Faith & Evidence / Archaeology and historical context
How do we recognize forged, sensationalized or misidentified artifacts?
The answer
A genuine discovery can show where it was found, how it reached us, what independent testing has found, and what specialists who examined it actually read on it. Its claim stays within what the object says. Forgeries and sensational claims fail these tests: the object comes from the antiquities market with no record, the news reaches the media before any scholarly publication, the testing is partial or kept secret, and the claim is far bigger than the object. The Dead Sea Scroll fragments exposed as modern forgeries and the "Gospel of Jesus’ Wife" papyrus are clear examples. A Christian applies the same tests to every claim, whether it seems to help the faith or to harm it, because the faith rests on Christ and the apostolic witness, not on any object.
- First ask where, when and by whom the object was found, and whether its path to the present is on record. Objects from the market with no documented origin are the main source of forgeries.
- Ask whether independent laboratories and specialists have examined the object itself and published their results.
- Ask what the object really says. Many claims rest on a common name, a damaged line or a reading the text does not support.
- Be wary of finds announced first through the media, of claims that "prove" a doctrine, and of claims that bring large profit.
- Use the same standard for claims that support the faith and claims that attack it. The Church’s faith does not rest on an artefact.
Why this question matters
Sensational claims spread quickly, and each one that collapses weakens trust in real discoveries and in the defence of the faith. A believer who repeats an unverified claim harms the truth he wants to serve.
Sceptics err too when they dismiss a genuine find because it is inconvenient. Fair testing serves the truth on every side.
Forgery in antiquities is old and profitable, and the market for objects connected with the Bible is large. Archaeologists put great weight on context: an object excavated from a recorded layer can be dated by what lies above and below it, while an object with no context can be dated only by the object itself, and an object from the market has often been looted, which destroys the context on which its interpretation would depend.
Several kinds of examination are used. Epigraphers study the script, spelling and language for anachronisms. Materials scientists examine the patina (the natural crust that forms on stone or metal over centuries), the ink and the writing surface, and may use radiocarbon dating on organic material. Experts in the relevant field then publish their findings so that others can criticise them. A result that is announced without these steps is a claim and not yet a finding.
Dating the material is not enough. A forger can write a modern text on an ancient leather or papyrus, and a genuine ancient object may be given a modern interpretation. The text, the surface and the date have to be considered together.
Terms used
- Primary source: A text or object from the period being studied, such as an ancient letter, a manuscript or an inscription.
- Secondary source: A modern study that interprets primary sources, such as a scholarly book or article.
- Manuscript: A handwritten copy of a text on papyrus, parchment or paper.
- Papyrus: A writing material made from the papyrus plant, common in Egypt in antiquity.
- Dead Sea Scrolls: Manuscripts found near Qumran from about the third century BC to the first century AD, including Hebrew Bible texts.
- Tradition: In the Orthodox understanding, the Church’s lived and handed-on faith, within which Scripture is read.
The evidence
Provenance, independent scientific testing, expert reading and publication are the standard tests of an artefact. A find that lacks them is unproven and should not be used in argument.
We trust an object for three reasons: it is old, it is what it is said to be, and it says what it is said to say. Each test answers one of these questions. Context matters most, because an object excavated from a recorded layer can be checked in ways that an object from the market never can. [1]
The sound response to a claimed discovery is to wait for four things: the find-spot and custody record, independent testing, specialist publication, and proof that the object says what is claimed. This guards the reader against forgery and against an inflated reading of a genuine object.
What the Church teaches
The Church bears witness to Christ through the apostles, the Scriptures and the life of the Church, and it can afford to be patient with claimed discoveries. Truthfulness is part of Christian ethics. To use a doubtful claim in defence of the faith is to put the truth at risk for the sake of the truth.
Coptic Christians know the cost of forged texts from their own heritage: the manuscripts found at Nag Hammadi in Egypt and other Coptic papyri are real ancient documents that have been studied with care, and a modern forgery in the Coptic language, such as the papyrus presented in 2012, harms the study of the real ones. The Church receives the faith through the apostles and the Fathers, and it asks that claims about its own history be tested with the same honesty.
Objections answered
Forgeries are always found out later by experts. So any claim that favours Christianity can be dismissed in advance as a probable forgery.
That is simply bias in the other direction. Genuine discoveries have been made and confirmed, and the same expert checking that exposes forgeries is what confirms authentic objects. Every claim is judged on its own evidence. Calling every supportive object false is no fairer than calling every such object true.
The right lesson is that the same tests apply to everyone, and that a find is used in argument only after it has passed them.
Relics and holy objects honoured in the Church are in the same position as these artefacts. If you doubt a papyrus, you should doubt the relics.
They are different kinds of claim. A relic is honoured within the Church’s tradition about a saint, and the honour goes to the saint. No doctrine depends on any relic. A discovery put forward as evidence for or against the faith makes a historical claim, and so it is tested as history.
The Coptic Church holds that the relics of the saints are a means of God’s grace, and it venerates the portion of the relics of St Mark returned to Egypt in 1968, a return that is a matter of record. Honouring a saint is one thing; using an object as an argument is another.
Scholars who reject a sensational claim may simply be protecting their own views, in the same way that believers are accused of doing.
That is exactly why the tests must be public and repeatable. A judgment based on a published analysis of the script, the material and the context can be checked by anyone with the skills, whatever their motive. When specialists of different outlooks reach the same conclusion, it stands firm. When they still disagree, as with the James ossuary, the object should simply not be used in argument.
Conclusion
A claimed discovery earns trust through its record, its testing and the care of those who read it. The same questions apply whether a find seems to help the faith or to harm it. The Church can be patient and truthful here, because its faith rests on Christ and the witness of the apostles, not on any object.
Sources
- Beyond the Texts: An Archaeological Portrait of Ancient Israel and Judah · William G. Dever
No inbox has been set up yet, so nothing is sent. This copies a short report with the page address and revision for you to pass on.