Orthodoxia

Faith & Evidence / God’s character, relevance, evil and hiddenness

Why does God seem hidden or allow suffering?

IntermediatePhilosophicalAnswer available

Revision 1, updated

The answer

God is neither absent nor indifferent. The claim that a good God and evil cannot both exist does not hold: a good God can have good reasons to create free creatures who can love, and who can therefore also do wrong. The deeper answer is Christ Himself. In Him God entered our suffering, wept at the grave of a friend, was betrayed and died on the cross, and rose again, so that death and pain do not have the last word. God is not hidden from those who seek Him; He draws near with respect for our freedom, inviting rather than overpowering. We do not always know why a particular sorrow comes, but we know who is with us in it, and what He has promised.

  • The logical argument fails: “God and evil are contradictory” needs extra premises, such as that a good God must remove every evil at once, and these can rightly be denied.
  • Free will explains why a world of real love also allows real wrongdoing.
  • Natural suffering, and the suffering of children and animals, are met by the stability of the created order, the limits of our knowledge of God’s purposes, and the hope of resurrection.
  • God does not force Himself on anyone. He seeks a relationship of freedom and trust, and He makes Himself known to those who seek Him.
  • A person in pain needs presence, prayer and help first; arguments come later.
  • In the cross, God shared our suffering; in the resurrection, He overcame death. This is the Christian hope.

Why this question matters

For many people this begins not as a puzzle but as a loss, an illness, a prayer that seemed unanswered, or a long silence. No one’s pain is merely an example, and honest questions are not a fault. They deserve a serious and loving answer.

Two questions are often mixed. One asks whether suffering makes belief in God unreasonable. The other asks how to keep trusting God while suffering. Both have answers, but they are given differently: the first with reasons, the second above all with presence and prayer.

The logical problem of evil argues that it is contradictory to say that God is all-powerful and entirely good and also that evil exists. The evidential problem makes a weaker claim: that the kinds and amounts of evil, especially evils that seem pointless, make it less likely that such a God exists than that none does. The reference entry used here (S42) sets out both forms and the main responses.

The best-known reply to the logical problem is the free-will defence, developed by Alvin Plantinga (S40, cited as a whole work). Its core idea is that God might have a good reason for creating beings who are free to do wrong, since a world with free, morally responsible creatures can be more valuable than one without them, and that this shows there is no contradiction. The defence is usually taken to be about moral evil, that is, harm done by free agents. Natural evil (earthquakes, disease), and the suffering of children and of animals, are not obviously accounted for by it, and defenders add further considerations such as the value of a stable natural order.

The argument from divine hiddenness (S43) asks a different question: if God desires a relationship with every person, why are there people who seek sincerely and do not find him, or who are unable to believe? It is a distinct argument from the problem of evil, though they are often combined.

Terms used

  • Resurrection: In Christian teaching, Jesus’ bodily rising from the dead to a transformed life. It is a different claim from the claim that his followers came to believe it.
  • Crucifixion: A Roman method of execution by fixing a person to a cross or stake.
  • Theism: The view that there is one personal God who made and sustains the world.
  • Theodicy: An attempt to explain why a good God permits evil and suffering.
  • Divine hiddenness: The question why a loving God is not more evident to people who sincerely seek him.

The evidence

The logical argument, that God and evil are contradictory, fails, because it depends on premises (for example that a good God would remove every evil He could) that can rightly be denied.

The free-will defence, set out by Alvin Plantinga, shows that God and evil can exist together: a world with free creatures who can truly love is worth more than a world without them, even though freedom can be misused. That is enough to remove the charge of contradiction. [1] [2]

The evidential problem, that the kind and amount of suffering count against God, is met by several considerations together, completed by the Christian hope of resurrection.

A stable natural order, in which creatures can learn, act and love, carries the possibility of harm. Suffering borne in faith can form character. We are not in a position to say that any evil serves no purpose in God’s providence. And the resurrection promises that no suffering is wasted or final. Suffering must also be weighed against the positive reasons for belief in God. [1]

Divine hiddenness is best understood through the kind of relationship God seeks: one of freedom and trust, which cannot be forced.

