Faith & Evidence / God’s existence and knowledge
Do consciousness, reason or moral experience support theism?
The answer
Three things we all live by point beyond mindless matter: there is something it is like to be a person, our reasoning can grasp truth, and some things, such as cruelty for its own sake, are really wrong. A world that began from mindless matter gives no reason to expect any of these. A world created by a living, reasoning and good God leads us to expect all three. The Church teaches why: human beings are made in the image of God, given reason and a conscience by the Word through whom all things were made. These arguments do not by themselves reveal the Trinity, but they show that the world looks like the work of a Mind, and they open the door to the God who made Himself known in Christ.
- Consciousness: a full description of brain processes still does not say what an experience is like (the “hard problem”). If the world comes from a Mind, minds in it are exactly what we should expect.
- Reason: if our beliefs were shaped only for survival, we would have no ground to trust them in philosophy and science. If our reason is a gift from the Word, our trust in it makes sense.
- Morality: some acts are wrong whatever anyone thinks. God, who is Himself the good, is the firmest ground for such truths, and the Euthyphro question dissolves once this is seen.
- These arguments point to a Mind and a source of goodness behind the world. The fullness of who God is, Father, Son and Holy Spirit, is known through His revelation in Christ.
- The Church teaches that human beings are made in God’s image, with reason and a conscience. The arguments show why that teaching fits the world we know from the inside.
Why this question matters
Arguments from consciousness, reason and morality start from what we know from the inside. No one needs to study physics to know that they experience, that they are trying to reason well, and that some things truly matter. That is why these arguments stand so close to ordinary life.
They also show that the deepest features of our own lives are not accidents. Seen clearly, they lead from the experience every person shares toward the God who made us in His image.
The argument from consciousness. A scientist can describe what the brain does when a person sees red, but it seems a further question why there is any experience of red at all. The philosopher David Chalmers called this the “hard problem” of consciousness in the 1990s, and the term is now in wide use. Some philosophers conclude that consciousness is a basic feature of reality that physics does not capture. A theistic version of the argument says that if the universe began from a mind, the existence of minds in it is just what we would expect, while if it began from mindless matter it is surprising. Others who accept the problem look for answers in physical, functional or “panpsychist” accounts, none of which involves God.
The argument from reason. If our mental states are caused by physical processes that were selected for survival and not for truth, then, the argument goes, we have reason to doubt that our beliefs, including this belief itself, are reliable. Alvin Plantinga developed a well-known form of this argument, and C. S. Lewis offered an earlier and simpler version. Some object that natural selection favours accurate perception, since false beliefs about food and danger are costly. But selection rewards behaviour that keeps us alive, not true belief as such, and it does not explain why we should trust our reasoning about mathematics, philosophy or God; that trust makes best sense if our minds come from the wise Creator who made them to know the truth.
The moral argument. Most people hold that some things, such as torturing a child for fun, are wrong regardless of anyone’s opinion. Moral realism is the view that there are such objective moral facts. The theist argues that God’s nature is the best ground for them, while a non-theist can reply that moral facts are basic, or that they are grounded in the nature of persons and their well-being, or that realism is false. The Euthyphro question, from Plato, asks whether something is good because God commands it or whether God commands it because it is good. Theists such as the Fathers answer that God is Himself the good, so the question is a false dilemma.
Terms used
- Apologetics: The reasoned defence and explanation of a belief. It offers arguments and evidence for examination; it does not replace faith or guarantee agreement.
- Theism: The view that there is one personal God who made and sustains the world.
- Christology: Teaching about who Christ is, especially how divinity and humanity are united in him.
- Tradition: In the Orthodox understanding, the Church’s lived and handed-on faith, within which Scripture is read.
- Inspiration: The Christian belief that God worked through the human authors of Scripture. It is a theological claim, distinct from the preservation of manuscripts.
The evidence
Conscious experience cannot be accounted for by a description of physical processes alone, and this “hard problem” is recognised even by philosophers who are not theists.
Describing what the brain does, however fully, still leaves the question why there is any experience at all. That the difficulty is recognised across the philosophical spectrum shows it is real, not a theist’s invention. [1]
Because a Mind lies behind the world, the existence of reasoning minds that can know the world and grasp moral truths is what we should expect; on a view in which everything comes from mindless matter it is a surprise.
The question is which account makes these facts at home in the world. Mind from Mind, reason from Reason and goodness from the Good fit naturally; mind, reason and goodness from what has none of them do not. [1] [2]
Human beings are made in the image of God, with reason, will and conscience, and this is why people can know something of the good and the true.
This is what Scripture and the Fathers teach about the human person, and it gives the reason behind the facts the arguments point to: we can know because we were made by the One who knows. [3] [4] [5]
These arguments rest on features of human life that every person can examine, not on an event, a text or a witness, so their strength lies in reflection rather than in historical sources.
