Faith & Evidence / Moral and comparative questions
Does explaining historical context morally justify a practice?
The answer
No. Explaining why a practice existed tells us what it was and why people did it; it does not make it right. But context is still needed to judge a text fairly: it shows who was addressed, what the law replaced, and whether a law was limiting an evil or commanding it. The Church reads Scripture as a revelation given in stages that reaches its fullness in Christ. The Lord Himself teaches this when He says that Moses permitted divorce because of hardness of heart, though from the beginning it was not so. So the Church can say plainly that some laws were concessions, not ideals, and it judges every earlier law by Christ, in whom God’s goodness is fully shown.
- Explanation answers “why did this happen?”; justification answers “was it right?”. They are different questions.
- Context matters for fairness: it shows what a law replaced, whom it addressed, and whether it limited or commanded a harm.
- Using context as a full defence is an error; ignoring context is also an error, because it judges a distant text as if it were a modern one.
- Some things are wrong in every age. The Church does not call a practice good simply because it appears in Scripture.
- Revelation is given in stages and measured by Christ, so the Church can call some laws concessions and not ideals.
- A good teacher meets people where they are and leads them on. That is how God dealt with Israel, and Christ shows where He was leading.
Why this question matters
Almost every discussion of a hard text reaches the same point: explaining is not excusing. That is true, and a Christian should be able to meet it clearly, not merely repeat the background again.
It is also a question of honesty. The Christian does not answer every hard text by saying that it belongs to its time. Christ gives a standard, and by that standard the Church can say what fell short of God’s intention.
Philosophers distinguish explanation from justification. A historian explains why a ruler ordered a massacre by giving his motives and circumstances; the explanation does not make the massacre right. The same holds for religious law. To say that a law reflects the assumptions of its age answers “why was it written this way?” It leaves open “is it good?”.
There is a second distinction, between moral relativism and fairness in judging. A person can hold that some acts are wrong in every age and still think that someone living in a different age, with different knowledge and constraints, may be blamed less or differently. The Church’s approach to the Old Testament depends on this: it can say that a law fell short of God’s intention without saying that those who lived under it were monsters.
Finally, the question depends on what one thinks Scripture is. If it is a collection of human texts only, then moral imperfection in some of them is unsurprising and creates no theological problem. If it is believed to be inspired, the believer owes an account of how inspired texts can contain laws that the Gospel overrides. This article gives the Church’s account.
Terms used
- Theodicy: An attempt to explain why a good God permits evil and suffering.
- Tradition: In the Orthodox understanding, the Church’s lived and handed-on faith, within which Scripture is read.
- Typology: Reading a person or event in the Old Testament as foreshadowing something in Christ. It is a way of reading, not a prediction in the narrow sense.
- Inspiration: The Christian belief that God worked through the human authors of Scripture. It is a theological claim, distinct from the preservation of manuscripts.
The evidence
Explaining the historical context of a practice does not make the practice morally right.
A historical account says why something happened; a moral judgement says whether it was right. Treating context as a full answer to a moral objection confuses the two, and the Lord Himself keeps them apart when He separates what Moses permitted from what God intended. [1]
Context is still needed to judge a law fairly: it shows whether the law limited an existing harm or created one, and what its first hearers understood by it.
The Old Testament gives clear examples. The rule of equal retribution set a limit on vengeance, and the Lord treats the law about divorce as a concession. In both, the setting shows what the law was doing. [1] [2]
Scripture records a revelation given in stages and measured by Christ, so that some of its laws are concessions and not the ideal will of God.
The opening of Hebrews says that God spoke in many parts and ways before speaking in a Son, and in the Sermon on the Mount the Lord sets His teaching beside what was said to those of old. Scripture itself teaches us to read the earlier law in stages. [3] [1]
The texts themselves show the pattern: some laws restrain and others permit; the Lord distinguishes concession from God’s intention; and the early Church did not adopt Israel’s civil and penal law as its own code.
In Scripture
Matthew 19:3–9
King James Version
3 ¶ The Pharisees also came unto him, tempting him, and saying unto him, Is it lawful for a man to put away his wife for every cause?
4 And he answered and said unto them, Have ye not read, that he which made them at the beginning made them male and female,
5 And said, For this cause shall a man leave father and mother, and shall cleave to his wife: and they twain shall be one flesh?
6 Wherefore they are no more twain, but one flesh. What therefore God hath joined together, let not man put asunder.
7 They say unto him, Why did Moses then command to give a writing of divorcement, and to put her away?
8 He saith unto them, Moses because of the hardness of your hearts suffered you to put away your wives: but from the beginning it was not so.
9 And I say unto you, Whosoever shall put away his wife, except it be for fornication, and shall marry another, committeth adultery: and whoso marrieth her which is put away doth commit adultery.
Leviticus 24:19–20
King James Version
19 And if a man cause a blemish in his neighbour; as he hath done, so shall it be done to him;
20 Breach for breach, eye for eye, tooth for tooth: as he hath caused a blemish in a man, so shall it be done to him again.
Hebrews 1:1–2
King James Version
1 God, who at sundry times and in divers manners spake in time past unto the fathers by the prophets,
2 Hath in these last days spoken unto us by his Son, whom he hath appointed heir of all things, by whom also he made the worlds;
What the Church teaches
The Church confesses that God is good, and that his goodness is fully shown in Christ. It therefore reads the earlier laws in the light of him, and it will not call a practice good because it appears in Scripture. It will say that the practice belongs to a stage, that the stage was addressed to people as they were, and that the Gospel brings what the earlier stage pointed to.
The Church does not pretend that the hard texts are easy, and it expects its members to say plainly that some things done in the name of Scripture were wrong.
Objections answered
If God is perfect, his law should have been perfect from the start. Talking of stages and concessions is an admission that the law was made by people and attributed to God.
A teacher who meets people where they are and leads them on is not imperfect for doing so; that is what perfect teaching looks like. The Lord Himself describes the law of Moses in this way when He speaks of hardness of heart.
The law was perfect for its purpose: to guard Israel, restrain evil and prepare for Christ. The staged character of revelation is not a sign of human invention but of divine patience, which leads a people step by step to the fullness revealed in the Son.
Moral standards have changed, so an appeal to “progressive revelation” is just a way of renaming moral change and giving it a religious label after the fact.
The direction can be seen in the texts themselves, not imposed afterwards: the limits on vengeance, the protection of the stranger and the fugitive, the prophets’ criticism of oppression, and finally the teaching of Christ, who names the earlier law a concession. That line runs through Scripture before any modern change in morals.
The Church does not say that moral progress is automatic. Its own history includes long periods in which it failed to follow what it taught, and that failure is judged by the same Christ.
If historical context may excuse the Bible, the same excuse is available to any religion for any practice. The principle proves too much.
That would be true if context were used as an excuse. The claim here is the reverse: context explains and does not justify. What the Church adds is a standard, Christ, by which the earlier law is judged, and that standard is open to examination by anyone.
The same fairness is owed to others: every tradition should be judged on what its adherents hold, by a standard that is stated openly and applied equally.
Conclusion
Explaining a practice is not justifying it, and context alone answers no moral objection. Context still matters for judging fairly. The Church reads Scripture as revelation given in stages and fulfilled in Christ, as the Lord Himself taught. So it can call some laws concessions and refuse to call them ideals, and it measures every law by Christ, in whom God’s goodness is fully revealed.
Sources
No inbox has been set up yet, so nothing is sent. This copies a short report with the page address and revision for you to pass on.