Faith & Evidence / God’s character, relevance, evil and hiddenness
Does freedom explain all suffering?
The answer
Freedom explains a great deal, and the Church's faith completes the answer. God made human beings free because love, justice and courage cannot be forced, and much suffering comes from the misuse of that gift. This shows that God and evil are not contradictory. Suffering with no human chooser behind it, such as disease and disaster, belongs to a creation wounded by the fall and awaiting renewal. And God has not stood apart from any of it: in Christ He entered suffering Himself, bore it on the cross, and will raise the dead and wipe away every tear.
- A world of free, responsible creatures who can love is better than a world of creatures who cannot, even though freedom can be abused.
- The free-will defence answers the charge that God and evil cannot coexist, and it answers it successfully.
- Natural suffering is part of a creation wounded by the fall, which God has promised to renew.
- God does not abandon the victims of evil: He judges every wrong, stands with the sufferer in the cross of Christ, and gives the final word to the resurrection.
- In Orthodox teaching, freedom is not only the power to choose but the capacity to grow into the good, which God never overrides.
Why this question matters
Free will is often the first thing believers say about suffering. Said quickly, it can sound like a way of closing the discussion. Understood rightly, it is a serious answer with a clear place within the Christian faith, and it helps to see that place clearly.
It also matters to a person in pain. Freedom explains what was done to someone by another; it is not a word to say to the sick. To them the Church speaks of the fallen creation, of Christ who suffered with us, and of the resurrection.
The free-will defence, as Alvin Plantinga developed it (S40, cited as a whole work), argues that it is possible that God could not have created a world with as much moral good as this one without creating beings free to do wrong, and that some of them would use their freedom badly. If that is possible, the claim that God and evil are logically incompatible fails. The Stanford Encyclopedia entry (S42) sets out the defence, the debate about it and its limits.
The defence is often criticised on three lines. First, it does not cover natural evil. Second, it can seem to prove too little: a being who is free to commit atrocity gains little if the atrocity is allowed to happen to others who are also free. Third, there is a puzzle about what freedom is. If it requires the possibility of doing evil, then God is not free, for God cannot do evil, and the saints in heaven would not be free either. But freedom, rightly understood, is the ability to act for good from one’s own character, which grows through choices made over time; in this sense God is perfectly free, and the saints, confirmed in the good, are truly free.
Terms used
- Resurrection: In Christian teaching, Jesus’ bodily rising from the dead to a transformed life. It is a different claim from the claim that his followers came to believe it.
- Crucifixion: A Roman method of execution by fixing a person to a cross or stake.
- Theism: The view that there is one personal God who made and sustains the world.
- Theodicy: An attempt to explain why a good God permits evil and suffering.
- Inspiration: The Christian belief that God worked through the human authors of Scripture. It is a theological claim, distinct from the preservation of manuscripts.
The evidence
The free-will defence shows that God and evil are not logically contradictory.
Plantinga's work sets out the defence, and the reference entry reports that the logical argument against God is now widely regarded as not established. If God could not create beings free to love without also making them free to do wrong, then the existence of evil does not contradict the existence of a good God. [1] [2]
Freedom answers moral evil; the fall of creation, the cross and the resurrection complete the Christian answer to suffering.
Christian thinkers who use the defence place it within a larger account: a creation wounded by the fall, a God who enters suffering in Christ, and the promised renewal of all things. The reference entry discusses how the defence is extended in these ways. [2]
The Scriptures present human beings as truly responsible for their choices and God as not the author of evil, and they do not read every suffering as the result of a sinful choice by the sufferer.
Sirach and St James affirm human responsibility and deny that God is the source of evil. Evil comes from the will that turns away from God, not from God. [3] [4]
In Orthodox theology, freedom is the capacity to grow toward the good in communion with God, and God's respect for it is part of His love.
St Athanasius teaches that human beings are made in God's image with reason and free will, and that the incarnation is God's way of restoring them from within without overriding them. [5]
The question is philosophical and theological rather than historical. The Scriptures cited show what the Jewish and Christian traditions have always taught about human responsibility.