A relationship with God requires freedom and cannot be compelled. God seeks more than intellectual agreement; He seeks love and trust. Knowledge of God is more widespread than it appears. And we cannot assume we know what God’s clearest self-disclosure should look like; Christians believe He gave it in Christ. [3]

Christianity answers suffering with God’s own presence in it: God entered human suffering in the cross of Christ, and in His resurrection death is overcome.

The Gospel of John shows Jesus weeping at the death of His friend Lazarus, and the letter to the Hebrews describes Him as one who shares our weakness and was tested as we are. The one who suffers is not met by a God who has never known suffering. [4]

This question is not mainly about the past, but it rests on a historical fact: Jesus of Nazareth was crucified, and His first followers proclaimed that He had risen. The Gospels show Him sharing human sorrow, weeping at a friend’s grave and suffering on the cross. Other articles set out the historical evidence for these events.

In Scripture

John 11:33–35

King James Version

33 When Jesus therefore saw her weeping, and the Jews also weeping which came with her, he groaned in the spirit, and was troubled,

34 And said, Where have ye laid him? They said unto him, Lord, come and see.

35 Jesus wept.

What the Church teaches

Christian faith does not claim to know why each instance of suffering occurs. It claims that God is not distant from it. In Christ, God became human, was weary, wept, was betrayed and died, so that a person who suffers is not met by a God who has never known suffering. In Orthodox understanding, the cross is also the way in which death is overcome, and so the Church confesses the resurrection as the final word, a hope for the dead and the grieving.

This is the faith of the Church. It answers the question of where God is and what hope there is, for those who share the faith, and it is offered as a witness to those who do not. No one is asked to stop asking their questions before they may come near.

In the Coptic Orthodox tradition the response to suffering is lived in worship before it is explained. The Church’s prayers, the liturgy and the commemoration of the saints and martyrs speak of suffering as something Christ shared and overcame, and the Church’s hope is stated in the resurrection and the life of the age to come. The Coptic Church also has a long memory of persecution, and its martyrs are remembered in its calendar and prayers.

This is how the Church understands and prays through suffering. It does not replace the pastoral care of a priest or a father of confession, which every person in pain is warmly invited to seek.

Objections answered

Even if there is no strict contradiction, the sheer amount of suffering, especially of children and animals, and the many evils that seem to serve no purpose, is exactly what we would expect if there is no God who cares. The free-will defence says nothing about an earthquake or a child’s cancer.

Free will is mainly an answer to moral evil, and Christians answer natural suffering in further ways. A world with stable natural laws, in which creatures can learn, act and love, carries the possibility of harm. We are in no position to declare that any evil serves no purpose in God’s providence. And the resurrection promises a restoration in which suffering is not the last word.

For a child’s cancer, the Christian answer is not a formula. It is that God is with that child, that Christ Himself took up suffering and death, and that He will dry every tear. Death does not get the final word over any of His little ones.

[1]

If God wanted a relationship with me, it would be easy for him to make himself known. A loving parent does not hide from a child. Sincere seekers who never find him are evidence that there is no such God, or none who cares.

The relationship God seeks is one of freedom, trust and love. Overwhelming proof would compel rather than invite. God is known in ways that are not only intellectual: in prayer, in conscience, in the love of others and in the life of the Church. Even the saints describe seasons of silence, and they speak of them as times when God was still near.

God has not hidden Himself. He has come close in Christ, and He promises that those who seek Him will find Him. No one can judge another person’s journey, and the door stays open to every seeker.

[3]

Pointing to the cross and to resurrection does not answer the question. It only restates the Christian story. An outsider asks why a good God allowed the suffering in the first place, and a believer in pain may find talk of meaning insulting.

The cross is not a story told to avoid the question. It is God’s own answer, given not in words but in His presence. The one who asks “where is God?” is shown God on the cross, sharing the worst of human pain, and then risen, opening the way through death.

For a person in pain, the first response is not an argument. Presence, listening, prayer and practical help come first, and anger or lament is not a failure of faith; the Psalms are full of it.

Conclusion

Suffering does not disprove God. The charge of contradiction fails, and the weight of suffering is met by the goods of freedom and a stable creation and by the hope of resurrection. Above all, God has not stayed distant: in Christ He entered our suffering and overcame death. The one who suffers needs presence before argument, and in Christ God gives exactly that.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close