Orthodoxia

Faith & Evidence / The Virgin Mary

How does the virgin birth differ from the Roman Catholic doctrine of the Immaculate Conception?

IntermediateTheologicalAnswer available

Revision 1, updated

The answer

They are about two different persons and two different conceptions. The virgin birth concerns the Lord Jesus: He was conceived in the Virgin’s womb by the Holy Spirit without a human father, as St Matthew and St Luke testify. The Immaculate Conception concerns Mary: the Roman Catholic Church defined in 1854 that from the first moment of her own conception she was preserved from original sin. The Coptic Orthodox Church confesses the first as part of the Creed and does not teach the second as a doctrine. She honours Mary as all-holy and holds that the Holy Spirit sanctified her when the Word took flesh from her.

  • Virgin birth: Jesus was conceived by the Holy Spirit, without a human father (Matthew 1:18–25; Luke 1:26–38). Every ancient church confesses it.
  • Immaculate Conception: Mary was preserved from original sin from her own conception. It was defined by Pius IX in 1854, and is not found in Scripture in so many words.
  • The Catholic argument draws on Luke 1:28 (“full of grace”), on the parallel of Eve and Mary in the Fathers, and on the fitness of the Mother of God.
  • Eastern Orthodox and Oriental Orthodox Christians honour Mary as all-holy, but understand original sin differently and do not hold this doctrine.
  • The Coptic Church teaches that Mary needed a Saviour (Luke 1:47) and was sanctified by the Holy Spirit when the Word took flesh from her.
  • Protestants reject the Immaculate Conception as lacking biblical warrant.

Why this question matters

Many people, including Christians, use “virgin birth” and “Immaculate Conception” as if they were the same. A common error is to think the Immaculate Conception is the conception of Jesus. Keeping them apart prevents confusion in both directions.

The distinction also shows exactly where the Coptic Orthodox Church stands and why: she holds the Creed’s confession of the virgin birth, and she does not accept a doctrine of the Roman Church that she judges to rest on a different account of original sin.

The virgin birth. Matthew 1:18–25 and Luke 1:26–38 report that Mary conceived Jesus by the Holy Spirit and not by Joseph. The Creed confesses that the Son was incarnate of the Holy Spirit and the Virgin Mary. Every ancient church, and nearly all Protestant churches, hold it. The article on what Matthew and Luke claim sets out the texts.

The Immaculate Conception. On 8 December 1854, in the bull Ineffabilis Deus, Pope Pius IX defined that Mary, from the first instant of her conception, by a singular grace and in view of the merits of Christ, was preserved free from original sin. Catholics find support in the angel’s greeting in Luke 1:28, which they read as describing a fullness of grace already present; in the early Fathers’ parallel between Eve, who was without sin before the fall, and Mary, the new Eve; and in the fitness that the mother of God be wholly free from sin. They do not say that she did not need Christ’s salvation but that she was saved in advance, by his merits.

Why the East does not hold it. Eastern and Oriental Orthodox Christians have not made it a doctrine. In the Greek and Alexandrian tradition, what is inherited from Adam is above all mortality and corruption, and a tendency to sin, not personal guilt as in the Latin tradition after St Augustine. So the idea of being “preserved from original sin” does not translate easily into their thought. They also point out that Luke 1:47 has Mary rejoice in God her Saviour, and that the Fathers speak of her purification by the Holy Spirit at the Annunciation (Luke 1:35). The Orthodox call her all-holy (Panagia) and generally avoid claiming more than the Church’s ancient tradition says.

Protestants. They reject the doctrine on the ground that it has no basis in Scripture and that it separates Mary from the rest of the redeemed. The Protestant churches did not accept the 1854 definition.

Terms used

  • Gospel: An early Christian account of the life, death and resurrection of Jesus. “Gospel” also means the good news they proclaim.
  • Theotokos: A Greek title for Mary, “God-bearer”, affirming that the child she bore is God the Word incarnate.
  • Virginal conception: The teaching that Jesus was conceived by the Holy Spirit without a human father.
  • Perpetual virginity: The teaching that Mary remained a virgin throughout her life. It is a separate claim from the virginal conception.
  • Tradition: In the Orthodox understanding, the Church’s lived and handed-on faith, within which Scripture is read.

The evidence

The virgin birth is the conception of Jesus by the Holy Spirit without a human father, reported by Matthew and Luke; the Immaculate Conception is a distinct doctrine about Mary’s own conception, defined by the Roman Catholic Church in 1854.

The texts of Matthew 1 and Luke 1 say the first; the date and content of the second are documented in the Roman Church’s own definition. [1] [2]

The New Testament does not teach the Immaculate Conception. The Catholic arguments from Luke 1:28, from the Eve–Mary parallel and from fittingness do not show that Mary was preserved from original sin at her own conception.

Luke 1:28 is a greeting to a woman favoured by God. It speaks of the grace given her for her calling to be the Mother of God, and says nothing about her own conception. Mary herself rejoices in God her Saviour (Luke 1:47). [3] [4]

The Coptic Orthodox Church confesses the virgin birth, calls Mary all-holy and Theotokos, and does not teach the Immaculate Conception.

