Orthodoxia

Faith & Evidence / Archaeology and historical context

What can archaeology establish about biblical history?

IntermediateArchaeologicalAnswer available

Revision 1, updated

The answer

Archaeology shows again and again that the Scriptures speak of real places and real people. It can establish that a place existed and was occupied, that a city was destroyed or rebuilt in a given period, and that a king named in the Bible is also named in an inscription of his own time, as Hezekiah is in the annals of the Assyrian king Sennacherib. It shows what daily life, trade and worship looked like. What it cannot do is weigh a miracle or an inspired word: those are known through the witness of God’s people. And it is weak at proving that something did not happen, since a people who move camp leave little behind. The Church’s faith rests on the apostolic witness, and she welcomes every honest find, because the God of Scripture acts in real history.

  • Archaeology is strongest on places, buildings, destruction layers, trade, pottery sequences and inscriptions that name people and kings.
  • Inscriptions from Israel’s neighbours name kings and events the Bible also names, such as Hezekiah in Sennacherib’s annals and the Assyrian siege of Lachish.
  • A miracle, an inspired word or a doctrine is known through the witness of God’s people, not through objects in the ground.
  • Absence of finds proves little where a community was small, mobile or built with perishable materials.
  • The Church reads Scripture within her faith and does not need archaeology to prove it; she welcomes honest evidence, because God acts in real history.

Why this question matters

Many readers meet the Bible and archaeology in headlines: a discovery that "proves the Bible", or a dig that "disproves" it. Both headlines usually say more than the find does. Knowing what a find can show lets the reader welcome real evidence without being shaken by noise.

The question matters to believers because the Scriptures claim to speak of events in time, and to unbelievers because it is one place where a religious text can be checked against the ground.

Archaeologists dig sites in layers, and each layer holds pottery, buildings and ash that can be ordered in time. Dates come from pottery styles (typology), from inscriptions that name known rulers, and from scientific methods such as radiocarbon dating of short-lived material like seeds and charred wood. Each method has a margin of error, and the margin matters when the argument concerns a few decades.

An inscription is a different kind of evidence. A royal inscription of a neighbouring empire, written at the time, names kings and campaigns, and it can be set beside what the Bible says. It is still a document with its own purposes: kings of the period boasted, and the surviving record is partial.

Reading the results is where the schools differ. Those often called maximalists, among whom K. A. Kitchen is a prominent example, argue that the Old Testament fits the evidence of the ancient Near East well and that silence is often explained by chance survival. Those often called minimalists or low-chronology scholars, such as Israel Finkelstein and Neil Asher Silberman, argue that the archaeological record supports a smaller and later early Israel than the narratives describe, and that much of the text took its present shape centuries after the events. William Dever, who wrote an archaeology-centred history of Israel and Judah, criticises both extremes.

Terms used

  • Apologetics: The reasoned defence and explanation of a belief. It offers arguments and evidence for examination; it does not replace faith or guarantee agreement.
  • Primary source: A text or object from the period being studied, such as an ancient letter, a manuscript or an inscription.
  • Secondary source: A modern study that interprets primary sources, such as a scholarly book or article.
  • Typology: Reading a person or event in the Old Testament as foreshadowing something in Christ. It is a way of reading, not a prediction in the narrow sense.
  • Inspiration: The Christian belief that God worked through the human authors of Scripture. It is a theological claim, distinct from the preservation of manuscripts.

The evidence

Archaeology can establish material and documentary facts: that places existed, that buildings and cities were built and destroyed in certain periods, and that named people appear in contemporary inscriptions.

This is the ordinary work of the discipline. The Assyrian relief of the siege of Lachish meets the biblical account of Sennacherib’s campaign in Judah, and the inscriptions of the ancient Near East give a firm outside frame for many biblical events. [1] [4]

A miracle, the inspiration of a text and the meaning of a doctrine are known through the witness of God’s people, not through excavation.

Objects show what people made, built and left behind. That an event was an act of God is made known by those who witnessed it and by the Church that received their witness. A find serves that witness by fixing its time and place. [3]

Where archaeologists differ over the early history of Israel (the patriarchs, the Exodus, the conquest, the united monarchy), the debate turns on dating and on the weight given to silence, and it does not overturn the Scriptures.

The same excavations are read in different ways because dates carry margins of error and because the earliest periods left little behind. A conclusion drawn from silence about small, mobile peoples is weak, and later finds have often filled gaps once taken as proof against the text. [1] [2] [3]

Where an inscription outside the Bible names a king or a campaign that the Bible also names, the two sources confirm one another. The Assyrian records of Sennacherib’s campaign against Hezekiah and the relief of the siege of Lachish are clear examples: the Scriptures describe the real world of their time.

A Christian does not need to claim more than the evidence gives. A discovery that fits the text is welcome, and a discovery that raises a difficulty is a reason to look again at both the find and the reading of the text, in the confidence that God’s word is true.

What the Church teaches

The Church confesses that God acts in history, supremely in the Incarnation of God the Word, and so it has always cared that the Scriptures speak of real times and places. But what it confesses about Christ rests on the apostolic witness and the life of the Church, and it is not suspended on what a trench produces.

In the Coptic Orthodox Church the Old Testament is read as the book of the same God who became incarnate, and its history is read both as history and as the shadow of Christ, as St Paul and the Alexandrian Fathers did. Origen in particular, working in Alexandria, wrote homilies on the historical books that found Christ in them without denying their narrative. This is why a debate about the date of a wall does not shake the Church’s use of the Scripture in worship.

Objections answered

If a major event such as the Exodus left no clear trace after a century and a half of excavation, the most reasonable conclusion is that it did not happen as described.

Silence proves little here. A large settled city leaves walls and pottery. A people moving through a desert, living in tents, leaves almost nothing; and in the Nile Delta the ancient surface is often buried under silt or eroded away. The absence of finds is exactly what one would expect, and it is no evidence that the Exodus did not happen.

The Exodus is remembered at the heart of Israel’s whole life, in the Passover and in the prophets and psalms, and the Exodus article sets out the evidence in full. A people does not build its identity on a slavery it invented.

[1] [2]

Christian and Jewish archaeologists who work on the Bible have an interest in finding confirmation, and their results should be discounted.

Commitments apply to every side: scholars who want to show that the Bible is late and unreliable bring theirs too. A find is judged by its evidence, published so that others can check it, with dates and layers that can be tested, and not by the faith of the one who dug it. Discounting believers alone is itself a bias.

[1] [2] [3]

A believer should treat any archaeological result that conflicts with the text as mistaken, since Scripture is the word of God.

The Church receives Scripture as inspired and does not set it under a spade. Scripture is true; scholarly reconstructions of a date or a site are not infallible, and they are revised often. So a believer can meet any find with calm, look again at both the find and the reading of the text, and trust that truth does not contradict truth. The Church’s tradition reads the books on several levels, historical, moral and typological, and does not tie her faith to a single archaeological answer.

Conclusion

Archaeology is a good witness to places, objects, destructions and the names that appear in inscriptions, and again and again it shows that the Scriptures speak of a real world, real kings and real cities. Miracle, inspiration and meaning are known through the witness of God’s people. The Church’s faith rests on that witness, and she welcomes every honest find without fear, because the God of Scripture acts in history.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close