Faith & Evidence / Moral and comparative questions
Does Christian hypocrisy disprove Christian claims?
The answer
The failures of Christians are real, sometimes grave, and the Church does not excuse them. Christians have persecuted others, used the faith to defend cruelty, protected the guilty and ignored the poor. But the sins of believers do not make the Gospel false. Christ Himself condemned hypocrisy more sharply than anyone, and foretold that some who called Him Lord would not do His will; hypocrites prove His warning, not that He was wrong. The truth of the faith rests on who Jesus is and on His resurrection. The failures call Christians to humility and repentance, and they invite everyone who is searching to look at Christ Himself, whose life is the standard and whose mercy is the hope of all who fall short.
- The objection is partly right: Christians have often failed to live as they teach, and some have done grave harm in the name of the faith.
- Jesus himself condemned hypocrisy and warned that some who call him Lord would not be known by him; the standard condemns those who fall short of it.
- The behaviour of believers is evidence about believers. It is not direct evidence about whether the central Christian claims, about Jesus, are true.
- The New Testament says openly that the first Christians were sinners, and a name brought into disrepute by their conduct: St Paul rebuked St Peter, and he told others that the name of God was blasphemed because of them.
- The same history is full of Christians who gave their lives in care of the poor, the sick and the persecuted; that too is the fruit of the Gospel.
- The right response to the failures is repentance and a better life, not denial and not despair.
Why this question matters
For many people this is not an argument but a wound. They have been hurt by someone who spoke for the Church, or by a congregation that put its reputation before a victim, or by a relative whose religion made him harder to live with. A reply that begins by defending the Church would be another injury.
It is also one of the most common reasons given for leaving, or never approaching, the faith. The answer therefore begins by admitting that the charge is often true, and then shows why Christ is still worth coming to.
The failures are not hard to name. Christians took part in the persecution of Jews and of other Christians, in religious wars, in the slave trade, in the abuse of children and the concealment of that abuse, and in countless smaller acts of cruelty and neglect. Churches have chosen to protect their name over the vulnerable. These facts should not be softened. The Coptic Church knows from its own history that Christians have persecuted Christians, since for long periods before the Arab conquest Egypt’s non-Chalcedonian Christians suffered at the hands of the imperial Church, and it also has to look at the faults of its own people.
The New Testament itself records failure. Jesus condemns the hypocrisy of religious leaders, and warns that not everyone who says Lord, Lord will enter the kingdom. St Paul tells of rebuking St Peter for acting against the truth of the Gospel, and writes that the name of God is blasphemed among the Gentiles because of the conduct of those who claim to know him. The letter of James says that faith without works is dead. The movement expected its members to fail and told them how to respond.
Outside observers noticed the other side too. Pliny, a Roman governor writing about 110 AD, reports that Christians bound themselves to avoid theft, fraud and adultery, and Justin Martyr describes a community that gathered gifts for orphans, widows, the sick and prisoners. The standard they held themselves to was high and was known to outsiders, which is part of why failures to meet it seem so grievous.
Terms used
- Apologetics: The reasoned defence and explanation of a belief. It offers arguments and evidence for examination; it does not replace faith or guarantee agreement.
- Primary source: A text or object from the period being studied, such as an ancient letter, a manuscript or an inscription.
- Resurrection: In Christian teaching, Jesus’ bodily rising from the dead to a transformed life. It is a different claim from the claim that his followers came to believe it.
- Tradition: In the Orthodox understanding, the Church’s lived and handed-on faith, within which Scripture is read.
The evidence
Christians, individually and as churches, have failed to live by their teaching and have at times done serious harm in the name of their faith; the Church does not deny this.
The failures are recorded in the New Testament itself and in the whole history of the Church. They are matters of public record and not of one side’s accusation. [3] [4] [1]
The failure of believers to live up to a teaching does not show that the teaching is false; the truth of the central Christian claims depends on the evidence about Jesus and not on the conduct of his followers.
The truth of a claim is separate from the character of those who hold it. A doctor who smokes does not make the danger of smoking false. Christ Himself said that false prophets would be known by their fruit and that not everyone who says "Lord, Lord" will enter the kingdom; and St James teaches that faith without works is dead. The Gospel itself judges the hypocrite. [2] [5]
The Christian movement was marked from its beginning by a high moral standard and by care for the poor, as observers outside it noticed, so the failures are failures against a standard that Christians set for themselves.
Pliny, a Roman governor examining Christians about AD 110, reports that they bound themselves by oath to avoid theft, fraud and adultery. St Justin Martyr describes the Sunday collection given to orphans, widows, the sick, prisoners and strangers. From the start, outsiders and insiders alike saw a community committed to a high standard and to the care of the needy. [6] [7]
The New Testament records failure honestly within the first generation, even among the apostles, and keeps it in Scripture. Outside observers in the second century record a high standard of conduct and a practice of care for the needy. Later centuries record great wrongs, and also hospitals, schools, relief of the poor and costly witness unto death. The same faith that its followers betrayed is the faith that judged their betrayal and inspired the good.
In Scripture
Matthew 23:1–3
King James Version
1 Then spake Jesus to the multitude, and to his disciples,
2 Saying, The scribes and the Pharisees sit in Moses’ seat:
3 All therefore whatsoever they bid you observe, that observe and do; but do not ye after their works: for they say, and do not.
Matthew 7:15–23
King James Version
15 ¶ Beware of false prophets, which come to you in sheep’s clothing, but inwardly they are ravening wolves.
