Orthodoxia

Faith & Evidence / Crucifixion and resurrection

Which trial details are secure, and which are debated?

AdvancedHistoricalAnswer available

Revision 1, updated

The answer

The heart of the account is firmly established. Jesus was handed over in Jerusalem, sentenced by the Roman governor Pontius Pilate, and crucified on a Friday near Passover under a written charge naming Him King of the Jews. A Roman historian, St Paul the Apostle and all four Gospels bear witness to it. The Gospels also agree that the priestly leaders in Jerusalem questioned Him and brought Him to Pilate, which fits what is known of Roman rule. Around this core, each evangelist tells the hours of the trial from his own angle: the night questioning, Barabbas, Herod, Pilate washing his hands. These are narratives, not court records, and their variety shows independent witness. They all lead to the same place: the Lord, judged by men, freely gave Himself for our salvation.

  • Secure: the handing over in Jerusalem, the Roman sentence, crucifixion under a written charge of kingship, and a Friday close to Passover. St Paul already knows that Jesus was handed over (1 Corinthians 11:23).
  • Well supported: the part of the priestly leadership in the arrest and in bringing Jesus to Pilate. All four Gospels agree on it, and it fits how a Roman governor relied on local leaders.
  • The Gospels tell the hearing before the priests each in his own way; they are narratives with their own purposes, not transcripts.
  • The release of Barabbas and the hearing before Herod Antipas (in St Luke) fit the political setting of Judea under Pilate; St Matthew adds Pilate washing his hands.
  • The core does not depend on harmonising every detail, and the variety of the accounts shows that they were not smoothed into one.

Why this question matters

A reader who learns that Jesus was crucified under Pilate naturally asks what happened in the hours before. Knowing what is firmly established, and how to read the Gospel narratives of those hours, lets the reader stand on solid ground.

It also matters for fairness. Some accounts of the trial have been misused to blame the Jewish people as a whole. A careful reading of what the sources say about who did what guards against that grave error.

Our detailed accounts are the four Gospels, written some decades after the events by followers of Jesus. Read as ancient documents, they are narratives with their own purposes, not legal records. Mark is usually thought to be the earliest, and Matthew and Luke appear to build on it; John tells the story in an independent form that differs in order and content.

Outside the Gospels the evidence is thin. Tacitus (Annals 15.44) and Josephus (Antiquities 18.63–64) place the execution under Pilate, but give no details of the hearing. For the legal setting we depend on Josephus on Judea under the Romans, on Philo, and on rabbinic rules from the Mishnah, which was put in writing around AD 200 and describes procedure in a form that may or may not reflect the first century.

Pilate governed Judea from about AD 26 to 36, with his seat at Caesarea and a presence in Jerusalem at the great festivals. The high priest Caiaphas held office throughout most of his term. These are the framework within which the details below are judged.

Terms used

  • Primary source: A text or object from the period being studied, such as an ancient letter, a manuscript or an inscription.
  • Independent attestation: Two sources report the same thing without one copying the other. Two copies of one source are one witness, not two.
  • Eyewitness: A person who saw an event first-hand. A writer who reports what others said is not an eyewitness.
  • Gospel: An early Christian account of the life, death and resurrection of Jesus. “Gospel” also means the good news they proclaim.
  • Synoptic Gospels: Matthew, Mark and Luke, which share much material and are read side by side.
  • Crucifixion: A Roman method of execution by fixing a person to a cross or stake.

The evidence

Jesus was handed over in Jerusalem, sentenced by the Roman governor Pilate and crucified on a Friday near Passover under a written charge of kingship.

Tacitus reports the execution under Pilate. St Paul knows that Jesus was handed over and crucified. All four Gospels agree on the Roman sentence, the inscription on the cross, and the day before the sabbath. And no movement would invent so shameful an end for the One it worshipped. [1] [2] [3]

Members of the Jerusalem priestly leadership took part in the arrest of Jesus and in handing Him to Pilate.

All four Gospels say so, and St John names Annas and Caiaphas. Josephus shows that priestly leaders in Jerusalem acted against men they thought dangerous, as with St James. A Roman governor at a crowded festival would rely on local leaders to identify someone they considered a threat. [4] [5] [1]

Before bringing Jesus to Pilate, the priestly leaders questioned Him, and each Gospel tells this hearing from its own angle.

