Orthodoxia

Faith & Evidence / God’s existence and knowledge

What are the selection-effect and multiverse objections?

AdvancedPhilosophicalScientificAnswer available

Revision 1, updated

The answer

No, neither reply removes the case for a Creator. The selection effect is true as far as it goes: no one could observe a universe where observers are impossible. But it explains only why we see these conditions, not why such conditions exist at all. A man who survives a firing squad of expert marksmen cannot explain his survival by saying he would not be there to notice otherwise. The multiverse is a bold hypothesis, but no other universe has been observed, and any machinery that produces universes would itself need the right laws and order. The question returns: why is there an ordered reality at all? The Church confesses that God made all things, visible and invisible, and that faith stands whether there is one universe or many.

  • The selection effect is correct as far as it goes: observers can only observe observer-permitting conditions. It explains what we see, not why such conditions are there.
  • The firing-squad illustration: surviving a squad of marksmen is not explained by saying “you could only observe it if you survived.” The survivor rightly asks why they all missed.
  • The multiverse says there are very many universes with varied constants, so a life-permitting one is expected somewhere. No other universe has been observed.
  • A universe-generating mechanism would itself need fitting laws, so the question of order moves back a step instead of disappearing.
  • God is the Creator of all things, whether one universe or many. Nothing in the Creed or the Fathers depends on the number.

Why this question matters

These two replies are the ones a thoughtful sceptic is most likely to raise against the fine-tuning argument. A believer should neither wave them away nor be shaken by them, but understand them and answer them well.

They also show a pattern worth recognising. A modest point (we can only observe what permits observers) is sometimes made to carry more than it can bear, and a large hypothesis (a multiverse) is sometimes offered as if it were an observation. Seeing this clearly lets the reader keep the real question in view.

The selection effect, often discussed under the name anthropic reasoning, observes that any observer will find conditions that permit observers. That is a truth of logic, as when a fish in a net sample of a lake can tell us nothing about fish smaller than the mesh. In the philosopher John Leslie’s firing-squad image, a man who is faced by a squad of marksmen and finds himself alive after they fire cannot explain it by saying that he could not be there to notice if he were dead. The fact that he is alive is certain, and it still calls for an explanation.

The multiverse is the proposal that our universe is one of a vast number, with differing constants or laws. Some versions arise from theories of cosmic inflation, in which new regions of space keep forming, and some from string theory, which in some forms allows an enormous number of possible low-energy physical settings. Physicists differ about whether these theories, which are not themselves established, really give rise to a multiverse, and whether the proposal can be tested. The philosopher Ian Hacking pointed out a related error, the “inverse gambler’s fallacy”: the fact that there are many universes does not by itself raise the chance that this particular one has the features it does, though it raises the chance that some universe does.

The two replies are different. The selection effect needs no extra universes, and it addresses only our observing. The multiverse adds universes and, with the selection effect, aims to remove the surprise. The question for the fine-tuning argument is whether this works, or whether it only relocates the question to the machinery that makes universes.

Terms used

  • Apologetics: The reasoned defence and explanation of a belief. It offers arguments and evidence for examination; it does not replace faith or guarantee agreement.
  • Theism: The view that there is one personal God who made and sustains the world.
  • Cosmological argument: An argument from the existence or beginning of the universe to a cause or explanation beyond it.
  • Fine-tuning: The observation that some physical constants fall in a narrow range compatible with life, and the debate over what that implies.
  • Tradition: In the Orthodox understanding, the Church’s lived and handed-on faith, within which Scripture is read.

The evidence

Observers can only observe conditions that permit observers; this explains why we find such conditions, but not why they exist.

This is a point of logic about observation, and a Christian accepts it gladly. But it concerns our observing, not the universe itself. The survivor of the firing squad knows he could only notice his survival if he survived, and he is still right to ask why the marksmen missed. [1] [2]

A multiverse is a hypothesis taken seriously by some physicists, but no other universe has been observed, the theories behind it are themselves unproven, and whether it can be tested is in question.

