotten of the Father and shares his divine being.

The conflict spread through the eastern Church. Constantine, who had recently become sole ruler of the empire, wanted unity in the Church, and he summoned the bishops to Nicaea in the summer of 325. The Church remembers them as the three hundred and eighteen fathers of Nicaea.

The council confessed that the Son is begotten of the Father, God from God, light from light, true God from true God, begotten and not made, of one essence with the Father. The Greek word for “of one essence” is homoousios. It also added anathemas against those who say that there was a time when the Son was not, or that he came from nothing, or that he is of another essence than the Father.

The council handled other matters: it sought a common date for Easter across the churches and addressed the Meletian schism in Egypt and other points of Church order. Later tradition collected a set of canons from it. The council’s creed ended briefly with belief in the Holy Spirit; the longer statement on the Spirit belongs to Constantinople in 381, and the text recited in the Church today is called the Nicene-Constantinopolitan Creed.

Terms used

  • Canon: The list of books a community receives as Scripture.
  • Christology: Teaching about who Christ is, especially how divinity and humanity are united in him.
  • Miaphysitism: The Coptic Orthodox teaching, from Cyril of Alexandria, that Christ is one incarnate nature of the Word, from two natures united without mixture, confusion or alteration. It rejects the idea of a single blended nature.
  • Trinity: The Christian teaching that God is one in essence and three in persons: Father, Son and Holy Spirit.
  • Tradition: In the Orthodox understanding, the Church’s lived and handed-on faith, within which Scripture is read.

The evidence

The council of 325 was summoned by Constantine to settle a dispute that began in Alexandria over the teaching of Arius, and it condemned that teaching.

The ancient accounts, including the letters and writings of St Athanasius, who was present, show the occasion, the convening and the condemnation clearly. [1]

The council did not begin the worship of Christ, did not vote Jesus into divinity, and did not decide which books belong to the Bible.

The dispute was between Christians who already worshipped Christ; the surviving record of the council concerns the creed, Easter and Church order, not the list of Scripture. [1]

The Nicene faith that the Son is of one essence with the Father was defended by Athanasius and accepted in the Church only after decades of dispute.

The fourth century was a long period of debate, and studies such as Ayres’ place Nicaea at its start, not its end. The faith of Nicaea prevailed not by force but because it was the faith of the Church, and St Athanasius held to it through five exiles. [1]

The Nicene confession expresses the faith of the Scriptures and the apostles: the Son is truly God, begotten of the Father.

The Church reads John 1 and Matthew 28:19, with the whole witness of Scripture, as teaching the Son’s full divinity. The council gave that teaching a precise form to answer Arius. [2]

Nicaea is well attested as an assembly of bishops that answered a real controversy, and its main decision is clear. The claims that it voted Jesus into divinity or fixed the Bible do not fit the record.

The worship of Christ is far older than the council: St Paul’s letters already call on His name as Lord, and the martyrs of the second and third centuries died confessing Him. Nicaea guarded that faith; it did not create it.

What the Church teaches

The Church believes that the Holy Spirit guides the Church’s councils, and that at Nicaea the bishops confessed the faith given to the apostles in words that exclude the denial of the Son’s divinity. It receives Nicaea, Constantinople and Ephesus as the three ecumenical councils whose teaching it holds.

The Coptic Orthodox Church therefore treats the Creed as the foundation of its confession of Christ and the Holy Trinity, and not as a human compromise.

Alexandria stood at the heart of the Nicene story. Pope Alexander, its nineteenth pope, opposed Arius; his deacon Athanasius went with him to the council and, as the twentieth pope of Alexandria, spent his life defending its faith, enduring exile more than once. The Church calls him the Apostolic.

The Creed is recited in the Coptic Liturgy and in the Agpeya, the book of the hours. When Copts say that they hold the faith of the three ecumenical councils, they mean that they stand in the line of Nicaea. Their separation from the later Council of Chalcedon is a distinct question, treated elsewhere.

Objections answered

Constantine imposed the outcome. The council was a political act to unify the empire, and the bishops signed what the emperor wanted.

The emperor called the council, paid for the bishops’ travel and attended the proceedings. But the question of faith came from the Church, in a quarrel that began in Alexandria before he took any interest, and the bishops answered it from the faith they had received.

The later history proves the point. Constantine himself later recalled Arius from exile, and in the following decades several emperors favoured the opponents of Nicaea and sent St Athanasius into exile. The Nicene faith survived imperial pressure against it; it was not imperial power that made it the faith of the Church.

[1]

The word “of one essence” is not found in the Bible. The council put a philosophical term in place of Scripture.

The word is not in Scripture, and some bishops at the time raised that objection. But Arius could accept every biblical title for the Son and still mean that He is a creature; a term was needed that excluded this reading.

The term adds nothing to Scripture; it guards what Scripture says: the Word was God, and all things were made through Him (John 1:1–3). The Church uses a precise word so that no one can empty the biblical words of their meaning.

Nicaea decided which gospels would be in the Bible and burned the rest.

The surviving record of the council does not contain a list of biblical books or a decision to destroy writings. Its subjects are the Son, Easter and Church order. The Gospels were already read in the churches long before Nicaea; the article on who chose the books describes how the lists were confirmed.

[1]

Conclusion

Nicaea was a council of bishops that answered a dispute begun in Alexandria by confessing the Son as true God, of one essence with the Father. It neither began the worship of Christ nor chose the Bible. It guarded the faith of the apostles in exact words, and the Coptic Orthodox Church, whose fathers Alexander and Athanasius stood at its heart, confesses that faith at every Liturgy.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close