Orthodoxia

Faith & Evidence / God’s existence and knowledge

What would count as evidence for or against God?

IntroductoryPhilosophicalAnswer available

Revision 1, updated

The answer

Yes, there is real evidence for God, though not of the laboratory kind. God is not an object inside the world for an instrument to register; He is its Creator. The evidence is of the kind we use for every large question: that there is a universe at all, that it has an order our minds can understand, that we have conscience and minds, that people meet God in prayer, and that God has acted in history in Jesus Christ. Suffering, the hiddenness of God and the reach of science are real questions, and each has a serious answer. Taken together, the evidence points to God.

  • Evidence means what is more expected if a claim is true than if it is false. It does not have to be a laboratory measurement.
  • The Creator of the universe is not a thing inside it, so the lack of a direct measurement is no more surprising than the lack of one for the laws of logic.
  • The existence and order of the universe, conscience, the mind, the experience of God and the history of Christ all point to God.
  • Suffering, the hiddenness of God, the variety of religions and the success of science are real questions, and each has a serious Christian answer.
  • The Christian faith names what would count against it: St Paul says that if Christ is not risen, faith is empty. It stakes itself on events that can be examined.
  • Faith for the Christian is more than the conclusion of an argument, but it is never cut off from reasons.

Why this question matters

Many conversations about God stall because the two sides hold different standards and never say so. One person expects God to show up the way a planet does; another treats any appeal to reasoning as an evasion. Naming the right standard lets the evidence be seen for what it is.

Saying there is “no evidence” for God usually means only that there is no laboratory measurement of Him. Once we look at the kinds of evidence that fit the question, the case for God is strong.

In ordinary life we accept many things on evidence that is not an experiment: that other people have minds, that the past happened, that some acts are cruel. In each case we ask what would be expected if the claim were true and compare it with what would be expected if it were false. The same question can be put about God. A creator who made the universe freely, and who is good, would be expected to leave some marks, and one who did not would be expected to leave others.

Christian Scripture itself speaks of a witness in creation. Read as an ancient document, a psalm says that the heavens tell of God’s glory (Psalm 19:1–4), and St Paul the Apostle argues in Romans that God’s power and divinity can be perceived in what he made (Romans 1:19–20).

The philosophical literature sorts the considerations into groups. Arguments from the existence and order of the universe, from conscious minds and from moral conviction are given for belief. Religious experience and the history of the claim that God has acted in Christ are also given. Against belief, philosophers point to the problem of evil (S42), to divine hiddenness, the fact that some sincere seekers do not find God (S43), and to the competing claims of different religions (S46). The relation of scientific method to religious questions is a further background issue (S45).

Richard Swinburne's works are a well-known attempt to treat the question as a cumulative judgement of probability, weighing every consideration together (S38 for a general reader, S39 for the full case). They are cited here only as whole works for their overall approach, because only the publisher pages have been consulted.

Terms used

  • Apologetics: The reasoned defence and explanation of a belief. It offers arguments and evidence for examination; it does not replace faith or guarantee agreement.
  • Theism: The view that there is one personal God who made and sustains the world.
  • Cosmological argument: An argument from the existence or beginning of the universe to a cause or explanation beyond it.
  • Fine-tuning: The observation that some physical constants fall in a narrow range compatible with life, and the debate over what that implies.
  • Theodicy: An attempt to explain why a good God permits evil and suffering.
  • Divine hiddenness: The question why a loving God is not more evident to people who sincerely seek him.

The evidence

Evidence for a claim is what is more to be expected if the claim is true than if it is false, and this standard applies to the question of God as it does to other large questions, even though the evidence is not experimental.

This is the account of evidence used in the philosophy of science and of religion. It is the same standard by which we believe that other minds exist and that the past happened. [5]

The evidence for God is of several distinct kinds (about the universe, about minds and morality, about experience, about history), and the Bible itself points to them and invites examination.

