Orthodoxia

Faith & Evidence / God’s character, relevance, evil and hiddenness

What is the difference between moral evil and natural suffering?

IntermediatePhilosophicalAnswer available

Revision 1, updated

The answer

Moral evil is suffering caused by the wrong choices of people: cruelty, war, theft, abuse. Natural suffering comes from processes with no human choice behind them: earthquakes, floods, disease, the pain of animals. The distinction helps us answer each rightly. Moral evil comes from the misuse of freedom, which God gave because love must be free. Natural suffering belongs to a creation that, as St Paul the Apostle teaches, groans because of humanity’s turning from God and waits to be set free. God does not leave either kind unanswered: in Christ He enters our suffering, defeats death by His resurrection, and promises to make all things new.

  • Moral evil comes from the wrong choices of free agents; natural suffering comes from nature and has no human wrongdoer behind it.
  • Freedom answers moral evil: God made creatures able to love, and so able to refuse.
  • Natural suffering belongs to a creation that, in the Church’s faith, shares in the consequences of humanity’s turning from God and awaits renewal (Romans 8).
  • Many cases are mixed: how many die in a disaster often depends on poverty, building choices and warnings unheeded, so the call to help is part of the answer.
  • The Lord teaches that those who suffer disaster are not worse sinners than others (Luke 13), and His resurrection is the beginning of creation’s renewal.

Why this question matters

People often talk past one another about suffering because they have different cases in mind. One is thinking of a murder; another of a child’s cancer. The first can be traced to a decision; the second cannot. An answer suited to one can sound hollow about the other.

Separating them lets the Christian answer each with the right words: freedom and responsibility for the first, the groaning of creation and the hope of its renewal for the second, and Christ’s cross and resurrection for both.

In the standard treatment, moral evil is evil that results from the free actions of agents who could have done otherwise; natural evil is suffering that results from natural processes such as disease, earthquakes and predation. The Stanford Encyclopedia entry on the problem of evil (S42) uses the distinction in setting out the main replies and the objections to them.

The free-will defence, developed by Alvin Plantinga (S40, cited as a whole work), is aimed at the logical problem and works most plainly for moral evil. For natural evil, defenders have proposed several lines: that the regularity of nature is a condition for rational action and for moral growth; that creation participates in the consequences of human turning from God, as the Bible teaches; and that some natural evils may be due to created beings other than humans who also have freedom.

Terms used

  • Resurrection: In Christian teaching, Jesus’ bodily rising from the dead to a transformed life. It is a different claim from the claim that his followers came to believe it.
  • Crucifixion: A Roman method of execution by fixing a person to a cross or stake.
  • Theism: The view that there is one personal God who made and sustains the world.
  • Theodicy: An attempt to explain why a good God permits evil and suffering.

The evidence

Moral evil (harm done by free agents) and natural suffering (harm from natural processes) are conceptually distinct, and the distinction is standard in discussion of the problem of evil.

The distinction organises the standard reference treatment of the problem (S42). It is a clear tool that lets each kind of suffering receive its proper answer. [1]

Freedom answers moral evil directly; natural suffering needs the fuller Christian account of creation, fall and renewal.

The free-will defence appeals to the value of free, responsible creatures, and so shows why God permits the abuse of freedom. Plantinga’s work (S40) is the standard statement. Natural events involve no abuse of freedom, so the Christian answer to them rests on the regular order of creation and on the Bible’s teaching about a creation that groans and awaits renewal. [2] [1]

The Bible presents creation as good in its origin, as affected by human turning from God, and as awaiting renewal; it does not treat nature’s hardships as a simple punishment of the people who suffer them.

Genesis calls creation very good and then tells of the ground cursed after the man’s disobedience; St Paul the Apostle says creation groans and waits to be freed from decay; and the Lord Himself refuses to read a disaster as proof of the victims’ guilt. Together these give a clear picture: hardship is not original, it is bound up with humanity’s fall, and it is not the last word. [3] [4] [5]

Orthodox theology sees created nature as dependent on God and prone to dissolution when separated from him, and sees Christ’s work as renewing nature itself.

St Athanasius teaches that creatures were made from nothing and are held in being by the Word, that turning from God brought corruption, and that the incarnation renews what had fallen into corruption. Christ heals not only souls but nature itself. [6]

This question is about meaning rather than historical events. What history does show is how the Lord taught about disaster: asked about victims of violence and of a falling tower, He refused to call them worse sinners and turned His hearers to repentance (Luke 13). How the fall relates to the long history of life is treated in the articles on creation and evolution.