In Scripture
Genesis 1:26–27
King James Version
26 ¶ And God said, Let us make man in our image, after our likeness: and let them have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the fowl of the air, and over the cattle, and over all the earth, and over every creeping thing that creepeth upon the earth.
27 So God created man in his own image, in the image of God created he him; male and female created he them.
Romans 2:14–15
King James Version
14 For when the Gentiles, which have not the law, do by nature the things contained in the law, these, having not the law, are a law unto themselves:
15 Which shew the work of the law written in their hearts, their conscience also bearing witness, and their thoughts the mean while accusing or else excusing one another;)
What the Church teaches
These facts are what one would expect if human beings are made in God’s image, and reason and conscience are gifts and not accidents. Faith is not reached by argument alone, but these arguments clear the way and show that faith is reasonable.
The Church’s own teaching is not an inference from consciousness, reason or morality. It begins with God’s revelation: the Word through whom all things were made became man, and the Spirit leads people into truth. The philosophical arguments are one way to explore whether the world looks like the work of a mind. They do not replace faith.
The Coptic Orthodox understanding of the human person is rooted in the Fathers of Alexandria. For St Athanasius, human beings are rational because they share in the Word, and the image of God in them is damaged by sin and restored in Christ. Reason is therefore not set against faith in this tradition. Reason is a gift to be healed and used in the service of God.
This is the Church’s teaching on the human person. It is not presented as a proof of God’s existence for someone who does not already share the faith.
Objections answered
Consciousness is produced by the brain, and neuroscience is advancing steadily. The history of science shows that features once thought to need a non-physical explanation (life, for example) turned out not to need one. The hard problem is a gap in knowledge, and to fill it with God is to repeat that error.
The brain’s role in consciousness is not in question: brain states and experience are closely linked. But a link is not an explanation. The hard question is why any physical process should be accompanied by experience at all.
The comparison with life does not hold. Life was explained by describing structure and function, and that is exactly what does not reach experience itself. Pointing to future science is a promise, not an answer. The argument does not fill a gap with God; it asks what kind of reality makes minds possible, and a Mind behind the world answers that directly.
Evolution accounts for our reasoning. Beliefs that track the world helped our ancestors survive, so we have reason to trust our faculties in everyday matters. The argument from reason assumes without justification that a naturalistic origin makes belief unreliable.
Reliable perception does help survival, but survival can be served by beliefs that are useful without being true. On a purely naturalistic origin, then, our trust in abstract reasoning about philosophy and science has no firm footing.
The argument does not undermine reason; it asks what grounds it. If our minds were made by the Word, the Reason of God, our trust in reason is well founded. That is why the theist can trust reason and the naturalist must borrow that trust.
Our moral sense is explained by evolution and culture. Feelings of care, fairness and disgust helped groups cooperate. If they have this origin, they do not track objective truths, so there is nothing for God to ground (the evolutionary debunking argument).
An account of how a belief arose does not show it false. Applied generally, the debunking argument would undermine moral knowledge of every kind, including the judgement that cruelty is wrong, which almost no one is willing to give up.
If God, who wills the good, stands behind the process that formed us, then our grasp of moral truth is not an accident. Our moral sense matches moral reality because both come from the same good Creator.
The Euthyphro question is still a problem. If what is good is whatever God commands, morality is arbitrary. If God commands it because it is good, then goodness is independent of God, and the moral argument fails.
Following the Fathers, the Church answers that the dilemma is false. God is not a ruler who issues commands from outside goodness. He is Himself the good, and His commands express His character, which is neither arbitrary nor something other than Himself.
Every account of reality ends somewhere. To ask what makes God good is to ask what makes goodness good. The Christian answer is that goodness is not a rule above God but the very life of God.
People who believe in God can be cruel, and many non-believers live admirable moral lives. Morality does not need religion, so the argument must be wrong.
The observation is true, and it agrees with the argument. St Paul the Apostle teaches that conscience gives knowledge of right and wrong to everyone, believer or not. The argument is not about who behaves better but about what grounds moral truth, and good lives among non-believers are themselves a witness to the law God wrote on every heart.
Conclusion
Consciousness, reason and moral experience show that the world is not, at its root, mindless matter. They are what we should expect if we are made by a living God who is Reason and Goodness itself, and they fit poorly with any other account. The Church gives their true name: we bear the image of God, and the Word who gave us reason became man to heal and restore that image. The arguments open the door; faith, received in the Church and lived in worship, walks through it.
Sources
- The Existence of God · Richard Swinburne
- Is There a God? · Richard Swinburne
- Genesis 1:26–27
- Romans 2:14–15
- On the Incarnation · Athanasius of Alexandria · On the Incarnation, ch. 3
No inbox has been set up yet, so nothing is sent. This copies a short report with the page address and revision for you to pass on.