St Mark and St Matthew tell of a night hearing and a morning decision, St Luke of a council at daybreak, and St John of questioning before Annas and then Caiaphas. They agree on the essential: the leaders questioned Jesus and then brought Him to the governor. The rabbinic rules sometimes cited against a night hearing were written down about a century and a half later, and cannot be used as a record of first-century practice. [4] [5] [6]

The release of Barabbas and the hearing before Herod Antipas, told in the Gospels, fit the setting of Judea under Pilate.

The Barabbas episode is in all four Gospels, and governors are known to have released prisoners to crowds on other occasions; the name itself is not the kind of detail that is easily invented. Herod Antipas ruled Galilee and was in Jerusalem for the feast, so sending a Galilean to him makes sense. Both scenes belong to the world in which the events took place. [7] [8] [9]

All four Gospels place the crucifixion on the Friday, the day before the sabbath, at the feast of Passover; St John presents it on the day of preparation for the Passover.

In St Mark, St Matthew and St Luke the Last Supper is a Passover meal and the Lord dies the next day. In St John the leaders have not yet eaten the Passover when Jesus stands before Pilate, so that Christ dies as the Passover lambs are being prepared. All four agree on the day of the week and the nearness of the feast, and the Church sees in both the truth that Christ is our Passover. [5] [10]

The historical case for the core is strong: the handing over, the Roman sentence, the charge of kingship and the crucifixion on a Friday at Passover. The Gospel narratives of the hours before fit the political world of Judea under Pilate and Caiaphas, and their variety shows several witnesses, not one invented script.

Responsibility for the death of Jesus cannot be laid on a whole people. The sentence was Roman, a part of the priestly leadership of Jerusalem took part in handing Him over, and Jesus, His disciples and the crowds who welcomed Him were Jews. No scene in the Gospels gives anyone the right to blame later generations.

In Scripture

1 Corinthians 11:23

King James Version

23 For I have received of the Lord that which also I delivered unto you, That the Lord Jesus the same night in which he was betrayed took bread:

Mark 15:25–26

King James Version

25 And it was the third hour, and they crucified him.

26 And the superscription of his accusation was written over, THE KING OF THE JEWS.

Mark 14:53–65

King James Version

53 ¶ And they led Jesus away to the high priest: and with him were assembled all the chief priests and the elders and the scribes.

54 And Peter followed him afar off, even into the palace of the high priest: and he sat with the servants, and warmed himself at the fire.

55 And the chief priests and all the council sought for witness against Jesus to put him to death; and found none.

56 For many bare false witness against him, but their witness agreed not together.

57 And there arose certain, and bare false witness against him, saying,

58 We heard him say, I will destroy this temple that is made with hands, and within three days I will build another made without hands.

59 But neither so did their witness agree together.

60 And the high priest stood up in the midst, and asked Jesus, saying, Answerest thou nothing? what is it which these witness against thee?

61 But he held his peace, and answered nothing. Again the high priest asked him, and said unto him, Art thou the Christ, the Son of the Blessed?

62 And Jesus said, I am: and ye shall see the Son of man sitting on the right hand of power, and coming in the clouds of heaven.

63 Then the high priest rent his clothes, and saith, What need we any further witnesses?

64 Ye have heard the blasphemy: what think ye? And they all condemned him to be guilty of death.

65 And some began to spit on him, and to cover his face, and to buffet him, and to say unto him, Prophesy: and the servants did strike him with the palms of their hands.

John 18:28–32

King James Version

28 ¶ Then led they Jesus from Caiaphas unto the hall of judgment: and it was early; and they themselves went not into the judgment hall, lest they should be defiled; but that they might eat the passover.

29 Pilate then went out unto them, and said, What accusation bring ye against this man?

30 They answered and said unto him, If he were not a malefactor, we would not have delivered him up unto thee.

31 Then said Pilate unto them, Take ye him, and judge him according to your law. The Jews therefore said unto him, It is not lawful for us to put any man to death:

32 That the saying of Jesus might be fulfilled, which he spake, signifying what death he should die.

Mark 15:6–15

King James Version

6 Now at that feast he released unto them one prisoner, whomsoever they desired.

7 And there was one named Barabbas, which lay bound with them that had made insurrection with him, who had committed murder in the insurrection.

8 And the multitude crying aloud began to desire him to do as he had ever done unto them.

9 But Pilate answered them, saying, Will ye that I release unto you the King of the Jews?

10 For he knew that the chief priests had delivered him for envy.

11 But the chief priests moved the people, that he should rather release Barabbas unto them.

12 And Pilate answered and said again unto them, What will ye then that I shall do unto him whom ye call the King of the Jews?