Some versions arise from theories of cosmic inflation or string theory, which physicists develop for other reasons. But other universes would lie beyond observation, so evidence for them could only ever be indirect. A hypothesis of this kind cannot be presented as a finding. [1]

Even if a multiverse exists, the question of order does not disappear: there is still the question why there is a universe-generating process of that kind at all.

A mechanism that produces many universes with varied constants must itself have laws that allow it to do so. Those laws are part of the order to be explained. The multiverse moves the question back a step; it does not answer it. And the philosopher Ian Hacking pointed out that many universes do not raise the chance that this particular universe has the features it has. [1] [3]

Christian faith in creation does not depend on there being one universe or many.

The Creed and the Fathers confess that God made all things, visible and invisible, and that all things hold together in the Word. Whatever exists, and however much of it there is, depends on Him. [4] [5]

These replies, and the argument they answer, concern philosophy and physics, not history. They do not rest on an event, a text or a witness, so the historical case for the faith is made elsewhere, above all in the articles on the resurrection.

In Scripture

Colossians 1:16–17

King James Version

16 For by him were all things created, that are in heaven, and that are in earth, visible and invisible, whether they be thrones, or dominions, or principalities, or powers: all things were created by him, and for him:

17 And he is before all things, and by him all things consist.

What the Church teaches

A Christian can accept the selection effect without difficulty, because it is a correct logical point. A Christian can also accept the physics of a multiverse, if it is ever established, without any change in faith, since the Church’s confession is that God made all things, whatever they are and however many there are.

What a Christian cannot do, with integrity, is claim that the multiverse has been refuted, or that science has shown that no Creator is needed. Neither the physics nor the philosophy has reached either result. Our knowledge of God does not come from this debate. It comes from what the Church receives as His revelation in Christ.

The Coptic Orthodox Church has no teaching about how many universes there are. Its teaching is that God, the Holy Trinity, is the Creator of all things visible and invisible, and the Church prays in the Creed in those words every day. The Fathers of Alexandria stressed that creation has a beginning in God’s will and no existence of its own apart from Him. That teaching is untouched by the question of one universe or many.

A believer who studies cosmology is not asked to take a side in these debates in order to be faithful. The Church’s concern is that creation is not divinised and not despised, and that science is pursued with honesty.

Objections answered

We would exist only in a universe that permits us, so being in one is exactly what we should expect, and it needs no further explanation. The question “why is it so?” is like asking why a puddle fits the hole it lies in.

The selection effect explains why we observe life-permitting conditions: we could observe nothing else. But it does not explain why such conditions exist at all. That is a different question, and it remains.

The puddle fits its hole because water flows to fill whatever shape is there. But the laws and constants of the universe did not shape themselves around us; they had to be such that life could arise in the first place. Like the survivor of the firing squad, we are right to ask why.

[1]

If there are enough universes with varied constants, a life-permitting one is bound to exist. This is a straightforward explanation of fine-tuning and does not require a mind.

A multiverse has not been observed, so it cannot claim to be the explanation the evidence demands. And any mechanism that produces universes with different constants must itself have a form and laws that allow it, which brings the question of order back again.

Moreover, as the inverse gambler’s fallacy shows, many universes do not make this one more likely to have the features it has. The multiverse does not remove the need for an explanation of order; it pushes it further back, to the place where the Christian has always placed it: in the Creator of all things.

[2]

Postulating a multiverse is no more extravagant than postulating God. Both are unobserved, and one at least comes from physics.

God and a multiverse are not rivals in the way this objection assumes. A multiverse, if it exists, would itself need a reason for its existence, and God could have created one universe or many. The real question is why there is anything at all, and why it is ordered, and a physical hypothesis cannot answer that, because it is part of what needs explaining.

The Church does not know God by the method of physics, nor does she argue for Him from gaps in a theory. God is the ground of all that exists, and He has made Himself known in Christ.

Conclusion

The selection effect is correct but answers only why we observe these conditions, not why they exist. The multiverse is an unobserved hypothesis, and any machinery that makes universes would itself need explaining. Neither removes the question of why there is an ordered universe at all, and neither removes the case for a Creator. The Church confesses God, the Maker of all things visible and invisible, whether there is one universe or many.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close