In Scripture

Genesis 3:17–19

King James Version

17 And unto Adam he said, Because thou hast hearkened unto the voice of thy wife, and hast eaten of the tree, of which I commanded thee, saying, Thou shalt not eat of it: cursed is the ground for thy sake; in sorrow shalt thou eat of it all the days of thy life;

18 Thorns also and thistles shall it bring forth to thee; and thou shalt eat the herb of the field;

19 In the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat bread, till thou return unto the ground; for out of it wast thou taken: for dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return.

Romans 8:18–25

King James Version

18 For I reckon that the sufferings of this present time are not worthy to be compared with the glory which shall be revealed in us.

19 For the earnest expectation of the creature waiteth for the manifestation of the sons of God.

20 For the creature was made subject to vanity, not willingly, but by reason of him who hath subjected the same in hope,

21 Because the creature itself also shall be delivered from the bondage of corruption into the glorious liberty of the children of God.

22 For we know that the whole creation groaneth and travaileth in pain together until now.

23 And not only they, but ourselves also, which have the firstfruits of the Spirit, even we ourselves groan within ourselves, waiting for the adoption, to wit, the redemption of our body.

24 For we are saved by hope: but hope that is seen is not hope: for what a man seeth, why doth he yet hope for?

25 But if we hope for that we see not, then do we with patience wait for it.

Luke 13:1–5

King James Version

1 There were present at that season some that told him of the Galilæans, whose blood Pilate had mingled with their sacrifices.

2 And Jesus answering said unto them, Suppose ye that these Galilæans were sinners above all the Galilæans, because they suffered such things?

3 I tell you, Nay: but, except ye repent, ye shall all likewise perish.

4 Or those eighteen, upon whom the tower in Siloam fell, and slew them, think ye that they were sinners above all men that dwelt in Jerusalem?

5 I tell you, Nay: but, except ye repent, ye shall all likewise perish.

What the Church teaches

The Church confesses that God made all things good, that human beings were made to care for creation and to bring it to him, and that the turning away of human beings brought death and disorder into the world. Creation is therefore seen as bound up with human beings, groaning with them and to be renewed with them. In Christ, who took a human body and a human nature, creation itself is joined to God, and the resurrection is the beginning of its renewal.

The Church therefore does not say that natural suffering is deserved or that it is secretly good. It calls death an enemy and prays for the sick, for the harvest and for the waters of the earth, and it looks for the day when God will make all things new.

The Coptic liturgy keeps creation inside prayer. The Church prays for the waters of the river, the plants of the field and the fruits of the earth, for the good order of the seasons, and for the sick, and it asks God to turn away what harms. This is how the tradition lives the distinction: it does not treat nature as an enemy to be explained away, nor as a thing indifferent to God, but as part of what God made and will renew.

Objections answered

Natural suffering predates human beings. Animals suffered and died long before there were humans to fall. Blaming nature’s pain on human sin is absurd, and the distinction only moves the problem.

The Church does not teach that each animal’s pain is a punishment for a human sin. It teaches that all creation is bound up with humanity, made to be offered to God through us, and that humanity’s turning from God is felt throughout creation. St Paul the Apostle says that creation was subjected to futility in hope and groans as it waits for freedom. The Church has not tied this faith to one scientific timeline.

The heart of the answer is not a timeline but a promise. Nature’s hardship belongs to a creation that is not yet what God will make it, and Christ, risen in the body, is the firstfruits of its renewal.

[4] [3]

God could have given us a world with the freedom to choose but with nature that does not kill. A world with fewer diseases and earthquakes would have lost nothing that matters.

A world in which nature continually bent to prevent harm would be a world in which no one could foresee the effects of an action, so choices would carry no real weight. Regular laws are the condition of knowledge, skill, responsibility and love in action. We are not in a position to say how much hardship could be removed without losing these goods.

Above all, the Christian does not claim that this present world is the final one. God has promised a new creation without death or tears, and in the risen Christ that promise has already begun.

[1] [2]

The distinction is too neat. Most disasters have human causes: poor building, poverty, neglect. Calling something “natural” hides human responsibility, and calling it “moral” hides the unfairness of luck.

This is true, and it is why the distinction is a tool and not a verdict. The Lord Himself refuses to blame the victims of the falling tower, and the Christian reading of disaster includes the duty of all who are able to help, to prepare and to relieve.

Even where the lines blur, the two ends remain: a deliberate act of cruelty and an illness with no one to blame differ in kind, and each receives its own answer.

[5]

Conclusion

Moral evil and natural suffering are different, and the Christian faith answers both. Moral evil comes from the misuse of the freedom God gave so that we could love. Natural suffering belongs to a creation that groans with fallen humanity and waits to be set free. Neither is the last word: Christ has entered our suffering, risen from the dead, and will make all things new.

Sources

↑↓ move↵ openEsc close