13 And they cried out again, Crucify him.

14 Then Pilate said unto them, Why, what evil hath he done? And they cried out the more exceedingly, Crucify him.

15 ¶ And so Pilate, willing to content the people, released Barabbas unto them, and delivered Jesus, when he had scourged him, to be crucified.

Luke 23:6–12

King James Version

6 When Pilate heard of Galilee, he asked whether the man were a Galilæan.

7 And as soon as he knew that he belonged unto Herod’s jurisdiction, he sent him to Herod, who himself also was at Jerusalem at that time.

8 ¶ And when Herod saw Jesus, he was exceeding glad: for he was desirous to see him of a long season, because he had heard many things of him; and he hoped to have seen some miracle done by him.

9 Then he questioned with him in many words; but he answered him nothing.

10 And the chief priests and scribes stood and vehemently accused him.

11 And Herod with his men of war set him at nought, and mocked him, and arrayed him in a gorgeous robe, and sent him again to Pilate.

12 ¶ And the same day Pilate and Herod were made friends together: for before they were at enmity between themselves.

Matthew 27:24–25

King James Version

24 ¶ When Pilate saw that he could prevail nothing, but that rather a tumult was made, he took water, and washed his hands before the multitude, saying, I am innocent of the blood of this just person: see ye to it.

25 Then answered all the people, and said, His blood be on us, and on our children.

John 19:14

King James Version

14 And it was the preparation of the passover, and about the sixth hour: and he saith unto the Jews, Behold your King!

What the Church teaches

The Church confesses that Christ was handed over and suffered willingly. The Gospels themselves show him foretelling the handing over and going to meet it, and the Church reads the trial scenes in that light: the one who is judged is the one who judges, and he accepts the sentence for our salvation. This confession does not depend on settling the disputed details above.

In Holy Week the Coptic Church reads the Gospel accounts of the arrest, the hearings and the trial on Thursday night and Good Friday, hour by hour, in the services of the Pascha. The Church receives all four Gospels as they stand and does not merge them into one script; each hour is read with the hymns and prayers that interpret it. The differences between the Gospels are therefore not hidden in the liturgy, and the focus of the Church's reading is the Lord's willing offering of himself.

Objections answered

Since none of the sources is an eyewitness account of the hearings, we should say we know nothing of the trial beyond the sentence.

Not having a named eyewitness for each scene is not the same as knowing nothing. Several details are told by more than one Gospel and fit what is known of Roman provincial rule: the handing over by local leaders, the question of kingship, and the written charge on the cross.

And the core rests on more than the Gospels: Tacitus, a Roman historian, and St Paul the Apostle, writing within a generation, support the same outline. We know a great deal about the trial and death of Jesus.

[1] [2] [3]

The Gospel trial before the council breaks the rules of Jewish procedure, so it must be a Christian invention to blame the Jewish authorities.

The rules cited in this argument come from the Mishnah, written down around AD 200, which describes an idealised procedure. They cannot be assumed to describe how the council led by the high priest worked in Jesus’ day. And the Gospels do not all describe a full formal trial: St Luke and St John describe a questioning that prepared the case for Pilate.

So the argument fails. A hearing that does not match rules written a century and a half later is no proof of invention. And the Gospels do not blame the Jewish people: Jesus, His disciples and the crowds who welcomed Him were themselves Jews.

[4] [6]

The disagreements between the Gospels about the trial show that none of them can be trusted on the death of Jesus.

Differences of detail within an agreed outline are normal when several writers report the same events, and they do not overturn the outline. The four Gospels agree on the handing over in Jerusalem, the Roman sentence, the charge of kingship and the Friday crucifixion, and a Roman historian and St Paul independently confirm the same outline.

The differences actually strengthen the witness. They show that the evangelists did not smooth their accounts into one, and that the core they share was received, not invented.

[1] [2] [3] [10]

Conclusion

The outline of the trial and crucifixion is firmly established: Jesus was handed over in Jerusalem, sentenced by Pilate, and crucified under the charge of kingship on a Friday at Passover. The Gospels tell the hours before from four angles, as real witnesses do, and their accounts fit the world of the time. The Church reads them as the story of the Lord who was judged by men and who freely offered Himself for the life of the world.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close