The Creed the Church prays confesses the incarnation of the Son of the Virgin; the Church’s teaching on Mary’s sanctification is that the Holy Spirit sanctified her at the Annunciation, and not that she was preserved at her conception. [4]

Historically: the virgin birth is reported in Matthew and Luke and was confessed by Ignatius of Antioch early in the second century. The Immaculate Conception was debated in the medieval West, with eminent theologians on both sides, and defined in 1854. The Eastern churches did not take part in that debate in the same terms.

In Scripture

Matthew 1:18–25

King James Version

18 ¶ Now the birth of Jesus Christ was on this wise: When as his mother Mary was espoused to Joseph, before they came together, she was found with child of the Holy Ghost.

19 Then Joseph her husband, being a just man, and not willing to make her a publick example, was minded to put her away privily.

20 But while he thought on these things, behold, the angel of the Lord appeared unto him in a dream, saying, Joseph, thou son of David, fear not to take unto thee Mary thy wife: for that which is conceived in her is of the Holy Ghost.

21 And she shall bring forth a son, and thou shalt call his name JESUS: for he shall save his people from their sins.

22 Now all this was done, that it might be fulfilled which was spoken of the Lord by the prophet, saying,

23 Behold, a virgin shall be with child, and shall bring forth a son, and they shall call his name Emmanuel, which being interpreted is, God with us.

24 Then Joseph being raised from sleep did as the angel of the Lord had bidden him, and took unto him his wife:

25 And knew her not till she had brought forth her firstborn son: and he called his name JESUS.

Luke 1:26–38

King James Version

26 And in the sixth month the angel Gabriel was sent from God unto a city of Galilee, named Nazareth,

27 To a virgin espoused to a man whose name was Joseph, of the house of David; and the virgin’s name was Mary.

28 And the angel came in unto her, and said, Hail, thou that art highly favoured, the Lord is with thee: blessed art thou among women.

29 And when she saw him, she was troubled at his saying, and cast in her mind what manner of salutation this should be.

30 And the angel said unto her, Fear not, Mary: for thou hast found favour with God.

31 And, behold, thou shalt conceive in thy womb, and bring forth a son, and shalt call his name JESUS.

32 He shall be great, and shall be called the Son of the Highest: and the Lord God shall give unto him the throne of his father David:

33 And he shall reign over the house of Jacob for ever; and of his kingdom there shall be no end.

34 Then said Mary unto the angel, How shall this be, seeing I know not a man?

35 And the angel answered and said unto her, The Holy Ghost shall come upon thee, and the power of the Highest shall overshadow thee: therefore also that holy thing which shall be born of thee shall be called the Son of God.

36 And, behold, thy cousin Elisabeth, she hath also conceived a son in her old age: and this is the sixth month with her, who was called barren.

37 For with God nothing shall be impossible.

38 And Mary said, Behold the handmaid of the Lord; be it unto me according to thy word. And the angel departed from her.

Luke 1:28

King James Version

28 And the angel came in unto her, and said, Hail, thou that art highly favoured, the Lord is with thee: blessed art thou among women.

Luke 1:35

King James Version

35 And the angel answered and said unto her, The Holy Ghost shall come upon thee, and the power of the Highest shall overshadow thee: therefore also that holy thing which shall be born of thee shall be called the Son of God.

What the Church teaches

The Church confesses that the Son of God was incarnate of the Holy Spirit and the Virgin Mary, and honours Mary as all-holy. She believes that the Holy Spirit sanctified her for this purpose, and that she shares our nature and is saved by her Son.

The Coptic Orthodox Church prays the Creed in every liturgy and confesses the incarnation from the Virgin Mary. She calls Mary Theotokos, Ever-Virgin and all-holy, and keeps her feasts. She does not hold the doctrine of the Immaculate Conception, a teaching that arose in the Latin tradition and was defined by Rome in 1854, but receives the Church’s ancient faith in the sanctification of Mary by the Holy Spirit.

Objections answered

Catholic: the Mother of God must have been preserved from all sin; it would be unfitting for the Son of God to take flesh from a sinner. If Orthodox Christians call her all-holy, they should accept the Immaculate Conception.

The Coptic Church agrees that Mary is all-holy and that the Word took flesh from a body made pure by the Holy Spirit. She differs over when and how: she holds that the Holy Spirit sanctified Mary when the Word became incarnate, and not that she was exempt from the common condition of humanity from her conception.

She also points out that Christ himself, in her teaching, redeems all who share human nature, and Mary’s own words about God her Saviour fit this. The Church has not found a basis for the 1854 definition in the early tradition she received, and does not think a bishop can make a new dogma by himself.

[4] [3]

Sceptics and some Protestants: both doctrines are later pious additions around a simple story of a young Jewish woman and her son.

The two doctrines are not on the same footing. The virgin birth is reported by two Gospels and was confessed by the early Church; the Immaculate Conception was defined in the nineteenth century. Treating them together hides this difference.

The virgin birth rests on the testimony of the Gospels and the unbroken faith of the Church, which confessed it from the beginning. It belongs to the mystery of the incarnation: the eternal Son took flesh from the Virgin by the Holy Spirit.

[1] [2]

Conclusion

The virgin birth concerns the conception of Christ and is confessed by every ancient church. The Immaculate Conception concerns the conception of Mary and was defined by the Roman Catholic Church in 1854. The Coptic Orthodox Church confesses the first with the whole ancient Church. She honours the Virgin as all-holy and Theotokos, sanctified by the Holy Spirit when the Word took flesh from her, and does not teach the second.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close