In Scripture
Sirach 15:11–20
King James Version
11 Say not thou, It is through the Lord that I fell away: for thou oughtest not to do the things that he hateth.
12 Say not thou, He hath caused me to err: for he hath no need of the sinful man.
13 The Lord hateth all abomination; and they that fear God love it not.
14 He himself made man from the beginning, and left him in the hand of his counsel;
15 If thou wilt, to keep the commandments, and to perform acceptable faithfulness.
16 He hath set fire and water before thee: stretch forth thy hand unto whether thou wilt.
17 Before man is life and death; and whether him liketh shall be given him.
18 For the wisdom of the Lord is great, and he is mighty in power, and beholdeth all things:
19 And his eyes are upon them that fear him, and he knoweth every work of man.
20 He hath commanded no man to do wickedly, neither hath he given any man licence to sin.
James 1:13–15
King James Version
13 Let no man say when he is tempted, I am tempted of God: for God cannot be tempted with evil, neither tempteth he any man:
14 But every man is tempted, when he is drawn away of his own lust, and enticed.
15 Then when lust hath conceived, it bringeth forth sin: and sin, when it is finished, bringeth forth death.
What the Church teaches
The Church teaches that God made human beings in his image with reason and a free will, and that love, being free, cannot be forced. The fall is the misuse of that freedom, and its result is death and a damaged world. God does not abandon the human being to the result. He comes in the incarnation to restore the image from within, and works in a way that calls for human cooperation, in repentance, in the sacraments and in the struggle for the good, without overriding the will.
The Church does not claim that this explains every evil, and it does not say that God wants the abuse of freedom. It says that God permits it and judges it, that he stands with its victims in the cross, and that the final word belongs to the resurrection. The Church also asks Christians to act: freedom is a call to stop harm where we can, and not only a reason why harm is allowed.
The Coptic Church holds the Alexandrian teaching that human beings have free will and that salvation is by grace with human cooperation. This is lived in the sacraments, in confession and repentance, and in the Church’s calling of its members to protect the weak. The Church’s refusal to treat suffering as always deserved is seen in its care for the sick and the poor, and in its remembrance of martyrs who were innocent victims of other people’s choices.
Objections answered
We do not think a parent should let one child attack another for the sake of the attacker’s freedom. Even if freedom is valuable, it is not worth the Holocaust or the abuse of a child. God could allow freedom and still intervene to stop the worst.
This is a serious objection, and the Church does not answer it by saying that the worst evils were worth it. A world in which God constantly stopped every serious harm would empty choice of its weight and remove the responsibility that makes love real. We also do not see how often God restrains evil unseen.
The deeper answer is the cross. God judges every act of evil, the freedom of the victim is never forgotten, and Christ has borne the worst that human beings can do. He will raise the dead and set every wrong right.
If the saints in heaven are free and never sin, then freedom does not require the possibility of sin, and God could have made us that way from the start.
Orthodox theology answers that freedom is not static. A human being is made able to grow in love and to become, by grace and by many acts of choice, fixed in the good. The saints' inability to sin is the fruit of a freedom exercised, not a lack of it.
A being created already complete would never have chosen that growth or freely returned God's love. The path through freedom is what makes the love of the saints their own.
Freedom is an illusion. Our choices are shaped by genes, upbringing and circumstance, so if there is no real freedom there is nothing for the defence to protect.
The Christian faith holds, with the Scriptures, that people are truly responsible for what they do. Our everyday experience of deliberating and being answerable for our choices is real evidence of that freedom.
The objection also undercuts itself. If there is no real freedom, then there are no real wrongs and no one to blame, and the moral outrage behind the objection loses its footing.
Conclusion
Freedom explains why a good God permits wrongdoing: love that is free can also be refused. Suffering that no human chose belongs to a creation wounded by the fall. And the final answer is Christ, who entered our suffering, bore it on the cross, and will raise the dead and make all things new.
Sources
- God, Freedom, and Evil · Alvin Plantinga
- The Problem of Evil · Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy · whole entry (logical and evidential versions of the problem; section not cited)
- Sirach 15:11–20
- James 1:13–15
- On the Incarnation · Athanasius of Alexandria · On the Incarnation 3-5 and 54
No inbox has been set up yet, so nothing is sent. This copies a short report with the page address and revision for you to pass on.