A psalm says that the heavens tell of God's glory, and St Paul the Apostle teaches that God's power and divinity can be seen in what He made. The faith itself sends us to creation as a witness to its Creator. [1] [2]

The considerations raised against belief, suffering, the hiddenness of God, the diversity of religions and the success of natural explanations, are serious, and each has a serious answer.

These are the points most often raised by thoughtful non-believers, and they deserve respect. Christian thinkers have answered each of them, and other articles on this site set out those answers. [3] [4]

One part of the case is historical and open to anyone: Jesus of Nazareth lived, was crucified under Pontius Pilate, and His first followers proclaimed that He had risen. Other articles examine the sources for each of these. If Christ is risen, God has acted in history, and the question of God is answered in a Person.

In Scripture

Psalms 19:1–4

King James Version

1 The heavens declare the glory of God; and the firmament sheweth his handywork.

2 Day unto day uttereth speech, and night unto night sheweth knowledge.

3 There is no speech nor language, where their voice is not heard.

4 Their line is gone out through all the earth, and their words to the end of the world. In them hath he set a tabernacle for the sun,

Romans 1:19–20

King James Version

19 Because that which may be known of God is manifest in them; for God hath shewed it unto them.

20 For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his eternal power and Godhead; so that they are without excuse:

What the Church teaches

The Church holds that God is known not only as a conclusion but as one who meets us: in creation, in the Scriptures, in Christ, and in the sacraments and prayer. Reasons clear the way and answer honest questions, while faith is a trust given in response to God and made possible by His grace.

The Coptic Orthodox Church does not teach that belief begins with a proof. Worship, the reading of Scripture, the lives of the saints and the sacraments are, in her teaching, the ordinary place where God is known. She has also always had teachers who explained and defended the faith to those outside: the school of Alexandria is the historic example. Both belong together. The believer lives the faith in prayer and can give a reasoned account of it when asked.

Objections answered

The burden of proof is on the person who makes the claim. Believers cannot point to evidence of the kind we accept for other claims, so the reasonable position is to withhold belief until they can.

The standard assumed here is itself a philosophical position, and it is not the standard we use for many things we reasonably believe, such as that other minds exist. The right question is which explanation of the whole of experience is best, and on that ground belief and disbelief both make claims that need support.

Disbelief is not a neutral starting point. To say there is no God is also a claim about the whole of reality, and it must explain why there is a universe, why it is ordered, and why we have minds and conscience. Belief in God explains these well.

[5]

Believers treat every outcome as fitting their view: a prayer answered shows God’s care, a prayer unanswered shows his wisdom. If nothing could count against it, the belief explains nothing.

Christian teaching does name things that would count against it. St Paul the Apostle writes that if Christ has not been raised, the faith is empty (1 Corinthians 15:14–17). The Church's claim is tied to events that historians can examine, and other articles on this site examine them.

Unanswered prayer is not a hidden escape route. Christ Himself prayed that the cup might pass and then accepted the Father's will. The Christian trusts a Father who answers as a Father, and that trust rests on what God has shown in Christ.

[3] [4]

Where science once pointed to God (lightning, disease, the origin of species) it has later offered natural explanations. The trend suggests that gaps remaining will also close, so the sensible expectation is that there is no God.

The Christian faith does not rest on gaps. The Fathers spoke of God as the ground of the whole order of nature, and the argument from the existence of an ordered universe does not depend on any unexplained detail. Better scientific explanation of how nature works does not answer why there is a nature at all.

Every scientific explanation assumes an ordered world and minds able to understand it. Science explains how the order works; it cannot explain why the order exists. That is the question God answers.

Conclusion

Evidence about God is not laboratory evidence, but it is real and strong: the existence and order of the universe, conscience and mind, the experience of God, and above all the history of Jesus Christ. The questions raised against belief deserve care, and they have answers. The Christian welcomes honest inquiry, since Scripture itself sends us to creation and to the witnesses of Christ.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close