16 Ye shall know them by their fruits. Do men gather grapes of thorns, or figs of thistles?
17 Even so every good tree bringeth forth good fruit; but a corrupt tree bringeth forth evil fruit.
18 A good tree cannot bring forth evil fruit, neither can a corrupt tree bring forth good fruit.
19 Every tree that bringeth not forth good fruit is hewn down, and cast into the fire.
20 Wherefore by their fruits ye shall know them.
21 ¶ Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the kingdom of heaven; but he that doeth the will of my Father which is in heaven.
22 Many will say to me in that day, Lord, Lord, have we not prophesied in thy name? and in thy name have cast out devils? and in thy name done many wonderful works?
23 And then will I profess unto them, I never knew you: depart from me, ye that work iniquity.
Galatians 2:11–14
King James Version
11 But when Peter was come to Antioch, I withstood him to the face, because he was to be blamed.
12 For before that certain came from James, he did eat with the Gentiles: but when they were come, he withdrew and separated himself, fearing them which were of the circumcision.
13 And the other Jews dissembled likewise with him; insomuch that Barnabas also was carried away with their dissimulation.
14 But when I saw that they walked not uprightly according to the truth of the gospel, I said unto Peter before them all, If thou, being a Jew, livest after the manner of Gentiles, and not as do the Jews, why compellest thou the Gentiles to live as do the Jews?
Romans 2:21–24
King James Version
21 Thou therefore which teachest another, teachest thou not thyself? thou that preachest a man should not steal, dost thou steal?
22 Thou that sayest a man should not commit adultery, dost thou commit adultery? thou that abhorrest idols, dost thou commit sacrilege?
23 Thou that makest thy boast of the law, through breaking the law dishonourest thou God?
24 For the name of God is blasphemed among the Gentiles through you, as it is written.
James 2:14–17
King James Version
14 What doth it profit, my brethren, though a man say he hath faith, and have not works? can faith save him?
15 If a brother or sister be naked, and destitute of daily food,
16 And one of you say unto them, Depart in peace, be ye warmed and filled; notwithstanding ye give them not those things which are needful to the body; what doth it profit?
17 Even so faith, if it hath not works, is dead, being alone.
What the Church teaches
The Church confesses that Christ came for sinners, that the Church is made up of sinners being healed, and that the holiness of the Church is Christ’s and not its members’. Every liturgy begins with the confession of sin, and the Church prays that God will forgive the sins of his people. It does not claim that Christians are better than others. It claims that they have a Saviour.
For that reason the right answer to the hypocrisy of Christians is not to defend it and not to leave. It is to repent, to make restitution where wrong has been done, to care for those who have been hurt, and to look again at Christ, whose life is the standard and whose mercy is the hope of those who fall short of it.
The Coptic Church has the practice of confession and of the Liturgy’s repeated prayers of repentance, in which the congregation says that it has sinned before God. The tradition of the desert Fathers placed the monk’s own failures at the centre of his attention, and taught that to judge another is a worse fault than the one he is judged for. These are the Church’s own resources for facing hypocrisy.
The Church also knows persecution, and the ordinary Copt’s faithfulness under pressure over fourteen centuries is part of its testimony. It does not use that to avoid the question, but it is part of the honest picture.
Objections answered
Christianity claims to transform people through the Holy Spirit and the sacraments. If the transformation is not visible in the lives of Christians, the claim is empty, and the faith has failed by its own test.
It is right to ask a faith that claims to change people for evidence of change. The change is real but gradual. The Church is a hospital for sinners, not a gathering of the finished. She expects struggle, falls and repentance, and repentance itself is part of the change.
And the evidence of transformation is everywhere in her history: saints, martyrs and monks, ordinary people whose lives were turned around, and long traditions of care for the poor and the sick that grew out of Christian communities. Many who came to Christ broken have been made whole. The failures are real, but so is the healing.
The worst failures were not individual lapses but done by the Church as an institution, with the support of its leaders and in the name of God. It cannot be said that these were just bad Christians.
The Church does not use the phrase “not true Christians” to dismiss the cases. Leaders and institutions have done wrong, and where this is so the Church must say it plainly, make what restitution it can and change.
The Church is both the body of Christ and a gathering of sinners being healed; her holiness comes from Christ and not from her members. That does not excuse any institution, which remains responsible for what it did. It means that the wrongs of Christians are judged by Christ Himself, and that He remains true when His people fail.
If Christians are no better than anyone else, there is no reason to think Christianity is true, since a true religion ought to produce better people.
The inference does not follow. A true medicine does not cure those who do not take it, and the Church claims that grace works with a person’s free response. It would be a mistake to take the average conduct of nominal members as the measure of the faith.
The Church does not rest its case on the moral record of Christians. It rests it on who Jesus is and on his resurrection, which is a different kind of claim, and the Church asks that it be examined on its own evidence.
Conclusion
The failures of Christians are real, and the Church names them and repents of them. They do not change who Jesus is: the truth of the Gospel rests on Him and on His resurrection, not on the conduct of His followers, and He Himself foretold that some who profess Him would not live by Him. Christians do not claim to be better than others; they claim to have a Saviour. Look at Him, and you will find both the standard that judges our failures and the mercy that heals them.
Sources
- Matthew 23:1–3
- Matthew 7:15–23
- Galatians 2:11–14
- Romans 2:21–24
- James 2:14–17
- Pliny the Younger and Trajan, Letters 10.96–97 (Fordham Internet Ancient History Sourcebook) · Pliny the Younger; Trajan · Letters 10.96
- First Apology · Justin Martyr · First Apology 67
No inbox has been set up yet, so nothing is sent. This copies a short report with the page address and revision for you to pass on.